The fundamental group of the circle
A loop on a circle can run around it any number of times, forward or backward. Can a loop that runs around twice be slid, with its ends held, into one that runs around once, or does the count of turns survive every deformation?
Where you are 5 in First algebraic topology
Why this exists
The fundamental group made the loops at a point into a group, but every group it computed was trivial: showing that a loop is not nullhomotopic means ruling out every homotopy at once. Wrapping the line \mathbb{R} around S^1 turns a loop on the circle into a path in \mathbb{R} whose net climb is an integer, the signed number of turns, and a homotopy cannot change an integer continuously. The result is the first nontrivial fundamental group, \pi_1(S^1, x_0) \cong \mathbb{Z}, and with it proofs that maps are not homotopic and spaces not homeomorphic.
Definition
Paths, loops, \simeq_p, [f] and \pi_1 are those of Homotopy and The fundamental group, and “map” means continuous map. Throughout, x_0 = (1, 0).
The covering of the circle. p : \mathbb{R} \to S^1 is p(u) = (\cos 2\pi u, \sin 2\pi u). A point of the The unit circle fixes its angle up to a multiple of 2\pi, so p(u) = p(v) if and only if u - v \in \mathbb{Z}. In particular p^{-1}(x_0) = \mathbb{Z} and p(u + n) = p(u) for n \in \mathbb{Z}.
Evenly covered sets. An open U \subseteq S^1 is evenly covered if p^{-1}(U) is a union of disjoint open sets of \mathbb{R}, the sheets over U, each mapped by p homeomorphically onto U.
Lifts. A lift of a map F : Y \to S^1 is a map \tilde{F} : Y \to \mathbb{R} with p \circ \tilde{F} = F. A lift of a path f is a path \tilde{f} in \mathbb{R}; it starts at \tilde{f}(0).
Standard loops. For n \in \mathbb{Z}, \omega_n(s) = (\cos 2\pi n s, \sin 2\pi n s) = p(ns) is a loop at x_0 running |n| times around S^1, counterclockwise for n > 0 and clockwise for n < 0. Also \omega_0 = c_{x_0}, and \bar{\omega}_n = \omega_{-n} since p(n - ns) = p(-ns).
Degree. Every loop f in S^1, at any base point, has a lift \tilde{f} (Theorem 3). Its degree is \deg f = \tilde{f}(1) - \tilde{f}(0), an integer since p(\tilde{f}(1)) = f(1) = f(0) = p(\tilde{f}(0)), and the same for every lift (Theorem 2). The degree of a map g : S^1 \to S^1 is \deg g = \deg(g \circ \omega_1).
Intuition
Place \mathbb{R} in space as the helix u \mapsto (\cos 2\pi u, \sin 2\pi u, u); then p is the shadow cast straight down onto the circle. Over a short arc the helix is a stack of disjoint copies of the arc, one per turn: the sheets. A point moving on the circle drags a point of the helix along once a starting floor is chosen, and the lift is its height. A loop at x_0 ends over x_0, so its lift ends on an integer floor, and the climb counts turns, counterclockwise minus clockwise. A path homotopy would move that end continuously through the integers, so it cannot move.
Results
Theorem 1 (evenly covered arcs). Let q = p(a) and U = S^1 \setminus \{q\}. Then p^{-1}(U) is the union of the disjoint open intervals J_n = (a + n, a + n + 1), n \in \mathbb{Z}, and p maps each J_n homeomorphically onto U. So U is evenly covered.
Theorem 2 (uniqueness of lifts). Let Y be connected and \tilde{F}_1, \tilde{F}_2 lifts of one map F : Y \to S^1. Then \tilde{F}_1 - \tilde{F}_2 is a constant integer. So two lifts that agree at one point are equal.
Theorem 3 (lifting paths and homotopies). (a) For a path f in S^1 and a \in \mathbb{R} with p(a) = f(0), there is exactly one lift of f starting at a. (b) For a map F : I \times I \to S^1 and a with p(a) = F(0, 0), there is exactly one lift \tilde{F} with \tilde{F}(0, 0) = a. (c) If F is a path homotopy from f_0 to f_1 and \tilde{f}_0, \tilde{f}_1 are their lifts starting at a, then \tilde{F} is a path homotopy from \tilde{f}_0 to \tilde{f}_1. In particular \tilde{f}_0(1) = \tilde{f}_1(1).
Theorem 4 (the fundamental group of the circle). The function \Phi : \pi_1(S^1, x_0) \to \mathbb{Z}, \Phi[f] = \deg f, is a well-defined isomorphism. So \pi_1(S^1, x_0) \cong \mathbb{Z} is infinite cyclic, generated by [\omega_1], with [\omega_n] = [\omega_1]^n, and every loop f at x_0 is path homotopic to \omega_n for exactly one n, namely n = \deg f. For every x \in S^1, \pi_1(S^1, x) \cong \mathbb{Z}.
Theorem 5 (degree of a map of the circle). Let g, g_0, g_1 : S^1 \to S^1 be maps. (a) If g_0 \simeq g_1, then \deg g_0 = \deg g_1. (b) g is nullhomotopic if and only if \deg g = 0. (c) \deg \mathrm{id}_{S^1} = 1, so \mathrm{id}_{S^1} is not nullhomotopic and S^1 is not contractible; and \pi_1(\mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\}, x_0) \cong \mathbb{Z}.
Why it is true
Theorem 1. Proof. p(u) = q exactly when u \in a + \mathbb{Z}, so p^{-1}(U) = \mathbb{R} \setminus (a + \mathbb{Z}), the union of the disjoint open intervals J_n. Two points of J_n differ by less than 1, never by a nonzero integer, so p is one-to-one on J_n. Each u \in \mathbb{R} has exactly one integer shift in [a + n, a + n + 1), so p maps that interval onto S^1, and removing p(a + n) = q gives p(J_n) = U. For the inverse let K_n = [a + n, a + n + 1], compact by Theorem 4 of Compactness in products and the Heine-Borel theorem. S^1 is a metric space, hence Hausdorff (Hausdorff spaces and separation), so p|_{K_n} is a closed map (Theorem 6 of Compactness and open covers). If C is closed in J_n, its closure \overline{C} in \mathbb{R} lies in K_n and \overline{C} \cap J_n = C; then p(\overline{C}) is closed in S^1 and lies in p(C) \cup \{q\}, so p(C) = p(\overline{C}) \cap U is closed in U. A closed continuous bijection is a homeomorphism (Theorem 5(b) of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms). \square
Theorem 2. Proof. d = \tilde{F}_1 - \tilde{F}_2 is continuous (Theorem 6(b) of Subspace and product topologies), and p(\tilde{F}_1(y)) = p(\tilde{F}_2(y)) puts d(y) in \mathbb{Z}. So d(Y) is connected (Theorem 4 of Connectedness), an interval of \mathbb{R} (Theorem 3 there) inside \mathbb{Z}, a single point when Y \neq \varnothing. \square
Theorem 3. Proof. (b) The sets U_1 = S^1 \setminus \{(1, 0)\} and U_2 = S^1 \setminus \{(-1, 0)\} are open (points are closed in the Hausdorff space S^1) and cover S^1, so F^{-1}(U_1), F^{-1}(U_2) are an open cover of I \times I, a compact metric space by the Heine-Borel theorem. Let \delta be a Lebesgue number of this cover (Theorem 6 of Compactness in products and the Heine-Borel theorem) and N a positive integer with \displaystyle \frac{\sqrt{2}}{N} < \delta. Each square \displaystyle R_{jk} = [\frac{j}{N}, \frac{j + 1}{N}] \times [\frac{k}{N}, \frac{k + 1}{N}], 0 \le j, k < N, has diameter \displaystyle \frac{\sqrt{2}}{N}, so F maps it into U_1 or U_2.
Take the squares row by row, k = 0 first, each row from left to right. Suppose \tilde{F} is already a continuous lift of F on the union A of the squares taken so far, and let R = R_{jk} be the next, with F(R) \subseteq U for U = U_1 or U_2. Then L = R \cap A is empty (first square), the left edge, the bottom edge, or both edges; both edges contain the corner \displaystyle c = (\frac{j}{N}, \frac{k}{N}), so L is connected (Theorem 5(a) of Connectedness). Let J be the sheet over U (Theorem 1) containing a for the first square, and containing \tilde{F}(c) otherwise; one exists since p(a) = F(0, 0) and p(\tilde{F}(c)) = F(c) lie in U. On R put \tilde{F} = (p|_J)^{-1} \circ F, a continuous lift. On L the old and new lifts agree at c, so they agree on L (Theorem 2), and the pasting lemma (Theorem 3(d) of Subspace and product topologies) makes \tilde{F} continuous on the closed set A \cup R. After N^2 squares, \tilde{F} lifts F with \tilde{F}(0, 0) = a. It is unique by Theorem 2, as the convex I \times I is path-connected, hence connected (Path-connectedness, Theorems 5 and 2).
(a) Apply (b) to F(s, t) = f(s) and take \tilde{f}(s) = \tilde{F}(s, 0). It is unique by Theorem 2, as I is connected.
(c) t \mapsto \tilde{F}(0, t) lifts the constant path at f_0(0), and so does the constant path at a; they agree at t = 0, so \tilde{F}(0, t) = a for all t (Theorem 2). Likewise \tilde{F}(1, t) = \tilde{F}(1, 0). Now s \mapsto \tilde{F}(s, 0) and s \mapsto \tilde{F}(s, 1) lift f_0 and f_1 starting at a, so by (a) they are \tilde{f}_0 and \tilde{f}_1. Hence \tilde{F} is a path homotopy, and \tilde{f}_1(1) = \tilde{F}(1, 1) = \tilde{F}(1, 0) = \tilde{f}_0(1). \square
Theorem 4. Proof. For a loop f at x_0 let \tilde{f} be its lift starting at 0, so \deg f = \tilde{f}(1). If f \simeq_p f', their lifts from 0 end at the same point (Theorem 3(c)), so \Phi is well defined.
Homomorphism. Let \tilde{f}, \tilde{g} lift f, g from 0 and end at m, n. Since p(u + m) = p(u), the path \tilde{g} + m lifts g and starts at m, so \tilde{f} \cdot (\tilde{g} + m) is defined, lifts f \cdot g, starts at 0 and ends at m + n. So \Phi([f][g]) = m + n.
Onto. s \mapsto ns lifts \omega_n from 0, so \Phi[\omega_n] = n.
One-to-one. If \deg f = 0, then \tilde{f} is a loop at 0 in the convex set \mathbb{R}, and H(s, t) = (1 - t)\tilde{f}(s) is a path homotopy from \tilde{f} to c_0 (Theorem 3 of Homotopy). Then p \circ H is a path homotopy from f to c_{x_0}. So only the identity maps to 0, and if \Phi(\alpha) = \Phi(\beta) then \Phi(\alpha\beta^{-1}) = 0 and \alpha = \beta.
As \Phi[\omega_1] = 1 generates \mathbb{Z}, [\omega_1] generates \pi_1(S^1, x_0), and \Phi([\omega_1]^n) = n = \Phi[\omega_n] gives [\omega_n] = [\omega_1]^n. Finally S^1 = \omega_1(I) is path-connected, so Theorem 4 of The fundamental group moves the base point. \square
Theorem 5. Proof. (a) Let H : S^1 \times I \to S^1 run from g_0 to g_1 and put F(s, t) = H(\omega_1(s), t), a map I \times I \to S^1 with a lift \tilde{F} (Theorem 3(b)). For each t, s \mapsto \tilde{F}(s, t) lifts the loop s \mapsto H(\omega_1(s), t), so the degree of H(\cdot, t) is \tilde{F}(1, t) - \tilde{F}(0, t). This is continuous in t and integer-valued on the connected I, so it is constant, as in the proof of Theorem 2.
(b) A constant map has a constant lift, so degree 0; by (a) so does every nullhomotopic map. Conversely, let \deg g = 0 and let \gamma lift g \circ \omega_1, so \gamma(0) = \gamma(1). As \omega_1(s) = \omega_1(s') with s \neq s' only for \{s, s'\} = \{0, 1\}, the rule \tilde{g}(\omega_1(s)) = \gamma(s) defines a function \tilde{g} : S^1 \to \mathbb{R}. The map \omega_1 : I \to S^1 is closed (Theorem 6 of Compactness and open covers), so for closed C \subseteq \mathbb{R} the set \tilde{g}^{-1}(C) = \omega_1(\gamma^{-1}(C)) is closed, and \tilde{g} is continuous. Then p \circ \tilde{g} = g, and G(x, t) = p((1 - t)\tilde{g}(x)) is a homotopy from g to the constant map at x_0.
(c) \mathrm{id} \circ \omega_1 = \omega_1 has degree 1, so by (b) \mathrm{id}_{S^1} is not nullhomotopic, and S^1 is not contractible (Theorem 7(a) of Homotopy). S^1 is a deformation retract of \mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\} (Example 5 of Homotopy), so Theorem 8(c) of The fundamental group and Theorem 4 give \pi_1(\mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\}, x_0) \cong \mathbb{Z}. \square
Worked examples
Two laps of a roundabout
Sofia drives into a roundabout at the entrance x_0 = (1, 0), the lane modeled as S^1 around the island. She misses her exit twice and leaves where she came in. With time scaled to I, her position is f(s) = (\cos 4\pi s^2, \sin 4\pi s^2). (a) Find the lifts of f starting at 0 and at -1. (b) Find \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{2}), \displaystyle f(\frac{3}{4}) and \deg f. (c) Find n with [f] = [\omega_n] and a path homotopy from f to \omega_n.
Solution(a) f(s) = p(2s^2), so \tilde{f}(s) = 2s^2 is a lift starting at 0, the only one by Theorem 3(a). As p(u - 1) = p(u), the lift starting at -1 is 2s^2 - 1.
(b) \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{2}) = p(\frac{1}{2}) = (-1, 0) and \displaystyle f(\frac{3}{4}) = p(\frac{9}{8}) = p(\frac{1}{8}) = (\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}). Then \deg f = 2 - 0 = 2; the other lift agrees, 1 - (-1) = 2.
(c) n = 2 by Theorem 4. The straight-line homotopy from 2s^2 to 2s in \mathbb{R}, followed by p, is
with H(s, 0) = f(s), H(s, 1) = \omega_2(s), and H(0, t) = p(0), H(1, t) = p(2) both equal to x_0.
A robot that turns back
Diego’s mowing robot runs on a circular track on the island, modeled as S^1 with its gate at x_0, in either direction. It runs twice counterclockwise and then three times clockwise, each at constant speed: h = \omega_2 \cdot \omega_{-3}. (a) Find the lift \tilde{h} starting at 0. (b) Find \displaystyle \tilde{h}(\frac{3}{4}), \displaystyle h(\frac{3}{4}) and \deg h. (c) Which \omega_n is h path homotopic to?
Solution(a) On \displaystyle [0, \frac{1}{2}], h(s) = \omega_2(2s) = p(4s); on \displaystyle [\frac{1}{2}, 1], h(s) = \omega_{-3}(2s - 1) = p(3 - 6s) = p(5 - 6s), since p(u + 2) = p(u). Put \tilde{h}(s) = 4s on \displaystyle [0, \frac{1}{2}] and \tilde{h}(s) = 5 - 6s on \displaystyle [\frac{1}{2}, 1]. Both pieces give 2 at \displaystyle s = \frac{1}{2}, so \tilde{h} is continuous (pasting lemma) and lifts h from 0; by Theorem 3(a) it is the lift.
(b) \displaystyle \tilde{h}(\frac{3}{4}) = \frac{1}{2}, so \displaystyle h(\frac{3}{4}) = p(\frac{1}{2}) = (-1, 0), and \deg h = \tilde{h}(1) = -1, as the homomorphism \Phi predicts: 2 + (-3) = -1.
(c) h \simeq_p \omega_{-1} = \bar{\omega}_1, so [h] = [\omega_1]^{-1}.
Multiplying the angle
For n \in \mathbb{Z} define m_n : S^1 \to S^1 by m_n(p(u)) = p(nu). (a) Show that m_n is a well-defined map and that m_{-1} is the reflection \rho(x, y) = (x, -y). (b) Show (m_n)_*[\omega_k] = [\omega_{nk}] and \deg m_n = n. (c) Find \deg(m_2 \circ f) for Sofia’s loop f. (d) Show that m_j \simeq m_k only if j = k.
Solution(a) p is onto, and if p(u) = p(v) then nu - nv \in \mathbb{Z}, so p(nu) = p(nv): the rule is well defined. On U_1 and on U_2 (as in the proof of Theorem 3) pick a sheet J; there m_n = p \circ (u \mapsto nu) \circ (p|_J)^{-1}, continuous by Theorem 1. So m_n is continuous at every point (Theorem 2(d) of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms). And p(-u) = (\cos 2\pi u, -\sin 2\pi u) = \rho(p(u)).
(b) m_n(\omega_k(s)) = m_n(p(ks)) = p(nks) = \omega_{nk}(s), and m_n(x_0) = x_0, so (m_n)_*[\omega_k] = [\omega_{nk}]: under \Phi, (m_n)_* is multiplication by n. With k = 1, \deg m_n = \deg \omega_n = n.
(c) m_2(f(s)) = p(4s^2), with lift 4s^2 from 0, so \deg(m_2 \circ f) = 4.
(d) Homotopic maps have equal degrees (Theorem 5(a)), and \deg m_j = j. So neither \rho nor m_2 is homotopic to \mathrm{id}_{S^1} = m_1.
The plane is not three-space
Prove that \mathbb{R}^2 is not homeomorphic to \mathbb{R}^n for any n \ge 3.
SolutionProof. Suppose h : \mathbb{R}^2 \to \mathbb{R}^n is a homeomorphism and q = h(0). Restricted to \mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\} it is a bijection onto \mathbb{R}^n \setminus \{q\}, continuous both ways (Theorem 3(b), (c) of Subspace and product topologies), so by Theorem 5 of The fundamental group the groups \pi_1(\mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\}, x_0) and \pi_1(\mathbb{R}^n \setminus \{q\}, h(x_0)) are isomorphic. The first is \mathbb{Z} (Theorem 5(c)). Translation by -q is a homeomorphism onto \mathbb{R}^n \setminus \{0\}, and
deformation retracts \mathbb{R}^n \setminus \{0\} onto S^{n-1}: \lVert H(x, t) \rVert = (1 - t)\lVert x \rVert + t > 0, H(x, 0) = x, H(x, 1) \in S^{n-1}, and H fixes S^{n-1}. As n - 1 \ge 2, S^{n-1} is simply connected (Example 5 of The fundamental group), so by Theorems 4, 5 and 8(c) there the second group is trivial. But \mathbb{Z} \not\cong \{e\}. \square
Loops on a torus
Let T^2 = S^1 \times S^1 with base point (x_0, x_0). (a) Show that [k] \mapsto (\deg(\mathrm{pr}_1 \circ k), \deg(\mathrm{pr}_2 \circ k)) is an isomorphism \pi_1(T^2, (x_0, x_0)) \to \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z}. (b) Let k(s) = (\omega_3(s), \omega_{-1}(s)), a = (\omega_1, c_{x_0}) and b = (c_{x_0}, \omega_1). Find the image of [k] and write [k] in terms of [a] and [b]. (c) Prove that T^2 is not homotopy equivalent to S^1.
Solution(a) It is the isomorphism of Theorem 7 of The fundamental group followed by \Phi \times \Phi.
(b) \mathrm{pr}_1 \circ k = \omega_3 and \mathrm{pr}_2 \circ k = \omega_{-1}, so [k] \mapsto (3, -1). Also [a] \mapsto (1, 0) and [b] \mapsto (0, 1), and (3, -1) = 3(1, 0) - (0, 1); the map is one-to-one, so [k] = [a]^3[b]^{-1}.
(c) Proof. Suppose \psi : \mathbb{Z} \to \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z} is an isomorphism with \psi(1) = (c, d), so every element is (mc, md) for some m \in \mathbb{Z}. From (1, 0) = (mc, md), mc = 1, so m = \pm 1 and d = 0; then (0, 1) = (m'c, 0) is impossible. So \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z} \not\cong \mathbb{Z}, while a homotopy equivalence would induce an isomorphism (Theorem 8(b) of The fundamental group). \square
Odd maps have odd degree
Call g : S^1 \to S^1 odd if g(-x) = -g(x) for all x. Prove that an odd map has odd degree, so it is not nullhomotopic.
SolutionProof. Let \gamma lift g \circ \omega_1 (Theorem 3(a)). Since \displaystyle p(u + \frac{1}{2}) = -p(u), for \displaystyle s \in [0, \frac{1}{2}],
So \displaystyle \gamma(s + \frac{1}{2}) - \gamma(s) - \frac{1}{2} is an integer for each s; it is continuous on the connected \displaystyle [0, \frac{1}{2}], so it is a constant k, as in the proof of Theorem 2. Using \displaystyle s = \frac{1}{2} and s = 0,
An odd number is not 0, so g is not nullhomotopic (Theorem 5(b)). \square For instance m_3 is odd, of degree 3.
Boundaries
- What lifts. Paths and squares always lift; a map S^1 \to S^1 lifts exactly when its degree is 0 (proof of Theorem 5(b), Exercise 13).
- Degree is a signed count, not the number of times a point is covered: the loop of Example 2 passes over (-1, 0) five times and has degree -1, and the map of Exercise 10 is onto with degree 0.
- Higher dimensions. \pi_1 cannot tell \mathbb{R}^3 from \mathbb{R}^4: removing a point leaves both simply connected. That needs homology (Hatcher, Algebraic Topology, chapter 2), as does Brouwer’s theorem for n \ge 3.
- One circle only. Other spaces need van Kampen’s theorem and the general theory of covering spaces (Hatcher, sections 1.2 and 1.3), beyond this course.
Where this goes next
Brouwer's fixed point theorem uses Theorem 5 to show that S^1 is not a retract of D^2, so every map D^2 \to D^2 fixes a point. The same count of turns proves the The fundamental theorem of algebra and, as a winding number, the The argument principle and Rouché's theorem; Example 5 gives the group of the torus, a surface of Classification of surfaces.
Exercises
Lifts and sheets
- Let f(s) = (\cos 2\pi(3s^2 - 2s), \sin 2\pi(3s^2 - 2s)). (a) Find the lifts of f starting at 0 and at 4. (b) Find \deg f and the n with [f] = [\omega_n]. (c) Find the smallest value of the lift from 0 and the point of S^1 reached then.
- Let g = \omega_3 \cdot \bar{\omega}_1. Find the lift \tilde{g} starting at 0 on each half of I, then \displaystyle \tilde{g}(\frac{3}{4}), \displaystyle g(\frac{3}{4}) and \deg g.
- Let h(s) = (\cos \pi s, \sin \pi s). Find every lift of h, the end of the lift starting at 3, and say why no lift starts at \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}.
- Let \displaystyle q = (0, 1) = p(\frac{1}{4}) and U = S^1 \setminus \{q\}. List the sheets over U given by Theorem 1, and find the points of the sheet containing 2 that lie over (-1, 0) and over (0, -1).
- Let F(s, t) = p(2s + ts(1 - s)) on I \times I. Show that F is a path homotopy from \omega_2 to a loop f_1, find its lift \tilde{F} with \tilde{F}(0, 0) = 0, and find \displaystyle \tilde{F}(\frac{1}{2}, 1), \displaystyle F(\frac{1}{2}, 1) and \deg f_1.
Degrees and induced maps
- Let \gamma(s) = (\cos 2\pi s, -4\sin 2\pi s) and \displaystyle f = \frac{\gamma}{\lVert \gamma \rVert}, a loop at x_0. Find \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{4}), \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{8}) and \deg f.
- Find n with [\omega_2][\bar{\omega}_5][\omega_1] = [\omega_n] in \pi_1(S^1, x_0).
- Let k(x, y) = (x^3 - 3xy^2, 3x^2y - y^3). Show that k(\cos\theta, \sin\theta) = (\cos 3\theta, \sin 3\theta), so k maps S^1 to S^1, and find \deg k and k_*[\omega_{-2}].
- Let g(x, y) = (y, x) on S^1. Find the lift of g \circ \omega_1 starting at \displaystyle \frac{1}{4}, and \deg g. Is g \simeq \mathrm{id}_{S^1}?
- Let g(x, y) = (\cos 2\pi y, \sin 2\pi y) on S^1. Find \deg g and show that g is onto.
Telling spaces apart
- Give \pi_1 up to isomorphism, with a reason: (a) \mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{(1, 1)\}; (b) the annulus \{x \in \mathbb{R}^2 : 1 \le \lVert x \rVert \le 2\}; (c) S^1 \times S^1 \times S^1; (d) S^1 \times S^2.
- In T^2 at (x_0, x_0), is (\omega_2, \omega_{-1}) path homotopic to (\omega_1, c_{x_0}) \cdot (\omega_1, \omega_{-1})? To (\omega_{-1}, \omega_2)?
Proofs
- Prove that there is no map \tilde{g} : S^1 \to \mathbb{R} with p \circ \tilde{g} = \mathrm{id}_{S^1}.
- Let f be a loop at x_0 whose image misses some point q of S^1. Prove that f \simeq_p c_{x_0}.
- Let g : S^1 \to S^1 have \deg g \neq 1. Prove that g(x) = x for some x \in S^1.
- Let g : S^1 \to S^1 be a map with g(x_0) = x_0 and d = \deg g. Prove that g_*[\omega_n] = [\omega_{dn}] for every n, so g_* is multiplication by d under \Phi.
Answers
- (a) 3s^2 - 2s and 3s^2 - 2s + 4, by Theorem 3(a), since f(s) = p(3s^2 - 2s). (b) \deg f = 1 - 0 = 1, so n = 1. (c) The derivative 6s - 2 vanishes at \displaystyle s = \frac{1}{3}, giving \displaystyle -\frac{1}{3} and the point \displaystyle p(-\frac{1}{3}) = (-\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}).
- On \displaystyle [0, \frac{1}{2}], g(s) = p(6s), so \tilde{g}(s) = 6s, reaching 3. On \displaystyle [\frac{1}{2}, 1], g(s) = \omega_1(2 - 2s) = p(2 - 2s), and the lift meeting 3 at \displaystyle s = \frac{1}{2} is \tilde{g}(s) = 4 - 2s. So \displaystyle \tilde{g}(\frac{3}{4}) = \frac{5}{2}, \displaystyle g(\frac{3}{4}) = (-1, 0), \deg g = 2.
- \displaystyle h(s) = p(\frac{s}{2}). A lift starts over (1, 0), at an integer k, and by Theorem 3(a) it is \displaystyle k + \frac{s}{2}, k \in \mathbb{Z}. The lift starting at 3 ends at \displaystyle \frac{7}{2}. No lift starts at \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}, as \displaystyle p(\frac{1}{2}) = (-1, 0) \neq h(0).
- With \displaystyle a = \frac{1}{4}, the sheets are \displaystyle J_n = (n + \frac{1}{4}, n + \frac{5}{4}), n \in \mathbb{Z}. The one containing 2 is \displaystyle J_1 = (\frac{5}{4}, \frac{9}{4}); over (-1, 0) it has \displaystyle \frac{3}{2}, and over (0, -1) it has \displaystyle \frac{7}{4}.
- \tilde{F}(s, t) = 2s + ts(1 - s) is continuous with p \circ \tilde{F} = F and \tilde{F}(0, 0) = 0, so it is the lift (Theorem 3(b)). \tilde{F}(0, t) = 0 and \tilde{F}(1, t) = 2, so F(0, t) = F(1, t) = x_0, and F(s, 0) = \omega_2(s). \displaystyle \tilde{F}(\frac{1}{2}, 1) = \frac{5}{4}, \displaystyle F(\frac{1}{2}, 1) = (0, 1), and \deg f_1 = 2.
- \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{4}) = (0, -1) and \displaystyle f(\frac{1}{8}) = (\frac{1}{\sqrt{17}}, -\frac{4}{\sqrt{17}}). The vectors (\cos 2\pi s, -(4 - 3t)\sin 2\pi s) are never 0, as 4 - 3t \ge 1, so dividing by their length gives a path homotopy from f to \omega_{-1}, with both ends at x_0. So \deg f = -1.
- \bar{\omega}_5 = \omega_{-5}, and \Phi turns the product into 2 - 5 + 1, so n = -2.
- The triple angle formulas give \cos 3\theta = \cos^3\theta - 3\cos\theta\sin^2\theta and \sin 3\theta = 3\cos^2\theta\sin\theta - \sin^3\theta. So k = m_3 of Example 3: \deg k = 3 and k_*[\omega_{-2}] = [\omega_{-6}].
- \displaystyle g(\omega_1(s)) = (\sin 2\pi s, \cos 2\pi s) = p(\frac{1}{4} - s), so the lift is \displaystyle \frac{1}{4} - s and \deg g = -1. No: \deg \mathrm{id}_{S^1} = 1, and Theorem 5(a) applies.
- g(\omega_1(s)) = p(\sin 2\pi s), with lift \sin 2\pi s, which starts and ends at 0: \deg g = 0. Every point of S^1 is p(u) with u \in [0, 1], and \sin 2\pi s takes every value in [0, 1] on \displaystyle [0, \frac{1}{4}] (intermediate values, The intermediate value theorem), so g is onto.
- (a) \mathbb{Z}: translation by (-1, -1) is a homeomorphism onto \mathbb{R}^2 \setminus \{0\} (Theorem 5(c)). (b) \mathbb{Z}: \displaystyle (1 - t + \frac{t}{\lVert x \rVert})x has length (1 - t)\lVert x \rVert + t \in [1, 2], so it deformation retracts the annulus onto S^1. (c) \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z}, by Theorem 7 of The fundamental group twice. (d) \mathbb{Z} \times \{e\} \cong \mathbb{Z}, as S^2 is simply connected.
- Under the isomorphism of Example 5, (\omega_2, \omega_{-1}) \mapsto (2, -1) and the product \mapsto (1, 0) + (1, -1) = (2, -1): yes. (\omega_{-1}, \omega_2) \mapsto (-1, 2): no.
- If \tilde{g} existed, \tilde{g} \circ \omega_1 would lift \omega_1, and since \omega_1(0) = \omega_1(1) it would start and end at the same point, so \deg \omega_1 = 0. But \deg \omega_1 = 1. \square
- q \neq x_0, so q = p(a) with 0 < a < 1, and 0 \in J_{-1} = (a - 1, a), a sheet over U = S^1 \setminus \{q\} (Theorem 1). As f(I) \subseteq U, \tilde{f} = (p|_{J_{-1}})^{-1} \circ f is a lift starting at 0 and ending at the one point of J_{-1} over x_0, namely 0. So \deg f = 0 and f \simeq_p c_{x_0} by Theorem 4. \square
- Suppose g(x) \neq x for all x. If (1 - t)g(x) = tx, taking lengths gives \displaystyle t = \frac{1}{2} and then g(x) = x, excluded. So \displaystyle H(x, t) = \frac{(1 - t)g(x) - tx}{\lVert (1 - t)g(x) - tx \rVert} is a homotopy in S^1 from g to x \mapsto -x. That map sends \omega_1(s) to \displaystyle -p(s) = p(s + \frac{1}{2}), with lift \displaystyle s + \frac{1}{2}, so its degree is 1, and \deg g = 1 by Theorem 5(a). \square
- g \circ \omega_1 is a loop at x_0 of degree d, so g_*[\omega_1] = [\omega_d] by Theorem 4. As g_* is a homomorphism (Theorem 5 of The fundamental group) and [\omega_n] = [\omega_1]^n, g_*[\omega_n] = [\omega_d]^n = [\omega_1]^{dn} = [\omega_{dn}]. \square