Limits and continuity in the complex plane
In the plane a point can be approached from every direction at once. What does \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = L mean then, which sets are the right homes for complex functions, and where is the principal logarithm continuous?
Where you are 6 in Complex functions
Why this exists
Limits of functions, epsilon and delta took limits of f : S \to \mathbb{R} at a limit point of S \subseteq \mathbb{R}, approached from the left or the right. In \mathbb{C} the distance |z - z_0| of The complex plane, revisited allows the same definition, but z may arrive along any line, spiral or sequence, and the limit must ignore all of these differences; the derivative of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations inherits that strength. This lesson also sets up open, closed and connected sets and regions, and finds where the principal logarithm of The complex exponential and logarithm is continuous and how it jumps.
Definition
Throughout, S \subseteq \mathbb{C} and D(a, r) = \{z : |z - a| < r\}.
Points and sets. Let G \subseteq \mathbb{C}.
- a \in G is an interior point of G if D(a, r) \subseteq G for some r > 0.
- b \in \mathbb{C} is a boundary point of G if every D(b, r) contains a point of G and a point not in G.
- c \in \mathbb{C} is a limit point of G if every D(c, r) contains a point of G other than c (Beck: accumulation point).
- d \in G is an isolated point of G if some D(d, r) contains no point of G but d.
G is open if all its points are interior, and closed if it contains all its boundary points. The boundary \partial G is the set of boundary points, the closure is \overline{G} = G \cup \partial G, and G is bounded if G \subseteq D(0, r) for some r. On the line these are the notions of Open, closed and compact sets in R.
Connected sets and regions. Sets X, Y are separated if there are disjoint open sets U \supseteq X and V \supseteq Y. A set is connected if it is not the union of two separated nonempty sets. A path is a continuous map \gamma : [a, b] \to \mathbb{C}. A region is a nonempty open connected set, usually called G; many books say domain.
Limits. Let f : S \to \mathbb{C}, z_0 a limit point of S and L \in \mathbb{C}. Then \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = L if for every \varepsilon > 0 there is a \delta > 0 with |f(z) - L| < \varepsilon for every z \in S such that 0 < |z - z_0| < \delta. So f carries the points of S in the punctured disk D(z_0, \delta) \setminus \{z_0\} into D(L, \varepsilon); z_0 need not be in S, and f(z_0) plays no part.
Continuity. f is continuous at z_0 \in S if for every \varepsilon > 0 there is a \delta > 0 with |f(z) - f(z_0)| < \varepsilon for all z \in S with |z - z_0| < \delta, and continuous on S if it is continuous at every point of S. At a limit point of S this says \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = f(z_0); at an isolated point it always holds. Real-valued functions such as \operatorname{Arg} are covered too.
Intuition
On the line a point has two sides. In the plane, 0 < |z - z_0| < \delta is a whole punctured disk, and all of it, every direction and every curve inside, must land in the \varepsilon-disk about L (Figure 1). Two routes with different limits prove there is no limit; agreeing routes prove nothing, as Limits and continuity in several variables shows with a function that agrees along every line and has no limit. An open set holds a disk about each of its points, which is why derivatives will live on open sets.
Results
1. Real and imaginary parts. Let f = u + iv on S, z_0 a limit point of S and L = a + ib. Then \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = L if and only if u(z) \to a and v(z) \to b. So f is continuous at z_0 \in S exactly when u and v are.
2. Laws. A limit is unique when it exists. If f \to A and g \to B as z \to z_0, then f + g \to A + B, fg \to AB and, when B \ne 0, \displaystyle \frac{f}{g} \to \frac{A}{B}. The functions z, \overline{z}, \operatorname{Re} z, \operatorname{Im} z and |z| are continuous on \mathbb{C}; so polynomials in z and \overline{z} are continuous on \mathbb{C}, and a quotient of two is continuous where its denominator is not 0.
3. Restrictions. If \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = L, T \subseteq S and z_0 is a limit point of T, then f|_T \to L at z_0. So if f|_{T_1} \to L_1 and f|_{T_2} \to L_2 with L_1 \ne L_2, then f has no limit at z_0.
4. Composition. If \lim_{z \to z_0} g(z) = w_0, the values of g lie in the domain of f, and f is continuous at w_0, then \lim_{z \to z_0} f(g(z)) = f(w_0). Compositions of continuous functions are continuous.
5. The exponential. e^{z}, \cos z, \sin z, \cosh z and \sinh z are continuous on \mathbb{C}.
6. Argument and logarithm. On the slit plane \mathbb{C} \setminus (-\infty, 0],
and \operatorname{Arg}, \operatorname{Log} and every principal power z^{\alpha} are continuous there. At each x_0 < 0, \operatorname{Arg} z \to \pi as z \to x_0 through \operatorname{Im} z \ge 0 and \operatorname{Arg} z \to -\pi through \operatorname{Im} z < 0. So \operatorname{Log} z tends to \ln|x_0| \pm \pi i from above and below, a jump of 2\pi i, and neither \operatorname{Arg} nor \operatorname{Log} has a limit at any point of (-\infty, 0).
7. Regions and paths. If any two points of G are joined by a path in G, then G is connected. If G is open and connected, any two of its points are joined by a chain of horizontal and vertical segments in G. So a nonempty open set is a region exactly when any two of its points are joined by a path in it.
Why it is true
Result 1. Proof. By Result 2 of The complex plane, revisited, |u(z) - a| and |v(z) - b| are at most |f(z) - L|, which is at most |u(z) - a| + |v(z) - b|. So a \delta serving \varepsilon for f serves it for u and v, and one serving \displaystyle \frac{\varepsilon}{2} for both u and v serves \varepsilon for f. \blacksquare
Result 2. Proof. Uniqueness. If f \to L and f \to L' \ne L, take \displaystyle \varepsilon = \frac{|L - L'|}{2} and the smaller \delta. As z_0 is a limit point, some z \in S has 0 < |z - z_0| < \delta, and then |L - L'| \le |L - f(z)| + |f(z) - L'| < |L - L'|, which is impossible.
Sum. |(f + g) - (A + B)| \le |f - A| + |g - B|. Product. Take \delta so small that |g - B| < 1, \displaystyle |f - A| < \frac{\varepsilon}{2(|B| + 1)} and \displaystyle |g - B| < \frac{\varepsilon}{2(|A| + 1)} on the punctured disk. Then |g| < |B| + 1 and |fg - AB| \le |f - A|\,|g| + |A|\,|g - B| < \varepsilon.
Quotient. Where \displaystyle |g - B| < \frac{|B|}{2}, the reverse triangle inequality gives \displaystyle |g| > \frac{|B|}{2}, so g \ne 0 and \displaystyle \left|\frac{1}{g} - \frac{1}{B}\right| = \frac{|B - g|}{|g|\,|B|} < \frac{2|g - B|}{|B|^2}, below \varepsilon once also \displaystyle |g - B| < \frac{\varepsilon|B|^2}{2}. So \displaystyle \frac{1}{g} \to \frac{1}{B}, and the product law finishes.
Basic functions. |\overline{z} - \overline{z_0}|, |\operatorname{Re}(z - z_0)|, |\operatorname{Im}(z - z_0)| and \big||z| - |z_0|\big| are all at most |z - z_0|, so \delta = \varepsilon works, and the laws carry continuity to sums, products and quotients. \blacksquare
Result 3. Proof. A \delta serving \varepsilon on S serves it on T. If f had a limit L, both restrictions would tend to L, forcing L_1 = L = L_2. \blacksquare
Result 4. Proof. Given \varepsilon, continuity gives \eta with |f(w) - f(w_0)| < \varepsilon when |w - w_0| < \eta, and the limit of g gives \delta with |g(z) - w_0| < \eta when z \in S and 0 < |z - z_0| < \delta. Chain the two. \blacksquare
Result 5. Proof. Let w = a + ib. By Result 1 of The complex exponential and logarithm,
and \displaystyle |e^{ib} - 1|^2 = (\cos b - 1)^2 + \sin^2 b = 4\sin^2\frac{b}{2} \le b^2. As w \to 0, |a| and |b| are at most |w|, so e^{a} \to 1 and |e^{ib} - 1| \le |b| \to 0. Thus e^{w} \to 1, and e^{z} - e^{z_0} = e^{z_0}(e^{z - z_0} - 1) \to 0. The other four functions are built from e^{\pm z} and e^{\pm iz}, so Results 2 and 4 apply. \blacksquare
Result 6. Proof. Let z = x + iy be off (-\infty, 0], r = |z| and \theta = \operatorname{Arg} z \in (-\pi, \pi). Then r + x = r(1 + \cos\theta) > 0, and the double-angle identities of Trigonometric identities give
As \displaystyle \frac{\theta}{2} \in (-\frac{\pi}{2}, \frac{\pi}{2}), \displaystyle \frac{\theta}{2} = \arctan\frac{y}{r + x}. The formula’s right side is built from y, the positive |z| + x and the continuous \arctan, so it is continuous by Results 2 and 4; then so are \operatorname{Log} z = \ln|z| + i\operatorname{Arg} z and z^{\alpha} = e^{\alpha\operatorname{Log} z}, by Results 4 and 5.
For the jump: \displaystyle \cos\theta = \frac{x}{|z|} for z \ne 0, with \theta \in [0, \pi] when y \ge 0 and \theta \in (-\pi, 0) when y < 0, so \displaystyle \operatorname{Arg} z = \arccos\frac{x}{|z|} for y \ge 0 and \displaystyle -\arccos\frac{x}{|z|} for y < 0. As z \to x_0 < 0, \displaystyle \frac{x}{|z|} \to -1, and \arccos is continuous with \arccos(-1) = \pi, giving the limits \pm\pi. Both half-planes have x_0 as a limit point, so Result 3 rules out a limit of \operatorname{Arg}, and Result 1 one of \operatorname{Log}. \blacksquare
Result 7. Proof. The first sentence is stated without proof here; it rests on the connectedness of [a, b] and of continuous images of connected sets, proved in Connectedness.
For the second, fix p \in G, let A be the set of points of G joined to p by such a chain, and B = G \setminus A. Take w \in G and D(w, r) \subseteq G. A point q of the disk is joined to w by the horizontal segment from w to \operatorname{Re} q + i\operatorname{Im} w and the vertical one on to q; on them the real and imaginary parts of s - w are at most those of q - w in size, so |s - w| \le |q - w| < r. Hence if w \in A the disk lies in A, and if w \in B it misses A. So A and B are open, disjoint, hence separated, with union G; as p \in A and G is connected, B = \varnothing. \blacksquare
Worked examples
A limit from the definition
Let f(z) = z^2 - 2z. Prove that \lim_{z \to 1 - i} f(z) = -2.
SolutionWe need a \delta with |z^2 - 2z + 2| < \varepsilon whenever 0 < |z - (1 - i)| < \delta. The quadratic z^2 - 2z + 2 = (z - 1)^2 + 1 has roots 1 \pm i, so
The second factor only has to stay bounded. If |z - (1 - i)| < 1, the triangle inequality gives |z - (1 + i)| \le |z - (1 - i)| + |{-2i}| < 3. So let \displaystyle \delta = \min\{1, \frac{\varepsilon}{3}\}: if 0 < |z - (1 - i)| < \delta, then |z^2 - 2z + 2| < 3\delta \le \varepsilon. \blacksquare
Figure 1 shows \displaystyle \varepsilon = \frac{3}{2}, \displaystyle \delta = \frac{1}{2}. As f(1 - i) = -2, f is continuous at 1 - i.
Cancelling, and a quotient with a conjugate
Find \lim_{z \to i} \dfrac{z^4 - 1}{z - i}, and decide whether \lim_{z \to i} \dfrac{z^4 - 1}{\overline{z} + i} exists.
SolutionSince i^4 = 1, z^4 - 1 = (z - i)(z + i)(z^2 - 1). For z \ne i the first quotient equals p(z) = (z + i)(z^2 - 1), and the limit ignores the value at i, so by Result 2 the limit is p(i) = 2i \cdot (-2) = -4i.
In the second, \overline{z} + i = \overline{z - i}, so with h = z - i,
On the horizontal line z = i + t, t real and nonzero, \displaystyle \frac{h}{\overline{h}} = 1 and the quotient tends to -4i. On the vertical line z = i + it, \displaystyle \frac{h}{\overline{h}} = \frac{it}{-it} = -1 and it tends to 4i. By Result 3 there is no limit: for h = |h|e^{i\varphi} the factor is e^{2i\varphi}, set by the direction alone.
Open, closed, connected
Let A = \{z : 1 < |z - i| \le 2\} and let B = \mathbb{C} \setminus (-\infty, 0] be the slit plane. Decide whether each is open, closed, bounded, a region, and find \partial A and \overline{A}.
SolutionThe set A. The point 3i is in A, but the points (3 + t)i with t > 0 are not, so A is not open. The point 0 \notin A is a boundary point, as the points -ti with 0 < t \le 1 are in A; so A is not closed. Points with 1 < |z - i| < 2 are interior, as the triangle inequality keeps both strict inequalities on a small disk, and every point of either circle is a boundary point, as at 0 and 3i. So \partial A is the pair of circles |z - i| = 1 and |z - i| = 2, and \overline{A} = \{z : 1 \le |z - i| \le 2\}. A is bounded, as |z| \le |z - i| + 1 \le 3, and connected by Result 7 (radius, arc, radius), but not a region.
The slit plane B. If z \in B and \operatorname{Re} z \ge 0, then D(z, |z|) \subseteq B; if \operatorname{Re} z < 0, then \operatorname{Im} z \ne 0 and D(z, |\operatorname{Im} z|) misses the real axis. So B is open. The segment from z \in B to 1 stays in B, since its points other than 1 have imaginary parts of the sign of \operatorname{Im} z, or lie on the positive axis if z > 0. By Result 7, B is a region.
Where a logarithm is continuous
Let f(z) = \operatorname{Log}(z^2 + 4). Find where f is continuous, and its limits at 3i through the right and the left half-plane.
SolutionBy Results 2, 4 and 6, f is continuous wherever z^2 + 4 \notin (-\infty, 0]. With z = x + iy, z^2 = x^2 - y^2 + 2xyi is real only when xy = 0 and negative only when x = 0 \ne y. So z^2 + 4 \in (-\infty, 0] exactly when z = iy with |y| \ge 2, and f is continuous on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{iy : |y| \ge 2\} (Figure 2). For instance f(i) = \operatorname{Log} 3 = \ln 3.
Near 3i, \operatorname{Im}(z^2 + 4) = 2xy has the sign of x. So as z \to 3i, z^2 + 4 \to -5 through the upper half-plane when \operatorname{Re} z > 0 and through the lower when \operatorname{Re} z < 0. By the \arccos formula in the proof of Result 6, \operatorname{Log} restricted to \operatorname{Im} w \ge 0 is continuous at -5, and Result 4 applied to the restrictions gives
By Result 3, f has no limit at 3i, though f(3i) = \operatorname{Log}(-5) = \ln 5 + \pi i exists.
A yacht’s plotter
Leah and Malik sail a yacht due north at 8 kilometers per hour. Their plotter, centered on the yacht with east along the real axis, shows a buoy at z(t) = -5 + (4 - 8t)i kilometers after t hours, 0 \le t \le 1, and prints \operatorname{Arg} z(t). Where is this reading continuous? Find a continuous angle \theta(t) with z(t) = |z(t)|e^{i\theta(t)}, and how far the direction to the buoy turns.
Solutionz(t) meets (-\infty, 0] only at \displaystyle t = \frac{1}{2}, where z = -5, so by Results 4 and 6 the reading is continuous for \displaystyle t \ne \frac{1}{2}. There it is \pi, and z(t) approaches -5 from above before and from below after, so the reading jumps by -2\pi as the buoy passes due west (Figure 3).
A continuous angle is \displaystyle \theta(t) = \pi + \arctan\frac{8t - 4}{5}. Check: with \displaystyle s = \arctan\frac{8t - 4}{5}, \displaystyle \cos s = \frac{5}{|z(t)|} and \displaystyle \sin s = \frac{8t - 4}{|z(t)|}, so |z(t)|e^{i(\pi + s)} = -5 - (8t - 4)i = z(t). It equals \operatorname{Arg} z(t) for \displaystyle t \le \frac{1}{2} and \operatorname{Arg} z(t) + 2\pi after. The direction turns counterclockwise by \displaystyle \theta(1) - \theta(0) = 2\arctan\frac{4}{5} \approx 1.349 radians, about 77^\circ, while the printed reading changes by 1.349 - 2\pi \approx -4.934. By Exercise 17, no continuous choice of angle works all the way around 0.
A short proof: sets cut out by continuous functions
Let G be open, f : G \to \mathbb{C} continuous and c > 0. Prove that \{z \in G : |f(z)| < c\} and \{z \in G : f(z) \ne 0\} are open.
SolutionLet |f(z_0)| < c and \varepsilon = c - |f(z_0)|. Continuity gives \delta_1 with |f(z) - f(z_0)| < \varepsilon for z \in G with |z - z_0| < \delta_1, and openness gives D(z_0, \delta_2) \subseteq G. On D(z_0, \min\{\delta_1, \delta_2\}), |f(z)| \le |f(z_0)| + |f(z) - f(z_0)| < c, so z_0 is interior to the first set. For the second, let f(z_0) \ne 0 and \varepsilon = |f(z_0)|; on the same kind of disk the reverse triangle inequality gives |f(z)| \ge |f(z_0)| - |f(z) - f(z_0)| > 0. \blacksquare
Boundaries
A limit needs a limit point. At an isolated point there is no limit to take, and continuity is automatic: every function on \{m + ni : m, n \in \mathbb{Z}\} is continuous.
Every logarithm has a cut. Arguments in [a, a + 2\pi) move the jump to the ray at angle a (Exercise 12, a = 0), but by Exercise 17 no logarithm is continuous on all of \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\}.
Continuous is far from differentiable. \overline{z} is continuous on \mathbb{C}, yet Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations shows it has a complex derivative nowhere.
Where this goes next
Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations takes the limit of \displaystyle \frac{f(z_0 + h) - f(z_0)}{h} as h \to 0 from every direction (Exercise 6 shows it failing), and proves a function with zero derivative on a region constant along the segments of Result 7; Exercise 10 shows connectedness is needed. Contour integrals integrates continuous functions along paths, using that a continuous function on a closed bounded set is bounded, proved as the extreme value theorem is on an interval.
Exercises
Limits
- Let z_0 = 1 + 2i. Find \overline{z_0}^{\,2}, and prove from the definition that \lim_{z \to z_0} \overline{z}^{\,2} = \overline{z_0}^{\,2}.
- Find \lim_{z \to 2i} \dfrac{z^2 + 4}{z^3 + 8i}.
- Find \lim_{z \to 0} \dfrac{z\operatorname{Re} z}{|z|}.
- Decide whether \lim_{z \to 0} \dfrac{\operatorname{Re}(z^2)}{|z|^2} exists.
- Show that \displaystyle \cos\frac{1}{z} has no limit at 0 and is unbounded near 0.
- Let z_0 = 3 + 4i. Find the limits of \dfrac{|z|^2 - 25}{z - z_0} as z \to z_0 along the horizontal and the vertical line through z_0. Does the limit exist?
Sets
- Let \displaystyle T = \left\{\frac{i^n}{n} : n \ge 1\right\}. Find the limit points and the isolated points of T, and \partial T and \overline{T}. Is T closed?
- Show that U = \{z : |z^2 - 1| < 1\} is open but not a region.
Continuity of Arg, Log and powers
- Where is f(z) = \dfrac{\overline{z}}{z^2 + 9} continuous? Does it have a limit at 3i?
- Show that f(z) = \operatorname{Log} z - \operatorname{Log}(-z) is continuous on \mathbb{C} \setminus \mathbb{R} and takes only two values there. Which?
- Find the limits of \displaystyle z^{1/2} = e^{\frac{1}{2}\operatorname{Log} z} at -4 through the upper and through the lower half-plane, and its value at -4.
- For z \ne 0 let A(z) be the argument of z in [0, 2\pi). Show that A(z) = \operatorname{Arg}(-z) + \pi for z \notin [0, \infty), find where A is continuous, and find its limits at 3 from above and from below.
- Let z(t) = 2 + 3e^{it} for 0 \le t \le 2\pi. For which t is \operatorname{Arg} z(t) discontinuous? By how much does a continuous angle \theta(t) with z(t) = |z(t)|e^{i\theta(t)} change from t = 0 to t = 2\pi?
Proofs
- Prove that if \lim_{z \to z_0} f(z) = L, then |f(z)| \to |L| and \overline{f(z)} \to \overline{L}. Show by an example that |f| can have a limit where f has none.
- Prove that the closed disk \overline{D}(a, r) is closed and that its boundary is the circle |z - a| = r.
- Prove that G \subseteq \mathbb{C} is open if and only if \mathbb{C} \setminus G is closed.
- Prove that no continuous function \theta on the circle |z| = 1 has e^{i\theta(z)} = z for every z on it, and conclude that no continuous L on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\} has e^{L(z)} = z for all z.
Answers
- \overline{z_0}^{\,2} = (1 - 2i)^2 = -3 - 4i. Proof. \overline{z}^{\,2} - \overline{z_0}^{\,2} = (\overline{z} - \overline{z_0})(\overline{z} + \overline{z_0}) has modulus |z - z_0|\,|z + z_0|, and if |z - z_0| < 1, then \displaystyle |z + z_0| \le |z - z_0| + 2|z_0| < 1 + 2\sqrt{5}. So \displaystyle \delta = \min\left\{1, \frac{\varepsilon}{1 + 2\sqrt{5}}\right\} works. \blacksquare
- \displaystyle -\frac{i}{3}. Since (2i)^3 = -8i, z^3 + 8i = (z - 2i)(z^2 + 2iz - 4), and z^2 + 4 = (z - 2i)(z + 2i). Cancel and substitute: \displaystyle \frac{4i}{-4 - 4 - 4}.
- 0. The modulus of the quotient is |\operatorname{Re} z| \le |z|, so \delta = \varepsilon works.
- It does not exist. On the ray z = te^{i\varphi}, t > 0, the quotient is \cos 2\varphi: 1 on the real axis, -1 on the imaginary axis.
- At \displaystyle z = \frac{1}{2\pi k} the value is 1 and at \displaystyle z = \frac{1}{(2k + 1)\pi} it is -1, so by Result 3 there is no limit. On the imaginary axis, \displaystyle \cos\frac{1}{iy} = \cos\left(-\frac{i}{y}\right) = \cosh\frac{1}{y} (Result 6 of The complex exponential and logarithm), unbounded as y \to 0.
- Horizontal 6, vertical -8i, so no limit. On z = z_0 + t: \displaystyle \frac{6t + t^2}{t} \to 6. On z = z_0 + it: \displaystyle \frac{8t + t^2}{it} \to \frac{8}{i} = -8i.
- The only limit point is 0, not in T; every point of T is isolated, since for m \ne n, \displaystyle \left|\frac{i^m}{m} - \frac{i^n}{n}\right| \ge \left|\frac{1}{m} - \frac{1}{n}\right| (reverse triangle inequality) \displaystyle \ge \frac{1}{n} - \frac{1}{n + 1}. So \partial T = \overline{T} = T \cup \{0\}, and T is not closed.
- U is open by Example 6 with f(z) = z^2 - 1 and c = 1. On the imaginary axis |(iy)^2 - 1| = y^2 + 1 \ge 1, so the half-planes \operatorname{Re} z > 0 and \operatorname{Re} z < 0 separate U into two nonempty parts, containing 1 and -1.
- On \mathbb{C} \setminus \{3i, -3i\}, by Result 2. No limit at 3i: \displaystyle |f(z)| = \frac{|z|}{|z - 3i|\,|z + 3i|} has numerator tending to 3 and denominator to 0.
- \pi i on the upper half-plane and -\pi i on the lower. Both terms are continuous off \mathbb{R} by Result 6, and the real parts cancel. If \operatorname{Im} z > 0, \operatorname{Arg} z - \pi \in (-\pi, 0) is an argument of -z, so it is \operatorname{Arg}(-z); below the axis, \operatorname{Arg}(-z) = \operatorname{Arg} z + \pi.
- 2i from above and -2i from below; the value is \displaystyle e^{\frac{1}{2}(\ln 4 + \pi i)} = 2i. By Result 6, \operatorname{Log} z \to \ln 4 \pm \pi i, and e^{w/2} is continuous, giving e^{\ln 2}e^{\pm\pi i/2} = \pm 2i.
- For z \notin [0, \infty), \operatorname{Arg}(-z) + \pi \in (0, 2\pi) is an argument of z = e^{i\pi}(-z), so A is continuous on \mathbb{C} \setminus [0, \infty) by Results 4 and 6. At 3: from above, -z \to -3 from below, so A \to -\pi + \pi = 0; from below, A \to \pi + \pi = 2\pi.
- Only at t = \pi: z(t) is real only at t = 0, \pi, 2\pi, with values 5, -1, 5, and \operatorname{Im} z(t) = 3\sin t turns negative after \pi, so the reading drops from \pi to near -\pi. Adding 2\pi after t = \pi gives a continuous angle, which changes by 2\pi: the circle goes once around 0.
- Proof. \big||f(z)| - |L|\big| \le |f(z) - L| and |\overline{f(z)} - \overline{L}| = |f(z) - L|, so a \delta serving \varepsilon for f serves both. For the example, \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{z}{|z|} has |f| = 1, but f is 1 on the positive and -1 on the negative real axis, so it has no limit at 0. \blacksquare
- Proof. Let K = \overline{D}(a, r). If |b - a| < r, then D(b, r - |b - a|) \subseteq K, and if |b - a| > r, then D(b, |b - a| - r) misses K (triangle inequality and its reverse form); neither b is a boundary point. If |b - a| = r, every D(b, \rho) contains b \in K and, for small t > 0, b + t(b - a) \notin K, at distance (1 + t)r from a. So \partial K is the circle, which lies in K. \blacksquare
- Proof. The definition of boundary point treats a set and its complement alike, so \partial G = \partial(\mathbb{C} \setminus G). A point z \in G is interior exactly when it is not a boundary point, since every disk about z contains z \in G. So G is open if and only if \partial G misses G, that is, \partial(\mathbb{C} \setminus G) \subseteq \mathbb{C} \setminus G: \mathbb{C} \setminus G is closed. \blacksquare
- Proof. Suppose \theta exists, and let \displaystyle g(t) = \frac{\theta(e^{it}) - t}{2\pi} on [0, 2\pi], continuous by Results 4 and 5. Since e^{i\theta(e^{it})} = e^{it}, Result 2 of The complex exponential and logarithm makes g integer-valued. If g took two different integers, the intermediate value theorem would give it a non-integer value between them, so g is constant. But e^{2\pi i} = e^{0} gives \displaystyle g(2\pi) = \frac{\theta(1) - 2\pi}{2\pi} = g(0) - 1, a contradiction. If L existed, then on |z| = 1, e^{\operatorname{Re} L} = |z| = 1, so \theta = \operatorname{Im} L (continuous by Result 1) would be such a function. \blacksquare