Algebraic elements and minimal polynomials
The number \displaystyle \sqrt{7} - \sqrt{3} is a root of many polynomials with rational coefficients, and \pi is a root of none. Which polynomial best describes a number, how do the others relate to it, and are sums and products of such numbers again such numbers?
Where you are 5 in Fields
Why this exists
Field extensions and degree measured F(\alpha) once \alpha was known to be a root of an irreducible polynomial over F. Three questions remain. Is a given element a root of any nonzero polynomial over F? If so, which of the infinitely many is the right one? And do such elements form a field, so that \displaystyle \sqrt{2} + \sqrt[3]{5} needs no separate argument? The answers carry the rest of the unit, from Splitting fields to Compass-and-straightedge constructions, and why an angle cannot be trisected.
Definition
In plain words: an element is algebraic when some nonzero polynomial over the smaller field kills it, and its minimal polynomial is the monic one of least degree that does.
Let E/F be a field extension.
- An element \alpha \in E is algebraic over F if g(\alpha) = 0 for some nonzero g \in F[x], and transcendental over F otherwise. A complex number algebraic over \mathbb{Q} is an algebraic number; their set is \overline{\mathbb{Q}}. A complex number transcendental over \mathbb{Q} is a transcendental number.
- The extension E/F is algebraic if every element of E is algebraic over F.
- If \alpha is algebraic over F, its minimal polynomial m_\alpha(x), or m_{\alpha, F}(x), is the monic polynomial of least degree in F[x] with \alpha as a root (it exists and is unique by Theorem 1). Its degree is the degree of \alpha over F. The roots of m_\alpha in a field containing all of them are the conjugates of \alpha over F.
- The set of elements of E algebraic over F is the algebraic closure of F in E. A field K is algebraically closed if every nonconstant polynomial in K[x] has a root in K.
For example, c \in F has m_c = x - c, and i has minimal polynomial x^2 + 1 over \mathbb{R} but x - i over \mathbb{C}. In the field F(t) of rational functions, t is transcendental over F (Exercise 13 of Field extensions and degree).
Intuition
An algebraic element is tied down: some power of it is an F-combination of lower powers, so everything built from it has finitely many coordinates. A transcendental element is free, like the indeterminate x. The minimal polynomial is the one relation every other follows from; a larger base field can only shorten it (Example 2).
Results
Throughout, E/F is a field extension.
Theorem 1 (the minimal polynomial). Let \alpha \in E be algebraic over F. Then: (a) there is exactly one monic polynomial m_\alpha of least degree in F[x] with m_\alpha(\alpha) = 0; (b) m_\alpha is irreducible in F[x]; (c) for g \in F[x], g(\alpha) = 0 if and only if m_\alpha \mid g; (d) every monic irreducible p \in F[x] with p(\alpha) = 0 equals m_\alpha; (e) F[\alpha] = F(\alpha), and if \deg m_\alpha = n, then (1, \alpha, \dots, \alpha^{n-1}) is a basis of F(\alpha) over F and [F(\alpha) : F] = n.
Theorem 2 (transcendental elements). Let \alpha \in E be transcendental over F. Then: (a) g \mapsto g(\alpha) is a ring isomorphism F[x] \to F[\alpha]; (b) F(\alpha) is the set of quotients g(\alpha)/h(\alpha) with g, h \in F[x], h \ne 0, and two are equal, g(\alpha)/h(\alpha) = g_1(\alpha)/h_1(\alpha), if and only if gh_1 = g_1h; so F(\alpha) is a copy of the rational function field F(t); (c) [F(\alpha) : F] is infinite and \alpha^{-1} \notin F[\alpha].
Theorem 3 (three tests). For \alpha \in E the following are equivalent: (i) \alpha is algebraic over F; (ii) [F(\alpha) : F] is finite; (iii) F[\alpha] is a field.
Theorem 4 (finite implies algebraic). If [E : F] = n is finite, every \alpha \in E is algebraic over F, of degree dividing n.
Theorem 5 (changing the base field). Let F \subseteq K \subseteq E and \alpha \in E algebraic over F. Then \alpha is algebraic over K, m_{\alpha, K} divides m_{\alpha, F} in K[x], and [K(\alpha) : K] \le [F(\alpha) : F].
Corollary 6 (finite generation). If \alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_k \in E are algebraic over F of degrees d_1, \dots, d_k, then F(\alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_k)/F is finite of degree at most d_1 d_2 \cdots d_k. Conversely, every finite extension E/F is F(\alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_k) for finitely many \alpha_i algebraic over F.
Theorem 7 (the algebraic elements form a field). The algebraic closure L of F in E is a subfield of E containing F, and L/F is algebraic. In particular \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is a subfield of \mathbb{C}.
Theorem 8 (transitivity). Let F \subseteq K \subseteq E with K/F algebraic. If \alpha \in E is algebraic over K, it is algebraic over F. Hence if E/K and K/F are algebraic, so is E/F.
Corollary 9. \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is algebraically closed.
Theorem 10 (counting). \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is countable and \mathbb{C} \setminus \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is uncountable, so transcendental numbers exist. And [\overline{\mathbb{Q}} : \mathbb{Q}] is infinite: an algebraic extension need not be finite.
Stated without proof: e is transcendental (Hermite, 1873), and so is \pi (Lindemann, 1882); the proofs are analytic and beyond this course. Every field F has an algebraic closure, an algebraically closed algebraic extension, unique up to an isomorphism fixing F; the proof uses Zorn’s lemma and is beyond this course (Dummit and Foote, Section 13.4).
Why it is true
“Theorem k there” means Theorem k of Field extensions and degree.
Proof of Theorem 1. Let J = \{g \in F[x] : g(\alpha) = 0\}. It contains a nonzero polynomial and no nonzero constant; let n \ge 1 be the least degree of a nonzero element, and scale one to a monic m \in J of degree n. (c) For g \in J, the division algorithm (Polynomial long division) gives g = qm + r with r = 0 or \deg r < n, and r(\alpha) = g(\alpha) - q(\alpha)m(\alpha) = 0, so minimality forces r = 0. Conversely m \mid g gives g(\alpha) = 0. (a) Another monic m_1 \in J of degree n is a multiple of m by (c), of the same degree, so a constant times m, and the constant is 1. Write m_\alpha = m. (b) If m_\alpha = gh with \deg g, \deg h < n, then g(\alpha)h(\alpha) = 0 in the field E, so g or h lies in J, against minimality. (d) By (c), m_\alpha \mid p; p is irreducible and m_\alpha is not constant, so p = cm_\alpha with c \in F, and c = 1 as both are monic. (e) Theorem 5 there, applied to the irreducible m_\alpha. \square
Proof of Theorem 2. (a) The map is a ring homomorphism onto F[\alpha] with kernel \{0\}, as \alpha is transcendental. (b) For h \ne 0, h(\alpha) \ne 0 by (a). The quotients are closed under sums, differences and products by the rules for fractions, and a nonzero g(\alpha)/h(\alpha) has inverse h(\alpha)/g(\alpha). So they form a subfield containing F and \alpha, contained in every such subfield: they are F(\alpha). And g(\alpha)/h(\alpha) = g_1(\alpha)/h_1(\alpha) means (gh_1 - g_1h)(\alpha) = 0, that is gh_1 = g_1h. (c) A relation c_0 + c_1\alpha + \dots + c_k\alpha^k = 0 is a polynomial killing \alpha, so all c_j = 0: (1, \alpha, \dots, \alpha^k) is independent for every k, impossible in a space of finite dimension (Bases and dimension, proved). If \alpha^{-1} = g(\alpha), then xg(x) - 1, with constant term -1, is a nonzero polynomial killing \alpha. \square
Proof of Theorem 3. (i) gives (ii) and (iii) by Theorem 1(e). If \alpha is transcendental, Theorem 2(c) makes [F(\alpha) : F] infinite and leaves \alpha \ne 0 without an inverse in F[\alpha]. \square
Proof of Theorem 4. The n + 1 elements 1, \alpha, \dots, \alpha^n of the n-dimensional space E are dependent (Bases and dimension, proved): c_0 + c_1\alpha + \dots + c_n\alpha^n = 0 with some c_j \ne 0. The degree [F(\alpha) : F] (Theorem 1(e)) divides [E : F] by the tower law (Corollary 7(a) there). \square
Proof of Theorem 5. m_{\alpha, F} \in F[x] \subseteq K[x] is nonzero and kills \alpha, so Theorem 1(c) over K gives m_{\alpha, K} \mid m_{\alpha, F}; compare degrees with Theorem 1(e). \square
Proof of Corollary 6. Let K_0 = F and K_i = F(\alpha_1, \dots, \alpha_i) = K_{i-1}(\alpha_i) (Lemma 2 there). By Theorem 5, [K_i : K_{i-1}] \le d_i; the tower law and Proof by induction give [K_k : F] \le d_1 \cdots d_k. Conversely, a basis (e_1, \dots, e_n) of a finite E/F consists of algebraic elements (Theorem 4), and F(e_1, \dots, e_n) contains every F-combination of them, so it is E. \square
Proof of Theorem 7. Each c \in F is a root of x - c, so F \subseteq L. For \alpha, \beta \in L, F(\alpha, \beta) is finite over F (Corollary 6) and contains \alpha \pm \beta, \alpha\beta, and \alpha/\beta when \beta \ne 0; by Theorem 4 they are algebraic, so they lie in L. \square
Proof of Theorem 8. Write m_{\alpha, K} = x^n + c_{n-1}x^{n-1} + \dots + c_0 with c_j \in K and let L = F(c_0, \dots, c_{n-1}), finite over F by Corollary 6. As m_{\alpha, K} \in L[x], [L(\alpha) : L] \le n (Theorem 1), so [L(\alpha) : F] is finite by the tower law, and \alpha \in L(\alpha) is algebraic over F by Theorem 4. \square
Proof of Corollary 9. A nonconstant f \in \overline{\mathbb{Q}}[x] has a root \alpha \in \mathbb{C} by the The fundamental theorem of algebra. It is algebraic over \overline{\mathbb{Q}}, which is algebraic over \mathbb{Q} (Theorem 7), so \alpha is algebraic over \mathbb{Q} (Theorem 8): \alpha \in \overline{\mathbb{Q}}. \square
Proof of Theorem 10. Polynomials of degree at most d in \mathbb{Q}[x] correspond to their coefficient lists in \mathbb{Q}^{d+1}, a countable set, so \mathbb{Q}[x] is a countable union of countable sets, countable (Countable sets). A nonzero polynomial of degree d has at most d complex roots, by induction on d: a root c splits off x - c (The remainder and factor theorems), and as \mathbb{C} has no zero divisors every other root is a root of the quotient. So \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is a countable union of finite sets, countable. As \mathbb{C} is uncountable (Countable and uncountable sets), it is not the union of \overline{\mathbb{Q}} and a countable set.
For the degree: for n \ge 1, x^n - 2 is irreducible over \mathbb{Q} by Eisenstein’s criterion at 2 (Irreducible polynomials and Eisenstein's criterion), so \displaystyle \sqrt[n]{2} has degree n. A finite [\overline{\mathbb{Q}} : \mathbb{Q}] = d would, by Theorem 4 applied to \displaystyle \sqrt[d+1]{2}, be divisible by d + 1 > d, which is impossible. \square
Worked examples
The minimal polynomial of a difference of square roots
Let \displaystyle \alpha = \sqrt{7} - \sqrt{3}. Find m_\alpha over \mathbb{Q} and the conjugates of \alpha.
SolutionSquaring, \displaystyle \alpha^2 = 10 - 2\sqrt{21}, so (\alpha^2 - 10)^2 = 84 and \alpha is a root of p = x^4 - 20x^2 + 16. By Theorem 1(c), m_\alpha \mid p, so m_\alpha = p as soon as [\mathbb{Q}(\alpha) : \mathbb{Q}] = 4.
Since \displaystyle (\sqrt{7} - \sqrt{3})(\sqrt{7} + \sqrt{3}) = 4, \displaystyle \sqrt{7} + \sqrt{3} = 4/\alpha lies in \mathbb{Q}(\alpha), hence so do \displaystyle \sqrt{7} = \frac{1}{2}(4/\alpha + \alpha) and \displaystyle \sqrt{3} = \frac{1}{2}(4/\alpha - \alpha): \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{7}, \sqrt{3}). If \displaystyle \sqrt{3} = a + b\sqrt{7} with a, b \in \mathbb{Q}, then \displaystyle 3 = a^2 + 7b^2 + 2ab\sqrt{7} forces ab = 0; b = 0 makes \displaystyle \sqrt{3} rational and a = 0 makes 21 = (7b)^2 a rational square, both false (Irrational numbers). So \displaystyle [\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{7}, \sqrt{3}) : \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{7})] = 2, and the tower law gives 4.
Hence m_\alpha = x^4 - 20x^2 + 16, of degree 4. Each of \displaystyle \pm\sqrt{7} \pm \sqrt{3} squares to \displaystyle 10 \pm 2\sqrt{21}, so is a root: these four numbers are the conjugates of \alpha.
The same element over three intermediate fields
Find the minimal polynomial of \displaystyle \alpha = \sqrt{7} - \sqrt{3} over \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{7}), \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{3}) and \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{21}), and check Theorem 5.
SolutionEach \displaystyle K = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{d}) here has degree 2, lies in \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) (\displaystyle \sqrt{21} = \sqrt{7}\sqrt{3}), and has K(\alpha) = \mathbb{Q}(\alpha), so by Example 1 and the tower law \alpha has degree 4/2 = 2 over K. A monic quadratic in K[x] killing \alpha is therefore m_{\alpha, K}.
From \displaystyle \alpha - \sqrt{7} = -\sqrt{3}, squaring gives \displaystyle \alpha^2 - 2\sqrt{7}\,\alpha + 4 = 0; from \displaystyle \alpha + \sqrt{3} = \sqrt{7}, \displaystyle \alpha^2 + 2\sqrt{3}\,\alpha - 4 = 0; and \displaystyle \alpha^2 = 10 - 2\sqrt{21}. So the minimal polynomials are \displaystyle x^2 - 2\sqrt{7}\,x + 4, \displaystyle x^2 + 2\sqrt{3}\,x - 4 and \displaystyle x^2 - 10 + 2\sqrt{21}, and over \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) it is x - \alpha.
Theorem 5 says each divides p = x^4 - 20x^2 + 16 in K[x]. Indeed each times its image under \displaystyle \sqrt{d} \mapsto -\sqrt{d} gives p, written as a difference of squares in three ways: p = (x^2 + 4)^2 - 28x^2, p = (x^2 - 4)^2 - 12x^2 and p = (x^2 - 10)^2 - 84. One quartic, irreducible over \mathbb{Q}, factors in three ways over three quadratic fields:
Two relations, one minimal polynomial
A real number \alpha satisfies g(\alpha) = 0 and h(\alpha) = 0, where g = x^4 - 2x^3 - 2x - 1 and h = x^3 - 5x - 2. Find m_\alpha over \mathbb{Q} and \mathbb{Q}(\alpha).
SolutionBy Theorem 1(c), m_\alpha divides g and h, so it divides their monic greatest common divisor, found by the Euclidean algorithm in \mathbb{Q}[x] (Euclidean domains and principal ideal domains):
So \gcd(g, h) = x^2 - 2x - 1. Its roots \displaystyle 1 \pm \sqrt{2} are irrational, so this quadratic is irreducible, and m_\alpha, a monic divisor of positive degree, equals it: m_\alpha = x^2 - 2x - 1, \displaystyle \alpha = 1 \pm \sqrt{2}, and \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}).
An element of \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) by linear algebra
Let \alpha \in \mathbb{C} be a root of f = x^3 + 2x - 2 and \beta = \alpha^2 - \alpha. Find m_\beta over \mathbb{Q}.
SolutionAt \pm 1, \pm 2, f takes 1, -5, 10, -14, so the cubic has no rational root (The rational root theorem) and is irreducible: (1, \alpha, \alpha^2) is a basis of \mathbb{Q}(\alpha), with \alpha^3 = 2 - 2\alpha and \alpha^4 = 2\alpha - 2\alpha^2. Reducing,
Four vectors in a space of dimension 3 are dependent. Writing \beta^3 + a\beta^2 + b\beta + c = 0 and comparing coordinates on \alpha^2, \alpha and 1 gives -8 - a + b = 0, -12 + 6a - b = 0 and 14 - 4a + c = 0, so a = 4, b = 12, c = 2, and \beta is a root of x^3 + 4x^2 + 12x + 2. The degree of \beta divides 3 (Theorem 4) and is not 1, as \beta \notin \mathbb{Q} (its coordinates are not those of a constant). So m_\beta = x^3 + 4x^2 + 12x + 2, and \mathbb{Q}(\beta) = \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) (Exercise 11 of Field extensions and degree).
Transcendental over one field, algebraic over another
Given that \pi is transcendental over \mathbb{Q}, show that \pi^2 is too, that \pi is algebraic over K = \mathbb{Q}(\pi^2) with m_{\pi, K} = x^2 - \pi^2, and that \mathbb{Q}[\pi] \ne \mathbb{Q}(\pi).
SolutionIf g(\pi^2) = 0 for a nonzero g \in \mathbb{Q}[x], then g(x^2) is a nonzero polynomial killing \pi, which is impossible.
Next, \pi is a root of x^2 - \pi^2 \in K[x], so it has degree at most 2 over K. Suppose \pi \in K. By Theorem 2(b) for the transcendental \pi^2, \pi = a(\pi^2)/b(\pi^2) with a, b \in \mathbb{Q}[x], b \ne 0, so \pi is a root of x\,b(x^2) - a(x^2). The first term is nonzero with only odd powers of x and the second has only even powers, so this polynomial is nonzero: a contradiction. Hence m_{\pi, K} = x^2 - \pi^2 and [\mathbb{Q}(\pi) : \mathbb{Q}(\pi^2)] = 2.
Finally \pi^{-1} \notin \mathbb{Q}[\pi] by Theorem 2(c), and \mathbb{Q}(\pi)/\mathbb{Q} is infinite (Theorem 3).
Rings between the fields
Let E/F be algebraic and R a subring of E with F \subseteq R. Prove that R is a field, and show that “algebraic” cannot be dropped.
SolutionProof. As a subring of a field, R is commutative with 1 \ne 0; it remains to invert each nonzero r \in R. Since R contains F and r and is closed under sums and products, F[r] \subseteq R. As r is algebraic over F, F[r] = F(r) is a field (Theorem 1(e)), so r^{-1} \in F[r] \subseteq R. \square
Without the hypothesis it fails: F \subseteq F[t] \subseteq F(t), and t^{-1} \notin F[t] (Theorem 2(c)).
An element defined over a larger field
Let \alpha \in \mathbb{C} be a root of \displaystyle f = x^3 - \sqrt{2}\,x - \sqrt{3}. Prove that \alpha is algebraic over \mathbb{Q} of degree at most 12, and find a nonzero P \in \mathbb{Q}[x] with P(\alpha) = 0.
SolutionProof. Let \displaystyle L = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}); by Corollary 6, [L : \mathbb{Q}] \le 4. As f \in L[x] kills \alpha, [L(\alpha) : L] \le 3 (Theorem 1), and the tower law gives [L(\alpha) : \mathbb{Q}] \le 12. By Theorem 4, \alpha is algebraic over \mathbb{Q} with degree dividing [L(\alpha) : \mathbb{Q}], so at most 12. \square
For P, multiply f by its images under the sign changes of \displaystyle \sqrt{2} and \displaystyle \sqrt{3}. With \displaystyle u = x^3 - \sqrt{3} and w = x^6 - 2x^2 + 3, the product \displaystyle (u - \sqrt{2}\,x)(u + \sqrt{2}\,x) is \displaystyle u^2 - 2x^2 = w - 2\sqrt{3}\,x^3. Then
P has rational coefficients and vanishes at \alpha, since its factor \displaystyle u - \sqrt{2}\,x = f does. A computer-algebra factorization (run in this lesson’s checks) shows P irreducible, so \alpha has degree exactly 12, \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) = L(\alpha), and \displaystyle \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3} \in \mathbb{Q}(\alpha).
Boundaries
- “Algebraic” depends on the base field. \pi is transcendental over \mathbb{Q}, of degree 2 over \mathbb{Q}(\pi^2) (Example 5), and of degree 1 over \mathbb{R}.
- Algebraic does not mean finite. \overline{\mathbb{Q}}/\mathbb{Q} is algebraic of infinite degree (Theorem 10). Corollary 6 needs finitely many generators.
- Particular numbers are hard. Theorem 10 makes almost every complex number transcendental, yet it is not even known whether e + \pi is irrational; Exercise 12 shows only that one of e + \pi, e\pi is transcendental.
Where this goes next
Splitting fields adjoins all the conjugates of \alpha at once, and Finite fields reads elements through their minimal polynomials over \mathbb{Z}_p. Compass-and-straightedge constructions, and why an angle cannot be trisected uses Theorem 4: a constructible number has degree a power of 2. Exercise 13 is the seed of Field automorphisms and the Galois group: a map fixing F moves \alpha only to roots of m_\alpha, and the The fundamental theorem of Galois theory counts those moves.
Exercises
Minimal polynomials
- Find the minimal polynomial and the degree of \displaystyle 1 + \sqrt[3]{4} over \mathbb{Q}.
- Amara and Samir look at \displaystyle \alpha = \sqrt{7 + 4\sqrt{3}}. Amara squares twice and gets x^4 - 14x^2 + 1; Samir says the minimal polynomial has degree 2. Find m_\alpha over \mathbb{Q} and factor Amara’s polynomial in \mathbb{Q}[x].
- Find the minimal polynomial of \displaystyle \sqrt[3]{2} + \sqrt[3]{4} over \mathbb{Q}.
- Writing k for [k], let K = \mathbb{Z}_3[x]/\langle x^2 + 1 \rangle and \gamma = x + \langle x^2 + 1 \rangle. Show that K is a field and find the minimal polynomials of \gamma^2 and of 1 + \gamma over \mathbb{Z}_3.
Changing the base field
- Find the minimal polynomial of \displaystyle \sqrt[4]{5} over \mathbb{Q}, over \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{5}) and over \mathbb{Q}(i).
- Let \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{2} + \sqrt{2}\,i. Find its minimal polynomial over \mathbb{Q}, over \mathbb{Q}(i) and over \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}).
Using the minimal polynomial
- Let \alpha \in \mathbb{C} be a common root of x^3 - x^2 - x - 2 and x^4 + x^3 + 4x^2 + 3x + 3. Find m_\alpha over \mathbb{Q} and \mathbb{Q}(\alpha).
- Let \alpha \in \mathbb{C} be a root of x^3 + 3x + 3 and \beta = \alpha^2 + 1. Find m_\beta over \mathbb{Q}.
- Given that \pi is transcendental over \mathbb{Q}, find [\mathbb{Q}(\pi) : \mathbb{Q}(\pi^2 - 2\pi)] and the minimal polynomial of \pi over \mathbb{Q}(\pi^2 - 2\pi), and show that \displaystyle \pi + \sqrt{2} is transcendental.
Proofs
- Let \alpha be transcendental over F, g \in F[x] nonconstant and \beta = g(\alpha). Prove that \beta is transcendental over F and that [F(\alpha) : F(\beta)] \le \deg g.
- Let \mathbb{Q}(t) be the field of rational functions over \mathbb{Q}. Prove that the only elements of \mathbb{Q}(t) algebraic over \mathbb{Q} are the rational numbers.
- Prove that if \alpha + \beta and \alpha\beta are algebraic over F, so are \alpha and \beta. Deduce that at least one of e + \pi and e\pi is transcendental.
- Let E/F be algebraic and \psi : E \to E a ring homomorphism with \psi(c) = c for every c \in F. Prove that \psi is onto.
Answers
- With \displaystyle \alpha = 1 + \sqrt[3]{4}, (\alpha - 1)^3 = 4, so \alpha is a root of x^3 - 3x^2 + 3x - 5. Also \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[3]{4}), and x^3 - 4 takes -3, -5, 4, -12, 60, -68 at \pm 1, \pm 2, \pm 4, so it is irreducible and the degree is 3. The monic cubic is a multiple of m_\alpha of the same degree: m_\alpha = x^3 - 3x^2 + 3x - 5.
- \displaystyle (2 + \sqrt{3})^2 = 7 + 4\sqrt{3} and \displaystyle 2 + \sqrt{3} > 0, so \displaystyle \alpha = 2 + \sqrt{3}, a root of x^2 - 4x + 1 as (\alpha - 2)^2 = 3. Its roots \displaystyle 2 \pm \sqrt{3} are irrational, so m_\alpha = x^2 - 4x + 1: Samir is right. By Theorem 1(c) it divides Amara’s polynomial, which is (x^2 - 4x + 1)(x^2 + 4x + 1).
- With \displaystyle a = \sqrt[3]{2} and \alpha = a + a^2: \alpha^3 = a^3 + 3a^4 + 3a^5 + a^6, which is 2 + 6a + 6a^2 + 4 = 6 + 6\alpha. So \alpha is a root of x^3 - 6x - 6, which takes -11, -1, -10, -2, 3, -15, 174, -186 at \pm 1, \pm 2, \pm 3, \pm 6, so it is irreducible: m_\alpha = x^3 - 6x - 6.
- x^2 + 1 takes 1, 2, 2 at 0, 1, 2, so it is irreducible and K is a field with 9 elements. As \gamma^2 = -1 = 2 \in \mathbb{Z}_3, m_{\gamma^2} = x - 2. And ((1 + \gamma) - 1)^2 + 1 = 0, so 1 + \gamma is a root of (x - 1)^2 + 1 = x^2 + x + 2, which takes 2, 1, 2 at 0, 1, 2: irreducible, and m_{1 + \gamma} = x^2 + x + 2.
- x^4 - 5 is Eisenstein at 5, so it is the minimal polynomial over \mathbb{Q}, of degree 4. Over \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{5}): \displaystyle (\sqrt[4]{5})^2 = \sqrt{5} and the degree is 4/2 = 2, so \displaystyle m = x^2 - \sqrt{5}. Over \mathbb{Q}(i): \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[4]{5}) \subseteq \mathbb{R} misses i, so \displaystyle [\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[4]{5}, i) : \mathbb{Q}] = 8 and the degree over \mathbb{Q}(i) is 8/2 = 4; by Theorem 5, m = x^4 - 5 again.
- \beta^2 = 2(1 + i)^2 = 4i and \beta^4 = -16, so \beta is a root of x^4 + 16. Since i = \beta^2/4 and \displaystyle \sqrt{2} = \beta/(1 + i), \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\beta) = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}, i), of degree 4. So m_{\beta, \mathbb{Q}} = x^4 + 16, and \beta has degree 2 over each quadratic field: over \mathbb{Q}(i), x^2 - 4i; over \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}), from \displaystyle (\beta - \sqrt{2})^2 = -2, \displaystyle x^2 - 2\sqrt{2}\,x + 4.
- With g = x^3 - x^2 - x - 2 and h = x^4 + x^3 + 4x^2 + 3x + 3: h = (x + 2)g + 7(x^2 + x + 1) and g = (x - 2)(x^2 + x + 1), so \gcd(g, h) = x^2 + x + 1. It has no real root, so it is irreducible, and m_\alpha equals it. Then \displaystyle \alpha = \frac{-1 \pm \sqrt{3}\,i}{2} and \displaystyle \mathbb{Q}(\alpha) = \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{3}\,i).
- x^3 + 3x + 3 takes 7, -1, 39, -33 at \pm 1, \pm 3, so \alpha has degree 3. From \alpha(\alpha^2 + 3) = -3, \alpha(\beta + 2) = -3, so \alpha^2 = 9/(\beta + 2)^2 = \beta - 1 and 9 = (\beta - 1)(\beta + 2)^2 = \beta^3 + 3\beta^2 - 4. So \beta is a root of x^3 + 3x^2 - 13, which takes -9, -11 at \pm 1 and is nonzero at \pm 13: m_\beta = x^3 + 3x^2 - 13.
- Let s = \pi - 1, transcendental (a polynomial killing s gives one killing \pi). Then \pi^2 - 2\pi = s^2 - 1, so K = \mathbb{Q}(s^2), and s \notin K by the parity argument of Example 5, so \pi \notin K. As \pi is a root of x^2 - 2x - (\pi^2 - 2\pi) \in K[x], the degree is 2 and this is m_{\pi, K}. If \displaystyle \pi + \sqrt{2} were algebraic, so would be \displaystyle \pi = (\pi + \sqrt{2}) - \sqrt{2}, as \overline{\mathbb{Q}} is a field (Theorem 7).
- Proof. Let g have degree d \ge 1 and leading coefficient c. If a nonzero h \in F[x] had h(\beta) = 0, then h(g(x)) would kill \alpha; its leading coefficient is that of h times c^{\deg h}, so it is nonzero, a contradiction. Next, g(x) - \beta \in F(\beta)[x] has leading coefficient c and kills \alpha, so \alpha has degree at most d over F(\beta). As \beta \in F(\alpha), F(\beta)(\alpha) = F(\alpha), and Theorem 1(e) gives [F(\alpha) : F(\beta)] \le d. \square
- Proof. Rationals are algebraic. Let u = c(t)/d(t) \in \mathbb{Q}(t) \setminus \mathbb{Q} with c, d \in \mathbb{Q}[x], d \ne 0. Then P = c(x) - u\,d(x) \in \mathbb{Q}(u)[x] kills t, and P \ne 0: for a coefficient d_k \ne 0 of d, the coefficient c_k - ud_k of P vanishes only if u = c_k/d_k \in \mathbb{Q}. So t is algebraic over \mathbb{Q}(u). If u were algebraic over \mathbb{Q}, then \mathbb{Q}(u)/\mathbb{Q} would be algebraic (Theorems 1(e) and 4), and Theorem 8 would make t algebraic over \mathbb{Q}, against Exercise 13 of Field extensions and degree. \square
- Proof. Let s = \alpha + \beta, p = \alpha\beta, and K = F(s, p), finite over F (Corollary 6), so algebraic over F (Theorem 4). Both \alpha and \beta are roots of x^2 - sx + p = (x - \alpha)(x - \beta) \in K[x], so they are algebraic over K, hence over F (Theorem 8). If e + \pi and e\pi were both algebraic over \mathbb{Q}, then \pi would be. \square
- Proof. \psi is injective, as its kernel is an ideal of a field without 1. Let \alpha \in E and S the set of roots of m_\alpha in E, finite and containing \alpha. For \beta \in S, m_\alpha(\psi(\beta)) = \psi(m_\alpha(\beta)) = 0, since \psi preserves sums and products and fixes the coefficients. So \psi maps the finite set S injectively into itself, hence onto it, and \alpha = \psi(\beta) for some \beta \in S. \square