Cauchy's theorem
When does a complex function integrate to zero around a closed loop, and how far can a loop be moved without changing its integral?
Where you are 5 in Complex integration
Why this exists
Contour integrals found that a closed path integral is 0 when f has an antiderivative on an open set containing the path, and that \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 1)} \frac{dz}{z} = 2\pi i although \displaystyle \frac{1}{z} is holomorphic on and near the circle. Antiderivatives are often out of reach, and being holomorphic near the loop is not enough. Cauchy’s theorem names the condition that is enough: f holomorphic on the loop and at every point inside it. Then the integral is 0, and a loop may be moved across any set where f is holomorphic without changing its integral. The rest of this course rests on this theorem.
Definition
A closed path \gamma : [a, b] \to \mathbb{C} is simple if \gamma(s) \ne \gamma(t) whenever a \le s < t < b: it meets itself only where it ends.
By the Jordan curve theorem, for a simple closed path \gamma the set \mathbb{C} \setminus \gamma is the union of two disjoint regions, a bounded one, the inside of \gamma, and an unbounded one, the outside; every point of \gamma is a boundary point of both. It is stated without proof, as in Green's theorem, and proved in a course on topology. \gamma is positively oriented if its inside is on the left, that is, it runs counterclockwise.
If \gamma_0 and its inside lie in the inside of \gamma_1, the closed region between them is the set K of points on or inside \gamma_1 that are not inside \gamma_0.
For a, b, c not on one line, in counterclockwise order, the closed triangle T is the set of points a + \lambda(b - a) + \mu(c - a) with \lambda, \mu \ge 0 and \lambda + \mu \le 1, and its boundary path is \partial T = [a, b] + [b, c] + [c, a].
Intuition
By Result 2 of Contour integrals, \int_\gamma f(z)\,dz is the line integral of the field \langle u, -v \rangle plus i times that of \langle v, u \rangle. Around a simple closed loop, Green's theorem turns each into a double integral over the inside of a scalar curl, -v_x - u_y and u_x - v_y, and the Cauchy-Riemann equations say exactly that both are 0. In the flow language of Contour integrals, a holomorphic \overline{V} is a flow with no swirl and no source inside the loop, so nothing circulates around it and nothing crosses it.
A point where f is not holomorphic acts like a vortex or a source. A loop around it may give a nonzero integral, but two loops that can be slid one onto the other across points where f is holomorphic give the same value (Result 2, Figure 1).
Results
1. Cauchy’s theorem. Let \gamma be a simple closed piecewise smooth path, and let f be holomorphic on an open set G that contains \gamma and its inside. Then
2. Deforming a loop. Let \gamma_0 and \gamma_1 be positively oriented simple closed piecewise smooth paths, with \gamma_0 and its inside in the inside of \gamma_1, and let f be holomorphic on an open set containing the closed region K between them. Then \int_{\gamma_1} f(z)\,dz = \int_{\gamma_0} f(z)\,dz.
3. One point inside. Let \gamma be a positively oriented simple closed piecewise smooth path and z_0 a point not on \gamma. Then
4. Goursat’s theorem. Let T be a closed triangle in an open set G. (a) If f is holomorphic on G, then \int_{\partial T} f(z)\,dz = 0. (b) The same holds if f is continuous on G and holomorphic on G \setminus \{p\} for one point p.
5. Cauchy’s theorem in a disk. Let D be an open disk, p \in D, and f continuous on D and holomorphic on D \setminus \{p\} (for instance, holomorphic on D). Then f has an antiderivative on D, and \int_\gamma f(z)\,dz = 0 for every closed piecewise smooth path \gamma in D, simple or not.
On the hypotheses. Results 1 and 2 are proved below assuming also that f' is continuous. Cauchy’s proof made the same assumption; Goursat removed it, and Results 4 and 5 do not use it. Cauchy's integral formula uses Results 3 and 5 to show that f' is again holomorphic, hence continuous, so Results 1 and 2 hold exactly as stated.
Why it is true
Result 1. Proof, with f' continuous on G. By Result 2 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations, f' = u_x + iv_x = v_y - iu_y, so the first partials of u and v are continuous and satisfy the Cauchy-Riemann equations. Reversing \gamma only changes the sign, so let \gamma be positively oriented, and let D \subseteq G be \gamma with its inside. By Result 2 of Contour integrals and Green’s theorem (Result 1 of Green's theorem),
so \int_\gamma f(z)\,dz = 0. \blacksquare
Result 2. Proof, with f' continuous. Positively oriented, the boundary of K is \gamma_1 with -\gamma_0. Green’s theorem for a region with a hole (Result 2 of Green's theorem, proved there for regions cut into pieces of type I and type II, and in general in a later course) and the same two computations give \int_{\gamma_1} f - \int_{\gamma_0} f = 0. \blacksquare
Result 3. Proof. \displaystyle \frac{1}{z - z_0} is holomorphic on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{z_0\} with continuous derivative. If z_0 is outside \gamma, Result 1 gives 0. If z_0 is inside, the inside is open, so some \overline{D}(z_0, r) lies inside \gamma. The region between C(z_0, r) and \gamma misses z_0, so Result 2 and Result 4 of Contour integrals give \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z - z_0} = \int_{C(z_0, r)} \frac{dz}{z - z_0} = 2\pi i. \blacksquare
Result 4. Proof. (a) Let d be the diameter of T, \ell its perimeter and I = \left|\int_{\partial T} f(z)\,dz\right|. The segments joining the midpoints of the sides cut T into four triangles similar to T with ratio \displaystyle \frac12, each traced counterclockwise (Figure 2). Each inner edge is traced once each way, so the two integrals cancel (Result 2 of Contour integrals), and \int_{\partial T} f is the sum of the four. One has modulus at least \displaystyle \frac{I}{4}; call its triangle T_1. Repeating gives closed triangles T \supseteq T_1 \supseteq T_2 \supseteq \cdots of diameter \displaystyle \frac{d}{2^n} and perimeter \displaystyle \frac{\ell}{2^n} with
Pick z_n \in T_n. By Subsequences and Bolzano-Weierstrass, applied to real and imaginary parts, a subsequence converges to some z_0. For m \ge n, z_m \in T_n, which is closed, so z_0 \in T_n for every n.
By Result 1(a) of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations, f(z) = f(z_0) + \varphi(z)(z - z_0) with \varphi continuous at z_0 and \varphi(z_0) = f'(z_0), so
The polynomial part has an antiderivative, so its integral around \partial T_n is 0 (Result 5 of Contour integrals). Given \varepsilon > 0, choose \delta with |\varphi(z) - f'(z_0)| < \varepsilon for |z - z_0| < \delta. Once \displaystyle \frac{d}{2^n} < \delta, every z on \partial T_n has \displaystyle |z - z_0| \le \frac{d}{2^n}, and the ML-inequality gives
So I \le \varepsilon d\ell for every \varepsilon > 0, and I = 0.
(b) If p \notin T, use (a) on G \setminus \{p\}. If p is a vertex, let the vertices be p, b, c in counterclockwise order, and for 0 < s < 1 let b_s = p + s(b - p) and c_s = p + s(c - p). The counterclockwise triangles (p, b_s, c_s), (b_s, b, c) and (b_s, c, c_s) make up T, and their inner edges cancel. The last two miss p, so their integrals are 0 by (a). With |f| \le M on the compact set T (The extreme value theorem), the first has integral at most Ms\ell, so \left|\int_{\partial T} f\right| \le Ms\ell for every s, and it is 0. If p is in T but not a vertex, the segments from p to the vertices cut T into two or three triangles with vertex p. \blacksquare
Result 5. Proof. Let c be the center of D and F(z) = \int_{[c, z]} f(w)\,dw. Fix z \in D and h \ne 0 small with z + h \in D. A disk is convex, so the triangle spanned by c, z, z + h lies in D, and Result 4(b) gives
(If the three points are on one line, this is additivity of a real integral along that line.) So F(z + h) - F(z) = \int_{[z, z + h]} f(w)\,dw, and the estimate in the proof of Result 6 of Contour integrals, which uses only the continuity of f at z, gives F'(z) = f(z). Result 5 of Contour integrals then gives \int_\gamma f = 0 for every closed \gamma in D. \blacksquare
Worked examples
Integrals that vanish
Find (a) \displaystyle \int_{\partial Q} \frac{e^{z}}{z^2 + 9}\,dz, where Q is the square with vertices \pm 2 \pm 2i, traced counterclockwise; (b) \int_{C(0, 1)} \operatorname{Log}(z + 2)\,dz; (c) \int_{C(0, 1)} \tan z\,dz.
SolutionIn each case we find an open set G where the integrand is holomorphic that contains the loop and its inside; Result 1 then gives 0.
(a) z^2 + 9 = 0 only at \pm 3i, so the integrand is holomorphic on the strip G = \{z : |\operatorname{Im} z| < 3\}. The square and its inside have |\operatorname{Im} z| \le 2, so they lie in G, and the integral is 0.
(b) \operatorname{Log}(z + 2) is holomorphic on G = \mathbb{C} \setminus (-\infty, -2] by the chain rule. The closed unit disk has \operatorname{Re} z \ge -1, so the integral is 0.
(c) From \cos(x + iy) = \cos x\cosh y - i\sin x\sinh y, |\cos(x + iy)|^2 = \cos^2 x + \sinh^2 y, which is 0 only when y = 0 and \cos x = 0. So the zeros of \cos z are \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2} + k\pi, and \tan z is holomorphic on \displaystyle D\left(0, \frac{\pi}{2}\right), which contains the closed unit disk. The integral is 0.
One pole inside, then two
Let \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{z + 5}{z^2 + 2z - 3}. Find \int_\gamma f(z)\,dz for the boundary \gamma of the square |x| + |y| \le 2, counterclockwise, and for C(-1, 3).
Solutionz^2 + 2z - 3 = (z - 1)(z + 3), and partial fractions give
The inside of the square is |x| + |y| < 2, which contains 1 but not -3. By Result 3 and linearity,
On C(-1, 3) both points are inside, as each is at distance 2 from -1, so the integral is \displaystyle \left(\frac32 - \frac12\right)2\pi i = 2\pi i.
A removable point
Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{e^{2z}}{z}\,dz for \gamma(t) = (2 + \cos 3t)e^{it}, 0 \le t \le 2\pi (Figure 1).
Solution|\gamma(t)| = 2 + \cos 3t \ge 1 and \gamma meets each ray from 0 once, so it is simple. The points re^{i\theta} with r < 2 + \cos 3\theta form a bounded connected set missing \gamma, and those with r > 2 + \cos 3\theta an unbounded one; so the first is the inside, and it contains 0. Split the integrand:
As z \to 0, g(z) tends to the derivative of e^{2z} at 0, which is 2; with g(0) = 2, g is continuous on \mathbb{C} and holomorphic off 0. The path lies in D(0, 4), so Result 5 gives \int_\gamma g(z)\,dz = 0, and Result 3 gives \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z} = 2\pi i. So
which is 2\pi i times e^{2 \cdot 0}, a first case of Cauchy's integral formula.
Circulation in a wind tunnel
Isabel and Samir test a long cylinder of radius 2 decimeters set across a wind tunnel. In a cross-section, with z in decimeters from the axis, they model the air velocity \mathbf{V} = (P, Q), in decimeters per second, by
As in Example 5 of Contour integrals, the real and imaginary parts of \int_\gamma \overline{V}\,dz are the circulation and the outward flux. Show that the air flows along the cylinder’s surface, and find the circulation and flux around every positively oriented simple closed loop in |z| > 2, such as the rectangle with vertices -6 - 4i, 7 - 4i, 7 + 4i, -6 + 4i traced by Isabel’s probe.
SolutionAt z = 2e^{i\theta} the outward normal is (\cos\theta, \sin\theta), and P\cos\theta + Q\sin\theta = \operatorname{Re}\big(\overline{V}e^{i\theta}\big). Here
so the normal component is 0: no air crosses the surface.
The formula defines a function holomorphic on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\}. The terms 12 and \displaystyle -\frac{48}{z^2} have antiderivatives 12z and \displaystyle \frac{48}{z} there, so they integrate to 0. The disk |z| \le 2 is connected and misses \gamma, so it is wholly inside or wholly outside: \gamma encloses the cylinder exactly when 0 is inside it. By Result 3,
around every loop enclosing the cylinder, and 0 around every other. So the circulation is 40\pi \approx 125.7 square decimeters per second and the flux 0 around any loop enclosing the cylinder, whatever its shape. Isabel’s rectangle stays at distance at least 4 from 0 and encloses it, so her probe reads exactly that.
A short proof: a degree gap of two
Let q be a polynomial of degree n \ge 2, p a polynomial of degree at most n - 2, and \gamma a positively oriented simple closed piecewise smooth path with every zero of q inside it. Prove that \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{p(z)}{q(z)}\,dz = 0.
SolutionProof. |z| has a maximum R_0 on the compact set \gamma (The extreme value theorem). Let R > \max(R_0, 1). The set |z| \ge R is connected, unbounded and misses \gamma, so it lies outside \gamma; hence \gamma and its inside lie in D(0, R). The zeros of q are inside \gamma, so \displaystyle \frac{p}{q} is holomorphic on an open set containing the region between \gamma and C(0, R), and Result 2 gives
Let b_n be the leading coefficient of q and A the sum of the moduli of the coefficients of p. For large R, Exercise 17 of Contour integrals gives \displaystyle |q(z)| \ge \frac{|b_n|R^n}{2} on |z| = R, while |p(z)| \le AR^{n - 2}. By the ML-inequality the right side has modulus at most
The left side does not depend on R and is bounded by a quantity tending to 0, so it is 0. \blacksquare
This settles the claim of Example 4 of Contour integrals: the zeros of z^5 - 2 have modulus 2^{1/5}, so \displaystyle \int_{C(0, R)} \frac{z^2 + 3}{z^5 - 2}\,dz = 0 for every R > 2^{1/5}.
A Gaussian integral by moving the line
Show that
e^{-z^2} is entire, so by Result 1 its integral around the rectangle with vertices -a, a, a + i, -a + i, counterclockwise, is 0. The bottom side gives \int_{-a}^{a} e^{-x^2}\,dx. On the top, z = x + i runs from x = a to -a, and (x + i)^2 = x^2 - 1 + 2ix, so it gives -e\int_{-a}^{a} e^{-x^2}e^{-2ix}\,dx. On each end, z = \pm a + iy with 0 \le y \le 1, |e^{-z^2}| = e^{y^2 - a^2} \le e^{1 - a^2} over a length 1. Let J_a = \int_{-a}^{a} e^{-x^2}\cos 2x\,dx. Taking real parts, with \operatorname{Re} e^{-2ix} = \cos 2x,
As a \to \infty the integral tends to \displaystyle \sqrt{\pi} (Example 6 of Double integrals in polar coordinates), and J_a converges since |e^{-x^2}\cos 2x| \le e^{-x^2} (Improper integrals). So \displaystyle e\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} e^{-x^2}\cos 2x\,dx = \sqrt{\pi}, and the value is about 0.6520.
Boundaries
The inside must be covered, not only the loop. \displaystyle \frac{1}{z} is holomorphic on the open annulus \displaystyle \{z : \frac12 < |z| < 2\} around C(0, 1), yet \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 1)} \frac{dz}{z} = 2\pi i (Exercise 15).
The theorem is sufficient, not necessary. \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 1)} \frac{dz}{z^2} = 0 although \displaystyle \frac{1}{z^2} is not holomorphic at 0, and \int_{C(0, 1)} |z|^2\,dz = 0 although |z|^2 is holomorphic on no open set (Exercise 14).
Simple loops count once. Run twice, C(0, 1) gives \displaystyle \int \frac{dz}{z} = 4\pi i; run clockwise, -2\pi i. The general count is the winding number \displaystyle n(\gamma, z_0) = \frac{1}{2\pi i}\int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z - z_0}, used in The argument principle and Rouché's theorem.
Result 5 needs a convex set and a point of continuity. Its proof works on any convex open set. On the annulus above, \displaystyle \frac{1}{z} has no antiderivative, and on D(0, 1) it is not continuous at 0.
Where this goes next
Cauchy's integral formula applies Result 5 to \displaystyle \frac{f(\zeta) - f(z)}{\zeta - z}, continuous at \zeta = z as g was in Example 3, and finds the values of f inside a circle from its values on it; Liouville's theorem and the fundamental theorem of algebra and The maximum modulus principle follow. Result 2 with a small circle around each bad point starts the The residue theorem, and the moved line of Example 6 returns in Real integrals by residues.
Beck’s text states Cauchy’s theorem in a deformation form: if two closed paths can be deformed continuously into each other through closed paths in a region G (they are G-homotopic) and f is holomorphic on G, their integrals are equal. Results 1 and 2 are special cases. That form is stated here without proof.
Exercises
Integrals that are zero
- Find \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 2)} \frac{z^3}{z^2 - 2z + 5}\,dz.
- Find \int_{C(3i, 2)} \operatorname{Log} z\,dz.
- Find \displaystyle \int_{C(\pi/2, 1)} \frac{dz}{\sin z}.
Points inside and outside
- Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z^2 + 1}, where \gamma is the boundary of the rectangle with vertices -1, 1, 1 + 2i, -1 + 2i, counterclockwise.
- Find \displaystyle \int \frac{z\,dz}{(z - 1)(z + 2)} around C(0, 3) and around C(1, 2).
- Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{3z + 4}{z^2 - z - 6}\,dz, where \gamma is the boundary of the triangle with vertices -1 - i, 4, -1 + i, counterclockwise.
- Let \gamma be a positively oriented simple closed piecewise smooth path through neither 0 nor 1. Find every possible value of \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z^2 - z}, and say which loops give each.
A removable point
- Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{\cos z}{z}\,dz, where \gamma is the boundary of the square with vertices \pm 1 \pm i, counterclockwise.
- Find \displaystyle \int_{C(1, 2)} \frac{e^{\pi z} + 3}{z}\,dz.
Moving the loop
- Let \gamma be the ellipse \displaystyle \frac{x^2}{16} + \frac{y^2}{4} = 1, counterclockwise. Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{z - 1 - i} and \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{dz}{(z - 1 - i)^2}.
- Find \displaystyle \int_\gamma \frac{z\,dz}{z^2 - 1}, where \gamma is the boundary of the rectangle with vertices \pm 2 \pm i, traced clockwise.
- In the setting of Example 4, a cylinder of radius 3 decimeters has \displaystyle \overline{V} = 10 - \frac{90}{z^2} + \frac{18i}{z} for |z| \ge 3. Check that the air flows along the surface, and find the circulation and the flux around the rectangle with vertices \pm 8 \pm 5i, counterclockwise, and around C(6i, 2).
- Use a rectangle of height \displaystyle \frac32 to show that \displaystyle \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} e^{-x^2}\cos 3x\,dx = \sqrt{\pi}\,e^{-9/4}.
Explaining
- Show that \int_{C(0, 1)} |z|^2\,dz = 0 and \int_{C(0, 1)} \overline{z}\,dz = 2\pi i. Neither integrand is holomorphic on any open set; explain why the first value does not follow from Result 1 and the second does not contradict it.
- Refute this claim: “\displaystyle \frac{1}{z} is holomorphic on the annulus \displaystyle \{z : \frac12 < |z| < 2\}, an open set containing C(0, 1), so Result 1 gives \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 1)} \frac{dz}{z} = 0.”
Proofs
- Let f be holomorphic on an open set containing a closed rectangle R, with boundary \partial R traced counterclockwise. Prove that \int_{\partial R} f(z)\,dz = 0 from Result 4, without Green’s theorem.
- Let f be holomorphic on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\}. Prove that \int_{C(0, r)} f(z)\,dz is the same for every r > 0, and that it is 0 if f is bounded on some punctured disk D(0, \rho) \setminus \{0\}.
- Let D be an open disk, p_1, \dots, p_k points of D, and f continuous on D and holomorphic on D \setminus \{p_1, \dots, p_k\}. Prove that f has an antiderivative on D.
- Let a \ne b with |a| < r and |b| < r. Prove that \displaystyle \int_{C(0, r)} \frac{dz}{(z - a)(z - b)} = 0 in two ways: by partial fractions, and by Example 5.
Answers
- 0. The zeros of z^2 - 2z + 5 are 1 \pm 2i, of modulus \displaystyle \sqrt5 > 2, so the integrand is holomorphic on \displaystyle D(0, \sqrt5); Result 1.
- 0. The closed disk |z - 3i| \le 2 has \operatorname{Im} z \ge 1, so it lies in the slit plane, where \operatorname{Log} is holomorphic; Result 1.
- 0. |\sin(x + iy)|^2 = \sin^2 x + \sinh^2 y (The complex exponential and logarithm), so the zeros of \sin z are the k\pi, all at distance at least \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2} > 1 from \displaystyle \frac{\pi}{2}; \displaystyle \frac{1}{\sin z} is holomorphic on \displaystyle D\left(\frac{\pi}{2}, \frac{\pi}{2}\right); Result 1.
- \pi. \displaystyle \frac{1}{z^2 + 1} = \frac{1}{2i}\left(\frac{1}{z - i} - \frac{1}{z + i}\right), with i inside and -i outside, so Result 3 gives \displaystyle \frac{1}{2i} \cdot 2\pi i = \pi.
- 2\pi i and \displaystyle \frac{2\pi i}{3}. \displaystyle \frac{z}{(z - 1)(z + 2)} = \frac{1/3}{z - 1} + \frac{2/3}{z + 2}. Both points are inside C(0, 3), giving \displaystyle \left(\frac13 + \frac23\right)2\pi i; only 1 is inside C(1, 2), as |-2 - 1| = 3, giving \displaystyle \frac13 \cdot 2\pi i.
- \displaystyle \frac{26\pi i}{5}. \displaystyle \frac{3z + 4}{z^2 - z - 6} = \frac{13/5}{z - 3} + \frac{2/5}{z + 2}. At x = 3 the triangle spans \displaystyle |y| \le \frac15, so 3 is inside; -2 is outside, as the triangle has x \ge -1. Result 3 gives \displaystyle \frac{13}{5} \cdot 2\pi i.
- 2\pi i, -2\pi i or 0. \displaystyle \frac{1}{z^2 - z} = \frac{1}{z - 1} - \frac{1}{z}, so by Result 3 the value is 2\pi i if only 1 is inside \gamma, -2\pi i if only 0 is, and 0 if both or neither are.
- 2\pi i. \displaystyle \frac{\cos z}{z} = \frac{1}{z} + \frac{\cos z - 1}{z}; the second term tends to 0, the derivative of \cos z at 0, so with that value it is continuous, and Result 5 on D(0, 2) gives 0 for it. Result 3 gives 2\pi i for the first.
- 8\pi i. \displaystyle \frac{e^{\pi z} + 3}{z} = \frac{4}{z} + \frac{e^{\pi z} - 1}{z}; the second term tends to \pi at 0, so Result 5 on D(1, 3) gives 0 for it. As 0 is inside C(1, 2), Result 3 gives 4 \cdot 2\pi i.
- 2\pi i and 0. \displaystyle \frac{1}{16} + \frac14 = \frac{5}{16} < 1, so 1 + i is inside, and Result 3 gives 2\pi i. \displaystyle \frac{1}{(z - 1 - i)^2} has the antiderivative \displaystyle -\frac{1}{z - 1 - i} off 1 + i, so the second integral is 0.
- -2\pi i. \displaystyle \frac{z}{z^2 - 1} = \frac12\left(\frac{1}{z - 1} + \frac{1}{z + 1}\right) with \pm 1 inside, so counterclockwise the value is \displaystyle \frac12(2\pi i + 2\pi i) = 2\pi i; clockwise reverses the sign.
- At z = 3e^{i\theta}, \overline{V}e^{i\theta} = 10e^{i\theta} - 10e^{-i\theta} + 6i = (20\sin\theta + 6)i, purely imaginary, so the normal component is 0. The rectangle stays in |z| \ge 5 and encloses 0, so \int \overline{V}\,dz = 18i \cdot 2\pi i = -36\pi: circulation -36\pi, that is 36\pi \approx 113.1 square decimeters per second clockwise, and flux 0. The disk |z - 6i| \le 2 has |z| \ge 4, so C(6i, 2) lies in the air and does not enclose 0: circulation and flux 0.
- Use the rectangle with vertices -a, a, \displaystyle a + \frac{3i}{2}, \displaystyle -a + \frac{3i}{2}. Since \displaystyle \left(x + \frac{3i}{2}\right)^2 = x^2 - \frac94 + 3ix, the top gives -e^{9/4}\int_{-a}^{a} e^{-x^2}e^{-3ix}\,dx, and on each end |e^{-z^2}| \le e^{9/4 - a^2} over a length \displaystyle \frac32. Result 1, real parts and a \to \infty give \displaystyle \sqrt{\pi} = e^{9/4}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} e^{-x^2}\cos 3x\,dx, so the integral is \displaystyle \sqrt{\pi}\,e^{-9/4} \approx 0.1868.
- On the circle |z|^2 = 1 and \displaystyle \overline{z} = \frac{1}{z}, so the integrals are \int_{C(0, 1)} 1\,dz = 0 and \displaystyle \int_{C(0, 1)} \frac{dz}{z} = 2\pi i. Result 1 is a sufficient condition only: it neither gives the first value nor forbids the second. An integral sees only the values on the path: there |z|^2 agrees with the entire function 1, and \overline{z} with \displaystyle \frac1z, which is not holomorphic at 0.
- Result 1 needs an open set containing the loop and its inside. The inside of C(0, 1) is D(0, 1), which contains 0, where \displaystyle \frac1z is undefined; the annulus does not contain it. The value is 2\pi i.
- Proof. Let the vertices be a, b, c, d counterclockwise. The diagonal [a, c] cuts R into the counterclockwise triangles T' with vertices a, b, c and T'' with vertices a, c, d. In \partial T' + \partial T'' the segments [c, a] and [a, c] cancel, so \int_{\partial R} f = \int_{\partial T'} f + \int_{\partial T''} f = 0 by Result 4(a). \blacksquare
- Proof. For 0 < r_1 < r_2, C(0, r_1) and its inside lie in the inside of C(0, r_2), and the region between is \{z : r_1 \le |z| \le r_2\}, inside the open set \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\}; Result 2 gives equal integrals. If |f| \le M on D(0, \rho) \setminus \{0\}, then for r < \rho the ML-inequality bounds the common value by 2\pi rM, which tends to 0 as r \to 0^+; so it is 0. \blacksquare
- Proof. As in the proof of Result 5, it suffices that \int_{\partial T} f = 0 for every closed triangle T in D. Let \delta be the least distance between two of the p_j (any \delta > 0 if k = 1). Cutting T by midpoints repeatedly gives triangles of diameter less than \delta, each containing at most one p_j, and the inner edges cancel. For such a triangle S, removing from D the p_j not in S leaves an open set containing S on which Result 4 applies, so \int_{\partial S} f = 0, and the sum is 0. \blacksquare
- Proof. \displaystyle \frac{1}{(z - a)(z - b)} = \frac{1}{a - b}\left(\frac{1}{z - a} - \frac{1}{z - b}\right), and both a and b are inside C(0, r), so Result 3 gives \displaystyle \frac{1}{a - b}(2\pi i - 2\pi i) = 0. Alternatively, (z - a)(z - b) has degree 2, the numerator 1 has degree 0 = 2 - 2, and both zeros are inside C(0, r), so Example 5 gives 0. \blacksquare