Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations
A complex difference quotient must have one limit however h approaches 0 in the plane. What does that demand of the real and imaginary parts of f, and which functions meet it?
Where you are 6 in Complex functions
Why this exists
The derivative of The derivative at a point is the limit of \displaystyle \frac{f(a + h) - f(a)}{h} as the real number h tends to 0. Limits and continuity in the complex plane lets h tend to 0 through the whole plane, and the same quotient with complex h defines the complex derivative. Comparing real h with imaginary h ties the Partial derivatives of u = \operatorname{Re} f and v = \operatorname{Im} f together by two equations, the Cauchy-Riemann equations. Holomorphic functions, those with a complex derivative throughout an open set, fill the rest of the course.
Definition
Let A \subseteq \mathbb{C}, f : A \to \mathbb{C}, and let z_0 be an interior point of A.
Derivative. f is differentiable at z_0 if the limit
exists, h ranging over the nonzero complex numbers with z_0 + h \in A.
Holomorphic and entire. f is holomorphic on an open set G \subseteq A if it is differentiable at every point of G, and holomorphic at z_0 if it is holomorphic on some disk D(z_0, r). A function holomorphic on \mathbb{C} is entire. Many books say analytic; this course keeps that word until Holomorphic functions are power series shows that the two mean the same.
Parts and partials. Write z = x + iy and f = u + iv, with u(x, y) = \operatorname{Re} f(x + iy) and v(x, y) = \operatorname{Im} f(x + iy). Their partial derivatives are written \displaystyle u_x = \frac{\partial u}{\partial x}, \displaystyle u_y = \frac{\partial u}{\partial y}, v_x, v_y, and second partials \displaystyle u_{xx} = \frac{\partial^2 u}{\partial x^2} and so on. For complex-valued f, f_x = u_x + iv_x and f_y = u_y + iv_y.
Cauchy-Riemann equations. u and v satisfy them at a point if there
Comparing real and imaginary parts, the pair says the same as the single equation f_y = if_x.
Intuition
Near z_0 a differentiable f acts on a small step h by f(z_0 + h) \approx f(z_0) + f'(z_0)h, multiplication by the number f'(z_0) = a + ib. On the step as a vector of \mathbb{R}^2 that is the matrix
the rotation-scaling matrix of Complex eigenvalues and rotation-scaling matrices. Any map with good partials acts on small steps by its Jacobian matrix, with rows (u_x, u_y) and (v_x, v_y). For that to be a complex multiplication the Jacobian must have the rotation-scaling form: u_x = a = v_y and v_x = b = -u_y, the Cauchy-Riemann equations. So where f'(z_0) \ne 0, small squares go to near-squares (Figure 1).
Results
1. Rules. (a) f is differentiable at z_0 if and only if there is a function \varphi on A, continuous at z_0, with f(z) - f(z_0) = \varphi(z)(z - z_0) for all z \in A; then f'(z_0) = \varphi(z_0). So a function differentiable at z_0 is continuous there. (b) If f and g are differentiable at z_0 and c \in \mathbb{C}, then so are f + cg, fg and, when g(z_0) \ne 0, \displaystyle \frac{f}{g}, with (f + cg)' = f' + cg', (fg)' = f'g + fg' and \displaystyle \left(\frac{f}{g}\right)' = \frac{f'g - fg'}{g^2} at z_0. (c) Chain rule. If g is differentiable at z_0, h is differentiable at w_0 = g(z_0), and g takes values in the domain of h, then (h \circ g)'(z_0) = h'(w_0)\,g'(z_0). (d) (z^n)' = nz^{n - 1} for every integer n (for z \ne 0 when n < 0). So polynomials are entire, and a quotient of polynomials is holomorphic off the zeros of its denominator.
2. The Cauchy-Riemann equations are necessary. If f = u + iv is differentiable at z_0 = x_0 + iy_0, then u_x, u_y, v_x, v_y exist at (x_0, y_0) and satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations there, and
3. A sufficient condition. Suppose u_x, u_y, v_x, v_y exist at every point of a disk D(z_0, r), are continuous at z_0, and satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations at z_0. Then f is differentiable at z_0. In particular, if u and v have continuous first partials on an open set G that satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations at every point of G, then f is holomorphic on G.
Conversely, if f is holomorphic on an open set G, then u and v have continuous partials of every order on G; this is stated here without proof and proved in Cauchy's integral formula. So f is holomorphic on G exactly when u and v have continuous first partials satisfying the Cauchy-Riemann equations there.
4. Exponential, sine, cosine, logarithm. e^{z} is entire with (e^{z})' = e^{z}, and on \mathbb{C}, (\sin z)' = \cos z, (\cos z)' = -\sin z, (\sinh z)' = \cosh z, (\cosh z)' = \sinh z. \operatorname{Log} is holomorphic on the slit plane \mathbb{C} \setminus (-\infty, 0] with \displaystyle (\operatorname{Log} z)' = \frac{1}{z}, and for each \alpha \in \mathbb{C} the principal power z^{\alpha} is holomorphic there with \displaystyle (z^{\alpha})' = \frac{\alpha z^{\alpha}}{z}.
5. Zero derivative. If f is holomorphic on a region G and f'(z) = 0 for every z \in G, then f is constant on G.
Why it is true
Result 1. Proof. (a) If f'(z_0) exists, let \displaystyle \varphi(z) = \frac{f(z) - f(z_0)}{z - z_0} for z \ne z_0 and \varphi(z_0) = f'(z_0); the definition of the limit says exactly that \varphi is continuous at z_0. Conversely, given \varphi, the difference quotient equals \varphi(z) for z \ne z_0 and tends to \varphi(z_0). Then f(z) = f(z_0) + \varphi(z)(z - z_0) \to f(z_0) by Result 2 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane.
(b) Let \varphi and \psi serve f and g as in (a). For f + cg take \varphi + c\psi. For the product, adding and subtracting f(z)g(z_0) gives
and the bracket is continuous at z_0, since f is, with value f(z_0)g'(z_0) + f'(z_0)g(z_0). If g(z_0) \ne 0, continuity with \varepsilon = |g(z_0)| gives a disk about z_0 on which g \ne 0, and there
with the bracket continuous at z_0 and equal to \displaystyle -\frac{g'(z_0)}{g(z_0)^2} there. The product rule applied to \displaystyle f \cdot \frac{1}{g} gives the quotient rule.
(c) Let \psi serve g at z_0 and \chi serve h at w_0. Then
As g is continuous at z_0 by (a) and \chi is continuous at w_0, \chi \circ g is continuous at z_0 (Result 4 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane), so the factor \chi(g(z))\psi(z) is continuous at z_0, with value h'(w_0)g'(z_0).
(d) The quotient of a constant is 0 and that of z is 1. If (z^n)' = nz^{n - 1}, the product rule gives (z \cdot z^n)' = z^n + z \cdot nz^{n - 1} = (n + 1)z^n. For n = -m < 0 the quotient rule gives \displaystyle \left(\frac{1}{z^m}\right)' = \frac{-mz^{m - 1}}{z^{2m}} = -mz^{-m - 1}. \blacksquare
Result 2. Proof. The nonzero real h = a have 0 as a limit point, so by Results 3 and 1 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane the restricted quotient
tends to f'(z_0), and its two parts to those of f'(z_0). So u_x and v_x exist and f'(z_0) = u_x + iv_x. For h = ib with b real, \displaystyle \frac{f(z_0 + ib) - f(z_0)}{ib} \to f'(z_0), so multiplying by i, \displaystyle \frac{f(z_0 + ib) - f(z_0)}{b} \to if'(z_0). So u_y and v_y exist and u_y + iv_y = if'(z_0) = -v_x + iu_x. Comparing parts, u_y = -v_x and v_y = u_x, and f'(z_0) = v_y - iu_y. \blacksquare
Result 3. Proof. Let h = a + ib with 0 < |h| < r, and split the step into a horizontal and a vertical part:
The segments from z_0 to z_0 + a and from z_0 + a to z_0 + h lie within |h| of z_0, so in the disk. By the definition of f_x, the first bracket is af_x(z_0) + a\varepsilon_1 with \varepsilon_1 \to 0 as h \to 0 (take \varepsilon_1 = 0 if a = 0). For the second, t \mapsto u(x_0 + a, y_0 + t) has derivative u_y(x_0 + a, y_0 + t) between 0 and b, so the mean value theorem (Result 2 of Partial derivatives, with x and y exchanged) gives s_1 between 0 and b with
and likewise s_2 for v. So the second bracket is bf_y(z_0) + b\varepsilon_2, where \varepsilon_2 is u_y(x_0 + a, y_0 + s_1) - u_y(x_0, y_0) plus i times v_y(x_0 + a, y_0 + s_2) - v_y(x_0, y_0). It tends to 0, because u_y and v_y are continuous at z_0 and the points are within |h| of it (\varepsilon_2 = 0 if b = 0). The Cauchy-Riemann equations say f_y(z_0) = if_x(z_0), so
As |a|, |b| \le |h|, the right side has modulus at most |\varepsilon_1| + |\varepsilon_2| \to 0, and f'(z_0) = f_x(z_0). \blacksquare
Result 4. Proof. For e^{z} = e^{x}\cos y + ie^{x}\sin y the partials u_x = e^{x}\cos y = v_y and u_y = -e^{x}\sin y = -v_x are continuous on \mathbb{C}, so Result 3 makes e^{z} entire and Result 2 gives (e^{z})' = u_x + iv_x = e^{z}. By the chain rule (e^{\pm iz})' = \pm ie^{\pm iz}, and the definitions in The complex exponential and logarithm give
the other three are alike.
For \operatorname{Log}, fix w_0 in the slit plane \Omega, let \zeta_0 = \operatorname{Log} w_0, and let \displaystyle Q(\zeta) = \frac{e^{\zeta} - e^{\zeta_0}}{\zeta - \zeta_0} for \zeta \ne \zeta_0 and Q(\zeta_0) = e^{\zeta_0} = w_0. Since (e^{z})' = e^{z}, Q is continuous at \zeta_0. For w \in \Omega with w \ne w_0, \operatorname{Log} w \ne \zeta_0, as their exponentials w and w_0 differ, and
\operatorname{Log} is continuous on \Omega (Result 6 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane) and Q(\zeta_0) \ne 0, so by Results 2 and 4 there the right side tends to \displaystyle \frac{1}{w_0}. Finally z^{\alpha} = e^{\alpha\operatorname{Log} z}, and the chain rule gives \displaystyle (z^{\alpha})' = e^{\alpha\operatorname{Log} z} \cdot \frac{\alpha}{z}. \blacksquare
Result 5. Proof. By Result 2, 0 = f' = u_x + iv_x = v_y - iu_y, so all four first partials vanish on G. On a horizontal segment in G at height y_0, x \mapsto u(x, y_0) and x \mapsto v(x, y_0) have derivative 0, so they are constant by the mean value theorem; likewise on vertical segments. By Result 7 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane, any two points of the region G are joined by a chain of such segments in G, so f takes the same value at both. \blacksquare
Worked examples
Differentiable at a single point
Let f(z) = z\operatorname{Re} z. Find every point where f is differentiable. Is f holomorphic anywhere?
SolutionFor z_0 \in \mathbb{C} and h \ne 0, \operatorname{Re} is additive, so f(z_0 + h) - f(z_0) = z_0\operatorname{Re} h + h\operatorname{Re} z_0 + h\operatorname{Re} h and
The last two terms tend to \operatorname{Re} z_0. The fraction \displaystyle \frac{\operatorname{Re} h}{h} is 1 for real h and 0 for imaginary h, so along the two axes the quotient tends to \operatorname{Re} z_0 + z_0 and to \operatorname{Re} z_0. These differ unless z_0 = 0, so by Result 3 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane f has no derivative at any z_0 \ne 0. At z_0 = 0 the quotient is \operatorname{Re} h \to 0, so f'(0) = 0.
So f is differentiable at 0 only, and holomorphic nowhere. Result 2 agrees: u = x^2 and v = xy give u_x - v_y = x and u_y + v_x = y, both zero only at the origin.
The Cauchy-Riemann equations on a line
Let f(x + iy) = x^2 + y + i(y^2 - x). Find where f is differentiable, and its derivative there.
SolutionHere u_x = 2x, u_y = 1, v_x = -1 and v_y = 2y. The equation u_y = -v_x holds everywhere, and u_x = v_y holds exactly when y = x. By Result 2, f is not differentiable off the line y = x. The four partials are polynomials, continuous on \mathbb{C}, so by Result 3 f is differentiable at every point of the line, with
A line contains no disk, so f is holomorphic nowhere.
A logarithm of a sum
Let f(z) = \operatorname{Log}(e^{z} + 1). Find the open set on which Results 1 and 4 make f holomorphic, f' there, and \displaystyle f'\!\left(\frac{\pi i}{2}\right). Show that f is differentiable nowhere else.
SolutionBy the chain rule and Result 4, f is holomorphic where e^{z} + 1 \notin (-\infty, 0], that is, where e^{z} \notin (-\infty, -1]. For z = x + iy, e^{z} = e^{x}e^{iy} is a negative real number exactly when y = (2k + 1)\pi with k \in \mathbb{Z}, and it is then -e^{x}, which is at most -1 exactly when x \ge 0. So f is holomorphic on
which is open, as the rays in R are closed and 2\pi apart. On G,
At the ray points with x = 0, e^{z} + 1 = 0 and f is undefined. Near a ray point with x > 0, \operatorname{Re}(e^{z} + 1) = 1 + e^{x}\cos y < 0 while \operatorname{Im}(e^{z} + 1) = e^{x}\sin y changes sign across the ray, so by Result 6 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane the limits of f from the two sides differ by 2\pi i. There f is not continuous, so not differentiable (Result 1).
Ideal flow in a spillway corner
Sofia and Mateo model the water near a corner of a spillway basin, where two walls meet at the origin along the rays \operatorname{Arg} z = 0 and \displaystyle \operatorname{Arg} z = \frac{\pi}{3}, positions in meters. Their velocity field is \mathbf{V} = (P, Q) = (x^2 - y^2, -2xy) meters per second. A planar flow is incompressible where P_x + Q_y = 0 and irrotational where Q_x - P_y = 0. Show that this flow is both, that the water runs along each wall, and find its speed and direction at \displaystyle \sqrt{3} + i.
SolutionLet f = P - iQ, so u = P and v = -Q. The Cauchy-Riemann equations u_x = v_y and u_y = -v_x read P_x = -Q_y and P_y = Q_x: incompressible and irrotational. So by Results 2 and 3, a field with continuous first partials on an open set G is incompressible and irrotational on G exactly when P - iQ is holomorphic on G. Here
which is entire, so the flow is both, everywhere.
As a complex number the velocity is P + iQ = \overline{z^2} = \overline{z}^{\,2}. On the wall z = re^{i\pi/3} it is r^2e^{-2\pi i/3} = -r^2e^{i\pi/3}, a negative multiple of the wall’s direction e^{i\pi/3}: the water runs along this wall toward the corner. On the wall z = r \ge 0 it is r^2 \ge 0, along that wall away from the corner. At \displaystyle \sqrt{3} + i = 2e^{i\pi/6} the velocity is \displaystyle 4e^{-i\pi/3} = 2 - 2\sqrt{3}\,i: speed 4 meters per second, heading \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{3} below due east. Figure 2 shows its paths (Exercise 14).
A short proof: constant real part
Let f = u + iv be holomorphic on a region G with u constant on G. Prove that f is constant on G.
SolutionProof. As u is constant, u_x = u_y = 0 on G. By Result 2, v_x = -u_y = 0, so f' = u_x + iv_x = 0 at every point of G, and Result 5 makes f constant. \blacksquare
Boundaries
Smooth is not holomorphic. \overline{z} = x - iy has constant partials, yet u_x = 1 \ne -1 = v_y everywhere, so by Result 2 it has a complex derivative nowhere, though it is continuous on \mathbb{C}.
The equations at one point are not enough without the other hypotheses of Result 3 (Exercise 19).
Result 5 needs a region. On the plane without the imaginary axis, the function equal to i where \operatorname{Re} z > 0 and to 2i where \operatorname{Re} z < 0 has zero derivative and constant real part, and is not constant.
Where this goes next
Harmonic functions differentiates the Cauchy-Riemann equations once more: when u and v have continuous second partials, u_{xx} = v_{yx} = v_{xy} = -u_{yy}, so \Delta u = 0. Möbius transformations differentiates \displaystyle \frac{az + b}{cz + d} by the quotient rule. Cauchy's theorem turns them, through Green’s theorem, into \int_\gamma f(z)\,dz = 0, and Cauchy's integral formula proves the smoothness assumed in the converse of Result 3.
Exercises
From the definition
- Prove from the definition that \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{1}{z} has \displaystyle f'(z_0) = -\frac{1}{z_0^2} at every z_0 \ne 0.
- Show from the definition that f(z) = |z|^2 z is differentiable at 0, find f'(0), and use Result 2 to show it is differentiable nowhere else.
- Let f(z) = \operatorname{Im} z. At any z_0, find the limits of the difference quotient along real h and along imaginary h. Where is f differentiable?
Cauchy-Riemann equations
- Let f(x + iy) = x^2 - y^2 - 2y + i(2xy + 2x). Show that f is entire, find f' by Result 2, and write f as a formula in z.
- Let f(x + iy) = e^{-y}\cos x + ie^{-y}\sin x. Show that f is entire, find f', and identify f.
- Where is f(x + iy) = x^3 + i(y - 1)^3 differentiable? Find f' there. Is f holomorphic anywhere?
- Find all real a, b, c for which u = 3x^2 + axy - 3y^2 and v = bx^2 + cy^2 + 6xy are the real and imaginary parts of an entire function, and write that function in terms of z.
- Show that f(z) = e^{\overline{z}} is differentiable nowhere.
Rules, exponential and logarithm
- Let f(z) = \dfrac{z}{z^2 + 2z + 2}. Where is f holomorphic? Find f'(i).
- Find where \displaystyle \tan z = \frac{\sin z}{\cos z} is defined, and show that it is holomorphic there with \displaystyle (\tan z)' = \frac{1}{\cos^2 z}.
- Where is the principal power f(z) = z^{i} holomorphic? Find f'(i).
- Find the open set on which Results 1 and 4 make f(z) = \operatorname{Log}(1 - z^3) holomorphic, and find f'(-1).
Flows
- Which of \mathbf{V}_1 = (2x + y,\ x - 2y) and \mathbf{V}_2 = (y, -x) is the velocity of an incompressible, irrotational flow on \mathbb{C}, in the sense of Example 4? For that one, write P - iQ in terms of z and find the speed at 1 + i.
- In Example 4, show that away from 0 the velocity is tangent to the level curves of \psi = 3x^2y - y^3, and that \psi = \operatorname{Im}(z^3).
Proofs
- Let f be holomorphic on a region G with |f| constant on G. Prove that f is constant.
- Prove that if f and \overline{f} are both holomorphic on a region G, then f is constant.
- Let f be holomorphic on an open set G, G^{*} = \{\overline{z} : z \in G\} and g(z) = \overline{f(\overline{z})}. Prove that g is holomorphic on G^{*} with g'(z) = \overline{f'(\overline{z})}.
- Prove that if f = u + iv is differentiable at z_0, then the Jacobian determinant u_xv_y - u_yv_x at z_0 equals |f'(z_0)|^2.
- Refute the claim “if u and v satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations at z_0, then f is differentiable at z_0” with \displaystyle f(x + iy) = \sqrt{|xy|} at 0, and say which hypothesis of Result 3 fails.
- Let f be holomorphic on a region G with f'(z) = c for every z \in G. Prove that f(z) = cz + b on G for some constant b.
Answers
- Proof. For 0 < |h| < |z_0|, z_0 + h \ne 0 and \displaystyle \frac{1}{h}\left(\frac{1}{z_0 + h} - \frac{1}{z_0}\right) = \frac{-1}{z_0(z_0 + h)}, which tends to \displaystyle -\frac{1}{z_0^2} as h \to 0 by Result 2 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane. \blacksquare
- f'(0) = 0, since \displaystyle \frac{f(h) - f(0)}{h} = |h|^2 \to 0. With u = x^3 + xy^2 and v = x^2y + y^3, u_x - v_y = 2x^2 - 2y^2 and u_y + v_x = 4xy. Both vanish only at 0.
- The quotient is \displaystyle \frac{\operatorname{Im} h}{h}: along real h the limit is 0, and along h = it it is \displaystyle \frac{t}{it} = -i. So f is differentiable nowhere.
- u_x = 2x = v_y and u_y = -2y - 2 = -v_x, continuous, so f is entire by Result 3, and f' = u_x + iv_x = 2x + i(2y + 2) = 2z + 2i. Indeed f(z) = z^2 + 2iz, since z^2 + 2iz = x^2 - y^2 - 2y + i(2xy + 2x).
- u_x = -e^{-y}\sin x = v_y and u_y = -e^{-y}\cos x = -v_x, continuous, so f is entire, and f' = u_x + iv_x = ie^{-y}(\cos x + i\sin x) = if. Since iz = -y + ix, f(z) = e^{iz} and f'(z) = ie^{iz}.
- On the lines y = 1 + x and y = 1 - x, with f' = 3x^2; holomorphic nowhere, as a line holds no disk. u_x - v_y = 3x^2 - 3(y - 1)^2 vanishes exactly when y - 1 = \pm x, u_y + v_x = 0, and the partials are continuous, so Results 2 and 3 apply.
- a = 2c and b = -c, with c any real number; the function is (3 - ci)z^2. The expressions u_x - v_y = (a - 2c)y and u_y + v_x = (a + 2b)x must vanish identically, and (3 - ci)(x + iy)^2 expands to u + iv.
- Here u = e^{x}\cos y and v = -e^{x}\sin y, so u_x - v_y = 2e^{x}\cos y and u_y + v_x = -2e^{x}\sin y. Both zero would need \cos y = \sin y = 0, impossible as \cos^2 y + \sin^2 y = 1, so by Result 2 there is no derivative anywhere.
- On \mathbb{C} \setminus \{-1 + i, -1 - i\}, the zeros of z^2 + 2z + 2 = (z + 1)^2 + 1 removed. The quotient rule gives \displaystyle f'(z) = \frac{2 - z^2}{(z^2 + 2z + 2)^2}, so \displaystyle f'(i) = \frac{3}{(1 + 2i)^2} = \frac{3}{-3 + 4i} = -\frac{9}{25} - \frac{12}{25}i.
- \cos z = 0 means e^{iz} + e^{-iz} = 0, that is, e^{2iz} = -1 = e^{\pi i}, so by Result 2 of The complex exponential and logarithm 2iz = \pi i + 2\pi ik, and \displaystyle z = \frac{\pi}{2} + k\pi with k \in \mathbb{Z}. Off these points the quotient rule and Result 4 give \displaystyle (\tan z)' = \frac{\cos^2 z + \sin^2 z}{\cos^2 z} = \frac{1}{\cos^2 z}, where \cos^2 z + \sin^2 z = 1 as (e^{iz} + e^{-iz})^2 - (e^{iz} - e^{-iz})^2 = 4.
- On the slit plane \mathbb{C} \setminus (-\infty, 0], by Result 4, with \displaystyle f'(z) = \frac{iz^{i}}{z}. As \displaystyle \operatorname{Log} i = \frac{\pi i}{2}, i^{i} = e^{-\pi/2}, so f'(i) = e^{-\pi/2} \approx 0.208.
- 1 - z^3 \in (-\infty, 0] exactly when z^3 \in [1, \infty), that is, z = re^{2\pi ik/3} with r \ge 1 and k = 0, 1, 2. So f is holomorphic off the three rays running outward from 1, e^{2\pi i/3} and e^{-2\pi i/3}, with \displaystyle f'(z) = \frac{-3z^2}{1 - z^3} and \displaystyle f'(-1) = -\frac{3}{2}.
- \mathbf{V}_1. Its P - iQ = 2x + y - i(x - 2y) = (2 - i)z is entire, and the speed at 1 + i is \displaystyle |(2 - i)(1 + i)| = |3 + i| = \sqrt{10}. For \mathbf{V}_2, Q_x - P_y = -1 - 1 = -2 \ne 0, so it is not irrotational.
- \nabla\psi = (6xy,\ 3x^2 - 3y^2) vanishes only at 0, and \mathbf{V} \cdot \nabla\psi is 6xy(x^2 - y^2) - 2xy(3x^2 - 3y^2) = 0, so \mathbf{V} is perpendicular to the gradient, hence tangent to the level curve. And z^3 = x^3 - 3xy^2 + i(3x^2y - y^3).
- Proof. Let u^2 + v^2 = k on G. If k = 0, then f = 0. Otherwise the partials exist by Result 2, and differentiating by the product rule gives uu_x + vv_x = 0 and uu_y + vv_y = 0. By the Cauchy-Riemann equations the second is vu_x - uv_x = 0. As equations in u_x and v_x the pair has determinant -u^2 - v^2 = -k \ne 0, so u_x = v_x = 0, f' = u_x + iv_x = 0 on G, and Result 5 applies. \blacksquare
- Proof. With f = u + iv and \overline{f} = u - iv, the Cauchy-Riemann equations for both give u_x = v_y and u_x = -v_y, and u_y = -v_x and u_y = v_x. So all four partials vanish on G, f' = u_x + iv_x = 0, and Result 5 applies. \blacksquare
- Proof. Conjugation keeps distances, |\overline{z} - \overline{w}| = |z - w|, so G^{*} is open. Fix z \in G^{*}, so \overline{z} \in G, and let \varphi serve f at \overline{z} as in Result 1(a). For small h \ne 0, \displaystyle \frac{g(z + h) - g(z)}{h} is the conjugate of \displaystyle \frac{f(\overline{z} + \overline{h}) - f(\overline{z})}{\overline{h}} = \varphi(\overline{z} + \overline{h}). As \varphi and conjugation are continuous, it tends to \overline{\varphi(\overline{z})} = \overline{f'(\overline{z})}. \blacksquare
- Proof. By Result 2, v_y = u_x and u_y = -v_x at z_0, so u_xv_y - u_yv_x = u_x^2 + v_x^2 = |u_x + iv_x|^2 = |f'(z_0)|^2. \blacksquare
- Proof. \displaystyle u = \sqrt{|xy|} is 0 on both axes and v = 0, so all four partials are 0 at the origin and the equations hold there. Along h = t + it with t > 0, \displaystyle \frac{f(h) - f(0)}{h} = \frac{t}{t(1 + i)} = \frac{1 - i}{2}, while along real h the quotient is 0, so f'(0) does not exist. What fails is existence of the partials on a disk: at (x, 0) with x \ne 0, \displaystyle u = \sqrt{|x|}\sqrt{|y|} has a corner in y, so u_y does not exist. \blacksquare
- Proof. g(z) = f(z) - cz is holomorphic on G with g' = f' - c = 0 by Result 1, so g is a constant b by Result 5. \blacksquare