Springs, damping and resonance
A mass on a spring is slowed by a damper and pushed by a periodic force. How much damping stops it from oscillating, and why does a push at one particular frequency make the motion grow without bound?
Where you are 5 in Second-order linear equations
Why this exists
Simple harmonic motion took the sine curve of a bouncing weight as given, and nothing in it ever slowed down. Real springs carry dampers and are pushed by motors. The lessons from Constant-coefficient equations to Variation of parameters solve every such model; this lesson reads the solutions: which damping stops the oscillation, how fast free motion dies, and why a force at the natural frequency builds motion without bound when nothing removes energy.
Definition
A body of mass m kilograms moves along a line on a spring. Let y, a function of the time t in seconds, be its displacement in meters from its resting position, positive in one fixed direction (downward for a hanging spring). The spring pulls back with force -ky (Hooke’s law), a damper resists with force -\gamma y', and an applied force F(t) newtons acts. Newton’s second law gives the spring equation
with m > 0, \gamma \ge 0, k > 0. For a hanging spring stretched L meters by the mass at rest, kL = mg with g = 9.8; measured from that rest position, the weight mg and the spring force -k(L + y) add to -ky, so gravity drops out.
- The motion is free if F = 0 and forced otherwise, undamped if \gamma = 0.
- The natural frequency is \displaystyle \omega_0 = \sqrt{k/m} radians per second.
- The critical damping is \displaystyle \gamma_c = 2\sqrt{mk}, where the discriminant \gamma^2 - 4mk of the characteristic equation m r^2 + \gamma r + k = 0 is 0. Free motion is underdamped if 0 < \gamma < \gamma_c, critically damped if \gamma = \gamma_c, overdamped if \gamma > \gamma_c. When underdamped, the roots are \displaystyle -\frac{\gamma}{2m} \pm \beta i with quasi-frequency \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{\omega_0^2 - \frac{\gamma^2}{4m^2}}.
- The energy is \displaystyle E(t) = \frac{1}{2} m\,y'(t)^2 + \frac{1}{2} k\,y(t)^2 joules, kinetic plus spring energy.
- For \gamma > 0 and F = F_0\cos\omega t with F_0 > 0, \omega > 0, the steady periodic solution y_{sp} is the solution of the form a\cos\omega t + b\sin\omega t, written A(\omega)\cos(\omega t - \varphi) with amplitude A(\omega) > 0 and phase lag \varphi. For any solution y, the free solution y - y_{sp} is its transient.
- Resonance is unbounded undamped motion forced at \omega = \omega_0; practical resonance is the \omega_r where A(\omega) is largest.
Intuition
Energy keeps the books: the spring stores it, the damper burns it at the rate \gamma (y')^2, and the force feeds it in at the rate F y'. Light damping drains the swings slowly; heavy damping makes the mass creep home without crossing equilibrium, also slowly, so one value between, \gamma_c, settles fastest.
A force at frequency \omega eventually drags the mass into motion at \omega, and the free motion dies as the transient. Pushed at \omega_0, in step with the velocity, the mass gains energy every cycle, and with no damper nothing takes it away. Pushed a little off \omega_0, the force drifts in and out of step: beats. With a damper, the energy burned grows with the amplitude until the two balance.
Results
1. Energy and uniqueness. Let F be continuous on an open interval I and y a solution of the spring equation on I. Then
So free motion loses energy when \gamma > 0 and keeps it when \gamma = 0. Two solutions on I with the same y(t_0) and y'(t_0) at some t_0 \in I agree on all of I. In particular every solution of m y'' + k y = 0 on I is c_1\cos\omega_0 t + c_2\sin\omega_0 t.
2. Free motion. Let F = 0.
- (a) If \gamma = 0, y = R\cos(\omega_0 t - \delta) with \displaystyle R = \sqrt{y(0)^2 + \big(y'(0)/\omega_0\big)^2} = \sqrt{2E/k}.
- (b) If 0 < \gamma < \gamma_c, y = R\,e^{-\gamma t/(2m)}\cos(\beta t - \delta), where \beta < \omega_0, and \displaystyle y\left(t + \frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right) = e^{-\pi\gamma/(m\beta)}\,y(t) for every t.
- (c) If \gamma = \gamma_c, y = (c_1 + c_2t)\,e^{-\omega_0 t}; if \gamma > \gamma_c, y = c_1e^{r_1t} + c_2e^{r_2t} with r_2 < r_1 < 0. In both cases a solution other than 0 is zero at most once.
- (d) If \gamma > 0, y(t) \to 0 and y'(t) \to 0 as t \to \infty. Let the decay rate \sigma(\gamma) be minus the largest real part of a root. Then \displaystyle \sigma = \frac{\gamma}{2m} for \gamma \le \gamma_c and \displaystyle \sigma = \frac{\gamma - \sqrt{\gamma^2 - 4mk}}{2m} for \gamma \ge \gamma_c; it increases strictly on [0, \gamma_c], decreases strictly on [\gamma_c, \infty) toward 0, and its largest value is \sigma(\gamma_c) = \omega_0.
3. Forcing without damping. Let \gamma = 0.
- (a) If F = F_0\cos\omega t with \omega \ne \omega_0, the solution with y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0 is
and every solution is bounded.
- (b) If F = F_0\cos\omega_0 t, the solution with y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0 is y = \dfrac{F_0}{2m\omega_0}\,t\sin\omega_0 t, and every solution is unbounded on [0, \infty).
- (c) For any continuous F on an interval containing 0, the solution with y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0 is
4. Forcing with damping. Let \gamma > 0 and F = F_0\cos\omega t with F_0 > 0, \omega > 0. There is exactly one solution of the form a\cos\omega t + b\sin\omega t, namely y_{sp} = A\cos(\omega t - \varphi) with
and \varphi \in (0, \pi) given by \displaystyle \cos\varphi = \frac{(k - m\omega^2)A}{F_0}, \displaystyle \sin\varphi = \frac{\gamma\omega A}{F_0}. Every solution y has y - y_{sp} \to 0 and y' - y_{sp}' \to 0 as t \to \infty.
5. Practical resonance. Under the hypotheses of Result 4, if \gamma^2 < 2mk, then A has its largest value on (0, \infty) exactly at
If \gamma^2 \ge 2mk, A decreases strictly on (0, \infty) and stays below \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{k}. As \gamma \to 0 with m, k, F_0 fixed, \omega_r \to \omega_0 and A(\omega_r) \to \infty.
Why it is true
Result 1. By the chain rule, E' = m y' y'' + k y y' = y'(m y'' + k y) = y'(F - \gamma y').
For uniqueness, let z be the difference of the two solutions. It solves the free equation with z(t_0) = z'(t_0) = 0, so its energy E_z \ge 0 has E_z(t_0) = 0. For t \ge t_0, E_z' = -\gamma (z')^2 \le 0 gives E_z(t) \le E_z(t_0) = 0. For t \le t_0, put \displaystyle c = \frac{2\gamma}{m}; then
so e^{ct}E_z(t) \le e^{ct_0}E_z(t_0) = 0. Thus E_z = 0 on I, and since k > 0, z = 0. For the last claim, matching a given solution’s value and slope at t_0 by c_1\cos\omega_0 t + c_2\sin\omega_0 t is a linear system with determinant \omega_0 \ne 0 (Computing a determinant); by uniqueness the two agree. This settles the claim Differential equations and their solutions stated without proof. \square
Result 2. The roots of m r^2 + \gamma r + k = 0 are \displaystyle \frac{-\gamma \pm \sqrt{\gamma^2 - 4mk}}{2m}. (a) and (b) are Result 4 of Complex and repeated roots with \displaystyle \alpha = -\frac{\gamma}{2m}. In (a), c_1 = y(0) and \displaystyle c_2 = \frac{y'(0)}{\omega_0}, so \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}kR^2 = \frac{1}{2}k\,y(0)^2 + \frac{1}{2}m\,y'(0)^2 = E. In (b), adding \displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{\beta} to t leaves the cosine unchanged and multiplies the exponential by e^{-\pi\gamma/(m\beta)}.
(c) At \gamma = \gamma_c the double root is \displaystyle -\frac{\gamma_c}{2m} = -\omega_0, and (c_1 + c_2t)\,e^{-\omega_0 t} vanishes only where c_1 + c_2t does. For \gamma > \gamma_c the roots are real with product \displaystyle \frac{k}{m} > 0 and sum \displaystyle -\frac{\gamma}{m} < 0, so both are negative, and c_1e^{r_1t} + c_2e^{r_2t} = e^{r_2t}\big(c_1e^{(r_1 - r_2)t} + c_2\big) vanishes only where the bracket does, which is strictly monotone if c_1 \ne 0 and the nonzero constant c_2 if c_1 = 0.
(d) Each term in (b) and (c) is e^{\rho t} or t\,e^{\rho t} with \rho < 0, times a bounded factor, so it tends to 0; and y' is a free solution too. For \gamma \le \gamma_c the largest real part is \displaystyle -\frac{\gamma}{2m}, so \sigma rises to \displaystyle \frac{\gamma_c}{2m} = \omega_0. For \gamma \ge \gamma_c it is r_1, and multiplying by the conjugate,
whose denominator increases strictly without bound; at \gamma_c it equals \displaystyle \frac{2k}{2\sqrt{mk}} = \omega_0. \square
Result 3. (c) is Result 3 of Variation of parameters with a = m: the function \displaystyle g = \frac{\sin\omega_0 t}{m\omega_0} solves the homogeneous equation with g(0) = 0 and \displaystyle g'(0) = \frac{1}{m}.
(a) The trial a\cos\omega t (Undetermined coefficients) gives m(\omega_0^2 - \omega^2)\,a = F_0. Subtracting a\cos\omega_0 t makes the value 0 at t = 0, and both terms have slope 0 there. The product form is \displaystyle \cos P - \cos Q = 2\sin\frac{Q + P}{2}\sin\frac{Q - P}{2}. By Result 1 every solution adds c_1\cos\omega_0 t + c_2\sin\omega_0 t, so |y| \le 2|a| + |c_1| + |c_2|.
(b) By (c) and \displaystyle \sin P\cos Q = \frac{1}{2}\big(\sin(P + Q) + \sin(P - Q)\big),
because the second integrand has antiderivative \displaystyle \frac{\cos(\omega_0 t - 2\omega_0 s)}{2\omega_0} in s, equal at s = 0 and s = t. Multiplying by \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{m\omega_0} gives y. Any other solution adds y_h with |y_h| \le |c_1| + |c_2|, and at \displaystyle t_n = \frac{(2n + 1/2)\pi}{\omega_0}, where \sin\omega_0 t_n = 1, it is at least \displaystyle \frac{F_0 t_n}{2m\omega_0} - |c_1| - |c_2|, which tends to \infty. \square
Result 4. Let p(r) = m r^2 + \gamma r + k. Then p(i\omega) = (k - m\omega^2) + i\gamma\omega has positive imaginary part, so p(i\omega) = |p(i\omega)|\,e^{i\varphi} with \varphi \in (0, \pi). By Result 3 of Undetermined coefficients, with i\omega not a root, the real part of \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{p(i\omega)}\,e^{i\omega t}, which is \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{|p(i\omega)|}\cos(\omega t - \varphi), solves the equation; this is A\cos(\omega t - \varphi). Two such solutions differ by a free solution R\cos(\omega t - \delta), which tends to 0 by Result 2(d), so R = 0. Last, Result 2(d) applies to the free solution y - y_{sp}. \square
Result 5. Maximizing A is minimizing D(u) = (k - mu)^2 + \gamma^2 u = m^2u^2 - (2mk - \gamma^2)\,u + k^2 over u = \omega^2 > 0. This parabola has its vertex at \displaystyle u^* = \frac{2mk - \gamma^2}{2m^2} = \omega_0^2 - \frac{\gamma^2}{2m^2}. If \gamma^2 < 2mk then u^* > 0, \gamma < \gamma_c so \beta is defined, and
If \gamma^2 \ge 2mk then u^* \le 0, so D increases strictly on (0, \infty) from D(0) = k^2. As \gamma \to 0, u^* \to \omega_0^2 and \gamma\beta \to 0. \square
Worked examples
Amara’s sorting deck in free motion
At the scrapyard, Amara installs a vibrating sorting deck of mass 400 kilograms on spring mounts, which sink 0.0245 meters under it. Before the dampers are attached she pushes the deck 0.01 meters down and lets it go moving upward at 0.3 meters per second. Find k, \omega_0, y(t) in amplitude-phase form, the period and the energy.
SolutionWith y positive downward, kL = mg gives \displaystyle k = \frac{400 \cdot 9.8}{0.0245} = 160{,}000 newtons per meter, and \displaystyle \omega_0 = \sqrt{160{,}000/400} = 20 radians per second. Here y(0) = 0.01 and y'(0) = -0.3, so by Result 2(a)
Its amplitude is \displaystyle R = \sqrt{0.01^2 + 0.015^2} = \sqrt{0.000325} \approx 0.01803 meters, and \cos\delta > 0 > \sin\delta gives \delta = -\arctan 1.5 \approx -0.9828 (Combining a sine and a cosine into one wave). The period is \displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{20} = \frac{\pi}{10} \approx 0.3142 seconds. The energy is
matching \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}kR^2 = 80{,}000 \cdot 0.000325.
The knock test
Malik attaches the dampers and knocks the deck. The recorder shows the deck oscillating, each high point of y half the one before. Find \gamma, compare it with \gamma_c, and find the quasi-period.
SolutionThe deck oscillates, so by Result 2(c) it is underdamped. Its velocity is a free solution, with zeros \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{\beta} apart (Complex and repeated roots), so consecutive high points are \displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{\beta} apart and by Result 2(b) their ratio is \displaystyle e^{-\pi\gamma/(m\beta)} = \frac{1}{2}. Write \displaystyle x = \frac{\gamma}{2m}, so that \beta^2 = 400 - x^2; the ratio condition says \displaystyle \frac{2\pi x}{\beta} = \ln 2. Then \displaystyle x^2\left(1 + \frac{4\pi^2}{(\ln 2)^2}\right) = 400 and
So \gamma = 800x \approx 1754 newton-seconds per meter. Critical damping is \displaystyle \gamma_c = 2\sqrt{mk} = 16{,}000, so \gamma \approx 0.110\,\gamma_c. Then \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{400 - x^2} \approx 19.879 and the quasi-period is \displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{\beta} \approx 0.3161 seconds.
A short proof: never faster than the start
Prove that for every \gamma \ge 0, free motion released from rest at y(0) = y_0 has |y(t)| \le |y_0| and |y'(t)| \le \omega_0|y_0| for all t \ge 0, and that the speed bound is reached when \gamma = 0.
SolutionBy Result 1 with F = 0, E' = -\gamma (y')^2 \le 0, so for t \ge 0, \displaystyle E(t) \le E(0) = \frac{1}{2}k y_0^2. Both terms of E are nonnegative, so \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}k y(t)^2 \le \frac{1}{2}k y_0^2 gives |y(t)| \le |y_0|, and \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}m\,y'(t)^2 \le \frac{1}{2}k y_0^2 gives \displaystyle |y'(t)| \le \sqrt{k/m}\,|y_0| = \omega_0|y_0|. For \gamma = 0 the motion y_0\cos\omega_0 t has speed \omega_0|y_0| at \displaystyle t = \frac{\pi}{2\omega_0}. \square
Beats on the test stand
With the dampers off, a shaker pushes Amara’s deck with force 304\cos 18t newtons, starting from rest at equilibrium. Find y(t) and the largest displacement.
SolutionHere \omega = 18 \ne \omega_0 = 20, and \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{m(\omega_0^2 - \omega^2)} = \frac{304}{400 \cdot 76} = 0.01. By Result 3(a)
The slow factor 0.02\sin t is an envelope for a fast oscillation of period \displaystyle \frac{2\pi}{19} \approx 0.331 seconds. So |y| \le 0.02, and at \displaystyle t = \frac{\pi}{2}, \displaystyle \sin 19t = \sin\frac{19\pi}{2} = -1, so y = -0.02: the largest displacement is 0.02 meters. The envelope falls to 0 every \pi seconds (Figure 1).
Pushed at the natural frequency
The shaker is set to 304\cos 20t, again from rest at equilibrium, with the dampers off. Stops limit the deck to |y| \le 0.05 meters. When does the deck reach them?
SolutionNow \omega = \omega_0, and Result 3(b) gives
The envelope 0.019\,t reaches 0.05 at \displaystyle t = \frac{50}{19} \approx 2.632 seconds. The deck first reaches |y| = 0.05 near the peak of |\sin 20t| at \displaystyle 20t = \frac{35\pi}{2}, at t \approx 2.735 seconds (numerically; Figure 2).
New dampers, steady state and transient
Malik fits new dampers with \gamma = 4000. The shaker applies 1600\cos 20t from rest at equilibrium. Find y(t), the amplitude and lag of the steady motion, a time after which the transient stays below 0.001 meters, and the shaker frequency giving the largest steady amplitude.
SolutionSince \gamma < \gamma_c = 16{,}000, the roots are \displaystyle -\frac{4000}{800} \pm \beta i = -5 \pm \beta i with \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{400 - 25} = 5\sqrt{15} \approx 19.365. At \omega = 20 = \omega_0, k - m\omega^2 = 0 and p(20i) = 80{,}000i, so by Result 4, \displaystyle A = \frac{1600}{80{,}000} = 0.02, \displaystyle \varphi = \frac{\pi}{2} and y_{sp} = 0.02\sin 20t. Adding the transient,
with y(0) = c_1 = 0 and y'(0) = 0.4 + \beta c_2 = 0, so \displaystyle c_2 = -\frac{0.4}{\beta} = -\frac{0.08}{\sqrt{15}} \approx -0.02066. The transient is at most 0.02066\,e^{-5t} in size, below 0.001 once \displaystyle t > \frac{1}{5}\ln 20.66 \approx 0.606 seconds.
The lag \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2} puts the force in step with the velocity 0.4\cos 20t, feeding energy at the rate 640\cos^2 20t \ge 0. Since \gamma^2 < 2mk, Result 5 gives the largest amplitude at \displaystyle \omega_r = \sqrt{400 - 50} = \sqrt{350} \approx 18.71, equal to \displaystyle \frac{1600}{4000 \cdot 5\sqrt{15}} \approx 0.02066 meters (Figure 3).
The eccentric motor
In service the deck is driven by a motor spinning an off-center weight with unbalance U = 4 kilogram-meters (mass times offset). At angular speed \omega it pushes the deck with force U\omega^2\cos\omega t. With \gamma = 4000, find the speed at which the steady amplitude is largest, that amplitude, the amplitude at the running speed 100 radians per second, and its limit at high speed.
SolutionResult 4 holds at each fixed \omega, with F_0 = U\omega^2, so
As F_0 now grows with \omega, Result 5 does not apply. Dividing inside the root by \omega^4 and writing \displaystyle v = \frac{1}{\omega^2}, maximizing A_U is minimizing k^2v^2 - (2mk - \gamma^2)\,v + m^2. Its vertex is at \displaystyle v^* = \frac{2mk - \gamma^2}{2k^2} = \frac{7}{3200}, so \displaystyle \omega_p = \sqrt{3200/7} \approx 21.38 radians per second, above \omega_0. The least value is \displaystyle \frac{\gamma^2(4mk - \gamma^2)}{4k^2}, and since \displaystyle \sqrt{4mk - \gamma^2} = 2m\beta,
At the running speed, k - m\omega^2 = -3.84 \times 10^6 and \gamma\omega = 4 \times 10^5, so A_U(100) \approx 0.01036 meters, and as \omega \to \infty, \displaystyle A_U \to \frac{U}{m} = 0.01. Here \displaystyle \omega_r\,\omega_p = \sqrt{350 \cdot 3200/7} = 400 = \omega_0^2 (Exercise 18).
Boundaries
- The model is linear. Dry friction, a stiffening spring or a pendulum at large angles (Nonlinear systems and linearization) gives a nonlinear equation.
- Unbounded resonance needs \gamma = 0 exactly. With \gamma > 0 the steady amplitude is at most \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{\gamma\beta} or \displaystyle \frac{F_0}{k} (Result 5).
- A peak needs \displaystyle \gamma < \gamma_c/\sqrt{2}. For \displaystyle \gamma_c/\sqrt{2} \le \gamma < \gamma_c free motion oscillates, but A has no peak.
- Other periodic forces are sums of sinusoids (Fourier series); each gets its own amplitude, and an undamped system resonates if any of their frequencies equals \omega_0 (Exercise 8).
Where this goes next
The Laplace transform handles forces that switch on suddenly or arrive as a blow, like Malik’s knock. Linear systems of differential equations couples two masses by springs. Phase portraits draws the motion in the plane of y and y': a center when undamped, a spiral when underdamped, a node when overdamped. Fourier series splits a periodic force into the sinusoids of Result 4.
Exercises
Free motion
- A 0.5 kilogram mass stretches a spring 0.098 meters at rest. It is pulled 0.03 meters below rest and given a downward velocity of 0.4 meters per second, with no damping. Find k, \omega_0, y(t) in the form R\cos(\omega_0 t - \delta), and the energy.
- A 2 kilogram mass hangs on a spring with k = 50. For \gamma = 12, \gamma = 20 and \gamma = 29, classify the free motion, give the roots and give the decay rate \sigma.
- With \gamma = 12 in Exercise 2, the mass is released from rest at y = 0.1. Find y(t), the quasi-period, the ratio of consecutive high points, and the ratio of energies one quasi-period apart.
- Mei’s test mass of 5 kilograms oscillates with quasi-period 0.6 seconds, each high point one quarter of the one before. Find \gamma and k.
Forcing without damping
- Solve y'' + 25y = 3\cos 4t, y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0, write the solution as a product, and find the largest value of |y|.
- Solve 2y'' + 32y = 10\cos 4t, y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0. When does the envelope reach 5?
- Use Result 3(c) to solve y'' + 9y = 6\sin 3t, y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0.
- An undamped system has m = 0.5 and k = 50, and the force is \cos\omega t + \cos 3\omega t. For which \omega > 0 are the solutions unbounded?
Forcing with damping
- Find the steady periodic solution of y'' + 2y' + 17y = 20\cos 3t, its amplitude and its phase lag.
- Solve the equation of Exercise 9 with y(0) = 0, y'(0) = 0, and name the transient.
- For y'' + 2y' + 17y = 20\cos\omega t, find the practical resonance frequency, the largest amplitude, and the amplitude at \omega = \omega_0.
- For y'' + \gamma y' + 17y = 20\cos\omega t, which \gamma > 0 give practical resonance? Describe A(\omega) for \gamma = 6.
- Before the new dampers, Amara’s deck had \gamma = 1750 (Example 2, rounded). The shaker applies 1600\cos\omega t. Find the steady amplitude at \omega = 20, the practical resonance frequency and the largest amplitude. Does the steady motion reach the stops at 0.05 meters?
- Malik fits a heavier eccentric with U = 6 and stiffer dampers with \gamma = 8000. Find the speed of largest steady amplitude, that amplitude, the amplitude at 100 radians per second, and its limit at high speed.
Proofs
- Let \gamma > 0 and y a free solution on \mathbb{R}. Prove that E is strictly decreasing unless y = 0.
- Let \gamma > 0, F = F_0\cos\omega t and \displaystyle T = \frac{2\pi}{\omega}. Prove that \int_0^T F\,y_{sp}'\,dt = \gamma\int_0^T (y_{sp}')^2\,dt = \pi\gamma\omega A^2.
- In Result 4, prove that the phase lag \varphi(\omega) increases strictly on (0, \infty), tends to 0 as \omega \to 0 and to \pi as \omega \to \infty, and equals \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2} exactly at \omega_0.
- Let \gamma > 0, U > 0, let A be the amplitude of Result 4 with F_0 = U\omega_0^2, and A_U that of Example 7. Prove that \displaystyle A_U\!\left(\frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega}\right) = A(\omega) for every \omega > 0, and deduce that when \gamma^2 < 2mk, \omega_r\,\omega_p = \omega_0^2 and the two peaks have the same height.
- Prove that for each fixed t, the solution in Result 3(a) tends to the solution in Result 3(b) as \omega \to \omega_0.
Answers
- \displaystyle k = \frac{0.5 \cdot 9.8}{0.098} = 50, \omega_0 = 10, y = 0.03\cos 10t + 0.04\sin 10t = 0.05\cos(10t - \delta) with \displaystyle \delta = \arctan\frac{4}{3} \approx 0.9273, and E = 0.04 + 0.0225 = 0.0625 joules, equal to \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}(50)(0.05)^2.
- Here \gamma_c = 20. For \gamma = 12: roots -3 \pm 4i, underdamped, \sigma = 3. For \gamma = 20: -5 twice, critically damped, \sigma = 5 = \omega_0. For \gamma = 29: roots -2 and -12.5, overdamped, \sigma = 2.
- y = e^{-3t}(0.1\cos 4t + 0.075\sin 4t), from c_1 = 0.1 and -3c_1 + 4c_2 = 0. The quasi-period is \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2} and the ratio of high points e^{-3\pi/2} \approx 0.00898; y and y' both scale by it, so energies scale by e^{-3\pi} \approx 8.07 \times 10^{-5}.
- \gamma \approx 23.10 and k \approx 575.0. The ratio gives \displaystyle \alpha = \frac{\ln 0.25}{0.6} \approx -2.3105 and \gamma = -2m\alpha; \displaystyle \beta = \frac{2\pi}{0.6} \approx 10.472; the roots \alpha \pm \beta i have product \displaystyle \frac{k}{m} = \alpha^2 + \beta^2.
- \displaystyle y = \frac{1}{3}(\cos 4t - \cos 5t) = \frac{2}{3}\sin\frac{t}{2}\,\sin\frac{9t}{2}, by Result 3(a) with \omega_0 = 5. So \displaystyle |y| \le \frac{2}{3}, and \displaystyle y(\pi) = \frac{1}{3}(1 + 1) = \frac{2}{3} is the largest value.
- \displaystyle y = \frac{5}{8}\,t\sin 4t, by Result 3(b) with m = 2, \omega_0 = 4, F_0 = 10. The envelope \displaystyle \frac{5}{8}t reaches 5 at t = 8.
- \displaystyle y = \frac{1}{3}\sin 3t - t\cos 3t. Result 3(c) gives y = 2\int_0^t \sin 3(t - s)\sin 3s\,ds, and \displaystyle \sin P\sin Q = \frac{1}{2}\big(\cos(P - Q) - \cos(P + Q)\big) makes the integral \displaystyle \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\sin 3t}{3} - t\cos 3t\right).
- \omega = 10 and \displaystyle \omega = \frac{10}{3}. Here \omega_0 = 10; by superposition and Result 3 the response is unbounded exactly when \omega or 3\omega equals \omega_0.
- y_{sp} = 1.6\cos 3t + 1.2\sin 3t = 2\cos(3t - \varphi), amplitude 2, lag \displaystyle \varphi = \arctan\frac{3}{4} \approx 0.6435. Here p(3i) = 8 + 6i, |p(3i)| = 10, and \displaystyle \frac{20}{8 + 6i} = 1.6 - 1.2i.
- y = y_{sp} - e^{-t}(1.6\cos 4t + 1.3\sin 4t), with y_{sp} = 1.6\cos 3t + 1.2\sin 3t from Exercise 9. The roots are -1 \pm 4i; c_1 = -1.6 and -c_1 + 4c_2 + 3.6 = 0 give c_2 = -1.3. The transient is the last term.
- \displaystyle \omega_r = \sqrt{17 - 2} = \sqrt{15} \approx 3.873; with \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{17 - 1} = 4 the largest amplitude is \displaystyle \frac{20}{2 \cdot 4} = 2.5; at \displaystyle \omega_0 = \sqrt{17}, \displaystyle A = \frac{20}{2\sqrt{17}} \approx 2.425.
- Exactly \displaystyle 0 < \gamma < \sqrt{34} \approx 5.831, from \gamma^2 < 2mk = 34. For \gamma = 6, A decreases strictly on (0, \infty), stays below \displaystyle \frac{20}{17} \approx 1.176 and tends to it as \omega \to 0.
- \displaystyle A(20) = \frac{1600}{1750 \cdot 20} \approx 0.0457 meters. \displaystyle \omega_r = \sqrt{400 - 1750^2/320{,}000} \approx 19.76, and with \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{400 - (1750/800)^2} \approx 19.880 the largest amplitude is \displaystyle \frac{1600}{1750\beta} \approx 0.0460 meters: inside the stops, by less than 5 millimeters.
- \displaystyle v^* = \frac{2mk - \gamma^2}{2k^2} = \frac{1}{800}, so \displaystyle \omega_p = \sqrt{800} \approx 28.28; with \displaystyle \beta = \sqrt{400 - 100} = 10\sqrt{3} the largest amplitude is \displaystyle \frac{6 \cdot 400}{8000 \cdot 10\sqrt{3}} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{100} \approx 0.01732 meters; A_U(100) \approx 0.01530 meters; the limit is \displaystyle \frac{U}{m} = 0.015.
- E' = -\gamma (y')^2 \le 0, so E is nonincreasing. If E(t_1) = E(t_2) with t_1 < t_2, then E' = 0 on [t_1, t_2], so y' = 0 and y is a constant c there; then y'' = 0 and the equation gives kc = 0, so c = 0. Then y(t_1) = y'(t_1) = 0, and by Result 1, y = 0. \square
- By Result 1, E' = F y_{sp}' - \gamma(y_{sp}')^2 for the energy of y_{sp}, which has period T; so E(T) = E(0), and integrating E' over [0, T] gives the first equality. With y_{sp}' = -A\omega\sin(\omega t - \varphi) and \displaystyle \int_0^T \sin^2(\omega t - \varphi)\,dt = \frac{\pi}{\omega}, the integral is \displaystyle \gamma A^2\omega^2\frac{\pi}{\omega} = \pi\gamma\omega A^2. \square
- Since \sin\varphi > 0, \displaystyle \cot\varphi = \frac{k}{\gamma\omega} - \frac{m\omega}{\gamma}, which decreases strictly on (0, \infty) from \infty to -\infty. The cotangent is a decreasing bijection of (0, \pi) onto \mathbb{R}, so \varphi increases strictly, with the stated limits. \displaystyle \varphi = \frac{\pi}{2} exactly when \cot\varphi = 0, that is m\omega^2 = k. \square
- Let \displaystyle D(\omega) = \sqrt{(k - m\omega^2)^2 + \gamma^2\omega^2} and \displaystyle \omega' = \frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega}. Then \displaystyle k - m\omega'^2 = \frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega^2}(m\omega^2 - k) and \displaystyle \gamma^2\omega'^2 = \frac{\omega_0^4}{\omega^4}\gamma^2\omega^2, so \displaystyle D(\omega') = \frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega^2}D(\omega) and \displaystyle A_U(\omega') = \frac{U\omega_0^4/\omega^2}{(\omega_0^2/\omega^2)D(\omega)} = A(\omega). As \displaystyle \omega \mapsto \frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega} is a bijection of (0, \infty), A_U has its unique maximum at \displaystyle \frac{\omega_0^2}{\omega_r} (Result 5), with the same value. \square
- Write \omega_0^2 - \omega^2 = -(\omega - \omega_0)(\omega + \omega_0), so \displaystyle y = \frac{F_0}{m(\omega + \omega_0)}\cdot\frac{\cos\omega t - \cos\omega_0 t}{-(\omega - \omega_0)}. As \omega \to \omega_0 the difference quotient tends to the derivative of \cos\omega t in \omega at \omega_0, which is -t\sin\omega_0 t, so \displaystyle y \to \frac{F_0}{2m\omega_0}\,t\sin\omega_0 t. \square