The maximum modulus principle
Where can the modulus of a holomorphic function be largest, and what do its values on the edge of a region say about its values inside?
Where you are 5 in Complex integration
Why this exists
A continuous real function on a closed interval can peak anywhere: 1 - x^2 is largest at 0, in the middle of [-1, 1]. The modulus of a holomorphic function never peaks inside its region. Over a closed bounded region the largest value of |f| sits on the boundary, so the boundary values bound every value within. Harmonic functions obey the same rule in both directions: a steady temperature is hottest and coldest on the edge of a plate, and a soap film spanning a bent wire is highest and lowest on the wire. The tool is the average over a circle from Cauchy's integral formula: a value that is the average of the values around it cannot exceed all of them.
Definition
Regions, boundaries and closures are as in Limits and continuity in the complex plane: a region is a nonempty open connected set, \partial G is the set of boundary points of G, and \overline{G} = G \cup \partial G.
Let U be an open set and \varphi : U \to \mathbb{R}; here \varphi is |f| or a harmonic u. Then \varphi has a local maximum at z_0 \in U if there is R > 0 with D(z_0, R) \subseteq U and \varphi(z) \le \varphi(z_0) for every z \in D(z_0, R), and a local minimum if \varphi(z) \ge \varphi(z_0) there. Equality is allowed, so a constant has a local maximum at every point. For a set S, \varphi attains its maximum over S at z_0 \in S if \varphi(z) \le \varphi(z_0) for every z \in S; then \max_S \varphi = \varphi(z_0). Minimum likewise.
A continuous function \varphi on U, real or complex, has the mean-value property if
for every closed disk \overline{D}(z_0, r) \subseteq U. The maximum modulus principle is the statement, made exact in Results 2 to 4, that the modulus of a nonconstant holomorphic function on a region has no local maximum.
Intuition
Suppose |f| has a local maximum M = |f(z_0)| at z_0, and draw a small circle about z_0. The values of f on it lie in the closed disk \overline{D}(0, M), and by the mean-value property their average is f(z_0), a point on the edge of that disk. An average of points of a disk lands on its edge only when all of them sit at that edge point; wherever f strays inward, it pulls the average inward. So f is constant on the circle.
So the graph of |f| has no peaks, and its only pits go down to 0, at zeros of f. In Figure 1 the closed level curves circle the zero, and the rest run out to the boundary, where the highest value lies.
A real derivative sees two directions, a complex one all of them: 1 - x^2 peaks at 0, but |1 - z^2| grows as z leaves 0 along the imaginary axis (Exercise 11).
Results
1. Mean-value property. (a) If f is holomorphic on an open set containing \overline{D}(z_0, r), then
(b) If u is harmonic on an open set containing \overline{D}(z_0, r), the same holds with u in place of f.
2. No local maximum. Let f be holomorphic on an open set U, and let |f| have a local maximum at z_0, with |f(z)| \le |f(z_0)| on D(z_0, R) \subseteq U. Then f is constant on D(z_0, R). If U is a region, f is constant on U.
The last sentence rests on the identity principle (a function holomorphic on a region and constant on a disk in it is constant), proved in Holomorphic functions are power series. Nothing else here uses it.
3. Maximum over a region. Let f be holomorphic on a region G. If |f| attains its maximum over G at a point of G, then f is constant on G.
4. Bounded regions. Let G be a bounded region and f continuous on \overline{G} and holomorphic on G. Then |f| attains its maximum over \overline{G} at a point of \partial G:
If f is not constant on G, then |f(z)| < \max_{\partial G}|f| for every z \in G.
5. Minimum modulus. Let f be holomorphic on a region G with f(z) \ne 0 for every z \in G. (a) If |f| has a local minimum at z_0 \in G, then f is constant on a disk centered at z_0. If |f| attains its minimum over G at a point of G, then f is constant on G. (b) If G is bounded and f is continuous on \overline{G}, then |f| attains its minimum over \overline{G} at a point of \partial G.
6. Harmonic functions. Let u be harmonic on a region G. (a) If u attains its maximum or its minimum over G at a point of G, then u is constant on G. (b) If G is bounded and u is continuous on \overline{G}, then u attains its maximum and its minimum over \overline{G} at points of \partial G. If moreover u is not constant on G, then for every z \in G
Why it is true
Lemma (constant modulus). If f is holomorphic on a region G and |f| is constant on G, then f is constant on G.
Proof. Write f = u + iv and u^2 + v^2 = c. If c = 0, then f = 0. Otherwise differentiate, the partials existing by Result 2 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations: uu_x + vv_x = 0 and uu_y + vv_y = 0. The Cauchy-Riemann equations v_x = -u_y, v_y = u_x turn these into
The first times u plus the second times v gives cu_x = 0; the first times -v plus the second times u gives cu_y = 0. So u_x = u_y = 0, then v_x = -u_y = 0, and f' = u_x + iv_x = 0 on G. By Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations, f is constant. \blacksquare
Result 1. Proof. (a) Result 1 of Cauchy's integral formula at w = z_0, with z = z_0 + re^{it} and dz = ire^{it}\,dt, gives
which is the formula. (b) The open set contains a disk D(z_0, R) with R > r, as shown in the proof of Result 1 of Cauchy's integral formula. By Result 5 of Harmonic functions there is f holomorphic on D(z_0, R) with \operatorname{Re} f = u. Apply (a) to f and take real parts. \blacksquare
Result 2. Proof. Let M = |f(z_0)| and 0 < r < R. Result 1 applies to \overline{D}(z_0, r), and with Result 1(c) of Contour integrals
So \int_0^{2\pi} \big(M - |f(z_0 + re^{it})|\big)\,dt = 0. The integrand is continuous and nonnegative; were it positive at one t, it would exceed some \varepsilon > 0 on an interval, and the integral would be positive. So |f| = M on every circle C(z_0, r), 0 < r < R: |f| is constant on the region D(z_0, R), and the Lemma makes f constant there. If U is a region, the identity principle carries this to all of U. \blacksquare
Result 3. Proof. Let |f| attain its maximum M over G at z_0, and E = \{z \in G : |f(z)| = M\}, which contains z_0. Each w \in E is a local maximum of |f|, since |f| \le M = |f(w)| on any disk D(w, \rho) \subseteq G. Result 2 makes f constant on that disk, so |f| = M there and D(w, \rho) \subseteq E: E is open. Its complement \{z \in G : |f(z)| < M\} is open as |f| is continuous. Two disjoint open sets are separated, and G is connected, so the complement is empty. So |f| = M on G, and the Lemma makes f constant. \blacksquare
Result 4. Proof. \overline{G} is closed and bounded, so the continuous |f| attains a maximum M over it at some p: if |f(z_n)| \to \sup_{\overline{G}}|f|, a subsequence of z_n converges to some p \in \overline{G} by Subsequences and Bolzano-Weierstrass on real and imaginary parts, and |f(p)| is the supremum by continuity, as in The extreme value theorem. If p \in G, Result 3 gives f = c on G; every point of \partial G is a limit of points of G, so f = c on \overline{G} by continuity. And \partial G is not empty: otherwise G = \overline{G} is closed, and G and \mathbb{C} \setminus G (nonempty, as G is bounded) are disjoint open sets covering \mathbb{C}, which is connected by Result 7 of Limits and continuity in the complex plane. Either way |f| reaches M on \partial G. If |f(z)| = M at some z \in G, Result 3 makes f constant; so for nonconstant f, |f| < M on G. \blacksquare
Result 5. Proof. \displaystyle g = \frac{1}{f} is holomorphic on G, and |g| has a local maximum, or attains its maximum over G, exactly where |f| has a local minimum, or attains its minimum. Results 2 and 3 for g give (a). For (b), |f| attains a minimum m over \overline{G} at some p. If m = 0, then f(p) = 0, so p \notin G and p \in \partial G. If m > 0, then g is continuous on \overline{G} and holomorphic on G, and by Result 4, |g| attains its maximum \displaystyle \frac{1}{m} at some q \in \partial G, where |f(q)| = m. \blacksquare
Result 6. Proof. (a) Let u attain its maximum M over G at z_0, and E = \{z \in G : u(z) = M\}. For w \in E and a disk D = D(w, \rho) \subseteq G, Result 5 of Harmonic functions gives f holomorphic on D with \operatorname{Re} f = u. Then g = e^{f} is holomorphic on D and |g| = e^{u} \le e^{M} = |g(w)|, so by Result 2 g is constant on D, and so is u = \ln|g|: u = M on D. So E is open, its complement in G is open by continuity, and as in Result 3, u = M on G. For a minimum, apply this to -u. (b) follows from (a), for u and -u, as Result 4 follows from Result 3. \blacksquare
Worked examples
Largest and smallest on a disk
Find the maximum and the minimum of |z^2 + 4z + 1| over the closed unit disk \overline{D}(0, 1), and where each is attained.
Solutionf(z) = z^2 + 4z + 1 is entire, so by Result 4 with G = D(0, 1) the maximum lies on the circle. For z = e^{it}, \displaystyle \frac1z = \overline{z}, so
and |f(e^{it})| = 4 + 2\cos t, largest, 6, at t = 0 and smallest, 2, at t = \pi. As f is not constant, |f| < 6 in the open disk: the maximum is 6, attained only at z = 1.
The minimum is not on the circle. The zeros of f are \displaystyle -2 \pm \sqrt3, and \displaystyle |-2 + \sqrt3| = 2 - \sqrt3 \approx 0.268 < 1, so the minimum is 0, at \displaystyle -2 + \sqrt3. Result 5 does not apply, because f has a zero in G (Figure 1).
A square
Find the maximum of |z^2 - 2z| over the closed square Q with corners 0, 2, 2 + 2i, 2i.
SolutionThe open square is a bounded region and f(z) = z(z - 2) is entire, so by Result 4 the maximum is on the edges; no critical point inside needs finding.
- Bottom, z = x, 0 \le x \le 2: |f| = x(2 - x) \le 1.
- Left, z = iy: \displaystyle |f| = y\sqrt{y^2 + 4}, increasing, at most \displaystyle 2\sqrt8 = 4\sqrt2 at y = 2.
- Right, z = 2 + iy: |f| = |2 + iy|\,|iy|, the same function of y.
- Top, z = x + 2i: with s = x - 1 \in [-1, 1],
which is at most 32, at s = \pm1.
The maximum is \displaystyle 4\sqrt2 \approx 5.657, at the top corners 2i and 2 + 2i (Figure 2). Inside, |f| is smaller; at the center (1 + i)(-1 + i) = -2, so |f(1 + i)| = 2.
An annulus
Find the maximum of \displaystyle \left|z + \frac1z\right| over the closed annulus 1 \le |z| \le 2.
Solution\displaystyle f(z) = z + \frac1z is holomorphic on \mathbb{C} \setminus \{0\}. The open annulus G = \{z : 1 < |z| < 2\} is a bounded region whose boundary is the two circles, so by Result 4 the maximum is on one of them. On |z| = 1, f(e^{it}) = 2\cos t, so |f| \le 2. On |z| = 2,
so \displaystyle |f|^2 = \frac94 + 4\cos^2 t \le \frac{25}{4}, with equality at t = 0 and \pi. The maximum is \displaystyle \frac52, at z = \pm 2. Inside the values are smaller, for instance \displaystyle f\left(\frac32\right) = \frac{13}{6}.
A harmonic function
Find the maximum and the minimum of u(x, y) = x^2 - y^2 + 2x over the closed unit disk.
Solutionu = \operatorname{Re}(z^2 + 2z), and u_{xx} + u_{yy} = 2 - 2 = 0, so u is harmonic on \mathbb{C} and by Result 6(b) both extremes are on the circle. With x = \cos t, y = \sin t and c = \cos t,
For c \in [-1, 1] this is largest at c = 1 and smallest at \displaystyle c = -\frac12. So the maximum is 3 at z = 1, and the minimum is \displaystyle -\frac32 at \displaystyle z = -\frac12 \pm \frac{\sqrt3}{2}i. As u is not constant, \displaystyle -\frac32 < u < 3 in the open disk. No condition on zeros was needed, whereas |z^2 + 2z| has its minimum 0 at the interior point 0.
A bubble wand
Layla and Jin design giant bubble wands at a toy company. One frame, seen from above, is the circle of radius 2 decimeters about the origin, bent so that above the point 2e^{it} the wire is
centimeters above the table. In the standard small-slope model of a soap film, the film’s height h(x, y) in centimeters over the point (x, y), with x and y in decimeters, is harmonic on D(0, 2), continuous on the closed disk, and equal to the wire’s height on the circle. Jin proposes \displaystyle h = 5 + y + \frac14(x^2 - y^2). (a) Show that this is the film. (b) Find the height at the center. (c) Find the highest and lowest points of the film.
Solution(a) \displaystyle h = \operatorname{Re}\left(5 - iz + \frac14 z^2\right) is harmonic on \mathbb{C}, and at (2\cos t, 2\sin t) it is 5 + 2\sin t + \cos^2 t - \sin^2 t, the wire. If H also has the three properties, w = H - h is harmonic on D(0, 2), continuous on the closed disk and 0 on the circle; by Result 6(b) its maximum and minimum are both 0, so H = h.
(b) By Result 1(b) at z_0 = 0 with r = 2, the center height is the average of the wire’s heights, and \sin t and \cos 2t average to 0: the center is 5 centimeters up.
(c) By Result 6(b) the extremes are on the wire. With s = \sin t and \cos 2t = 1 - 2s^2, the wire’s height is
It is largest, 6.5 centimeters, at \displaystyle s = \frac12, above \displaystyle (\sqrt3, 1) and \displaystyle (-\sqrt3, 1), and smallest, 2 centimeters, at s = -1, above (0, -2). Every point of the film inside the frame is strictly between these heights.
A short proof: a zero inside
Let G be a bounded region, and f continuous on \overline{G}, holomorphic and not constant on G, with |f(z)| = c for every z \in \partial G. Prove that f has a zero in G.
SolutionProof. Suppose f(z) \ne 0 for every z \in G. Since f is not constant, Result 4 gives |f(z)| < c for every z \in G. By Result 5(b), |f| attains its minimum over \overline{G} on \partial G, where its value is c, so |f(z)| \ge c on G. These contradict each other at any point of G. \blacksquare
For instance, \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{2z - 1}{2 - z} has |f| = 1 on C(0, 1), as |2z - 1| = |z|\,|2 - \overline{z}| = |2 - z| there. Its zero is \displaystyle \frac12.
Boundaries
Bounded, and continuous up to the edge. On the right half-plane |e^{z}| = 1 on the boundary but |e^{z}| is unbounded (Exercise 10). On D(0, 1), \displaystyle f(z) = \exp\frac{1 + z}{1 - z} is holomorphic; for z = e^{it} with 0 < t < 2\pi, \displaystyle \frac{1 + z}{1 - z} = i\cot\frac{t}{2}, so |f| = 1 on the circle except at 1, yet f(x) \to \infty as x \to 1^-. Result 4 fails because f has no continuous extension to 1.
Connected. On U = D(0, 1) \cup D(3, 1), the function equal to 0 on the first disk and 1 on the second is holomorphic, |f| has a local maximum at every point, and f is not constant. Results 3 to 6 need a region.
The minimum needs f \ne 0 on G. At a zero of f, |f| has the minimum 0 (Example 1). Harmonic u needs no such condition, as -u is harmonic.
Where this goes next
Liouville's theorem and the fundamental theorem of algebra proves the The fundamental theorem of algebra by Cauchy’s estimates; Exercise 17 proves it again from Result 5. Exercise 16 is the inequality in Schwarz’s lemma, the first step toward the holomorphic bijections of the disk named in Möbius transformations. Exercise 14 says that boundary values determine a solution of the Dirichlet problem; existence on a disk is Poisson’s formula, beyond this course. Holomorphic functions are power series proves the identity principle, completing Result 2.
Exercises
On a disk
- Find the maximum and the minimum of |z^2 - 4| over \overline{D}(0, 1), and where they are attained.
- Find the maximum and the minimum of |e^{z^2}| over \overline{D}(0, 1), and where they are attained.
- Find the maximum of |2z^2 - 5z + 2| over \overline{D}(0, 1), its minimum over the circle |z| = 1, and its minimum over \overline{D}(0, 1).
- Find the maximum and the minimum of u(x, y) = x^3 - 3xy^2 over the closed unit disk, and every point where they are attained.
Other regions
- Find the maximum of |\cos z| over the closed rectangle \displaystyle -\frac{\pi}{2} \le x \le \frac{\pi}{2}, 0 \le y \le 2, and where it is attained.
- Find the maximum of \displaystyle \left|z - \frac1z\right| over the closed annulus 1 \le |z| \le 3, and where it is attained.
Averages
- Use Result 1 to show that \int_0^{2\pi} e^{3\cos t}\cos(3\sin t)\,dt = 2\pi.
- Find \displaystyle \frac{1}{2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi} \frac{dt}{2e^{it} - 4}.
Application
- Another of Layla’s frames is the circle of radius 3 decimeters seen from above, with the wire 10 - 3\cos t + \cos 2t centimeters up over the point 3e^{it}. In the model of Example 5, the film is \displaystyle h = 10 - x + \frac19(x^2 - y^2). Check this, then find the height at the center and the highest and lowest points of the film.
Explaining
- Let H = \{z : \operatorname{Re} z > 0\}. Show that |e^{z}| = 1 on \partial H but |e^{z}| is unbounded on H. Why does this not contradict Result 4, and does |e^{z}| attain a maximum over H?
- The real function 1 - x^2 attains its maximum over [-1, 1] at the interior point 0. Find the maximum of |1 - z^2| over \overline{D}(0, 1), and explain why 0 is not a local maximum of |1 - z^2|.
Proofs
- Let f be holomorphic on an open set containing \overline{D}(z_0, R). Prove that \displaystyle f(z_0) = \frac{1}{\pi R^2}\iint_{\overline{D}(z_0, R)} f\,dA, integrating real and imaginary parts.
- Let f be holomorphic on an open set containing \overline{D}(0, R), and M(r) = \max_{|z| = r}|f(z)| for 0 < r \le R. Prove that M(r_1) \le M(r_2) when r_1 < r_2, with strict inequality unless f is constant on D(0, r_2).
- Let G be a bounded region and f, g continuous on \overline{G} and holomorphic on G, with f = g on \partial G. Prove that f = g on G. Prove the same for u, v harmonic on G and continuous on \overline{G}.
- Let f be holomorphic on a region G, and let \operatorname{Re} f attain its maximum over G at a point of G. Prove that f is constant on G.
- Let f be holomorphic on D(0, 1) with |f(z)| \le 1 there and f(0) = 0. Prove that |f(z)| \le |z| for every z \in D(0, 1), and |f'(0)| \le 1.
- Use Result 5 to prove that every polynomial p of degree n \ge 1 has a zero in \mathbb{C}.
Answers
- Maximum 5 at \pm i; minimum 3 at \pm 1. On the circle |z^2 - 4| = |e^{2it} - 4| runs from 3 (where z^2 = 1) to 5 (where z^2 = -1). The zeros \pm 2 are outside the disk, so Results 4 and 5 apply.
- Maximum e at \pm 1; minimum \displaystyle \frac1e at \pm i. |e^{z^2}| = e^{x^2 - y^2}, which is e^{\cos 2t} on the circle, and e^{z^2} is entire and never 0.
- Maximum 9 at -1; minimum over the circle 1 at 1; minimum over the disk 0 at \displaystyle \frac12. For |z| = 1, 2z^2 - 5z + 2 is z\big(2(z + \overline{z}) - 5\big), or z(4\cos t - 5), of modulus 5 - 4\cos t. The zero \displaystyle \frac12 of (2z - 1)(z - 2) lies inside.
- Maximum 1 at 1 and \displaystyle -\frac12 \pm \frac{\sqrt3}{2}i; minimum -1 at -1 and \displaystyle \frac12 \pm \frac{\sqrt3}{2}i. u = \operatorname{Re} z^3 is harmonic, equal to \cos 3t on the circle; Result 6(b).
- \cosh 2 \approx 3.762, at 2i. \cos(x + iy) = \cos x\cosh y - i\sin x\sinh y, so |\cos z|^2 = \cos^2 x + \sinh^2 y, at most \cosh^2 2, with equality only at x = 0, y = 2, on the top edge.
- \displaystyle \frac{10}{3}, at \pm 3i. On |z| = 1, |e^{it} - e^{-it}| = 2|\sin t| \le 2. On |z| = 3, f is \displaystyle \frac83\cos t + \frac{10}{3}i\sin t, of squared modulus at most \displaystyle \frac{100}{9}, reached at \displaystyle t = \pm\frac{\pi}{2}.
- Result 1(a) with f = e^{z}, z_0 = 0, r = 3 gives \displaystyle \frac{1}{2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi} e^{3e^{it}}\,dt = e^{0} = 1. The real part of e^{3e^{it}} is e^{3\cos t}\cos(3\sin t).
- \displaystyle -\frac14. \displaystyle \frac{1}{z - 4} is holomorphic on D(0, 4) \supseteq \overline{D}(0, 2), so by Result 1(a) the average is its value \displaystyle -\frac14 at 0.
- Center 10 centimeters; highest 14 centimeters above (-3, 0); lowest \displaystyle \frac{63}{8} = 7.875 centimeters above \displaystyle \left(\frac94, \pm\frac{3\sqrt7}{4}\right) \approx (2.25, \pm 1.98). \displaystyle h = \operatorname{Re}\left(10 - z + \frac19 z^2\right) is harmonic and equals 10 - 3\cos t + \cos 2t at (3\cos t, 3\sin t), so by Exercise 14 it is the film. The center is the average, 10. With c = \cos t the wire is 9 - 3c + 2c^2, whose derivative 4c - 3 vanishes at the minimum \displaystyle c = \frac34; on [-1, 1] the maximum is 14 at c = -1 (against 8 at c = 1). Result 6(b).
- On \partial H, |e^{iy}| = 1; on H, |e^{x + iy}| = e^{x}, unbounded. Result 4 needs G bounded. No maximum is attained, as e^{x + 1} > e^{x}, in line with Result 3.
- 2, at \pm i: on the circle |1 - e^{2it}| = |e^{-it} - e^{it}| = 2|\sin t|. At 0, |1 - z^2| = 1, but |1 - (iy)^2| = 1 + y^2 > 1 for y \ne 0, so every disk about 0 holds larger values. The real function sees only the real axis.
- Proof. In polar coordinates about z_0 the integral is \int_0^R I(\rho)\,\rho\,d\rho, where I(\rho) = \int_0^{2\pi} f(z_0 + \rho e^{it})\,dt. By Result 1(a), I(\rho) = 2\pi f(z_0) for 0 < \rho \le R, so the integral is \pi R^2 f(z_0). \blacksquare
- Proof. Let 0 < r_1 < r_2 \le R and G = D(0, r_2). By Result 4, |f(z)| \le \max_{\partial G}|f| = M(r_2) on G, which contains the circle |z| = r_1, so M(r_1) \le M(r_2). If f is not constant on G, Result 4 gives |f(z)| < M(r_2) on G, and M(r_1) is a value |f(z)| with |z| = r_1, so M(r_1) < M(r_2). \blacksquare
- Proof. h = f - g is continuous on \overline{G}, holomorphic on G and 0 on \partial G, so by Result 4, |h| \le \max_{\partial G}|h| = 0 on G. Likewise w = u - v is harmonic on G, as \Delta is linear, continuous on \overline{G} and 0 on \partial G; by Result 6(b) its maximum and minimum are values on \partial G, both 0, so w = 0. \blacksquare
- Proof. Let u = \operatorname{Re} f attain its maximum at z_0. Then g = e^{f} is holomorphic with |g| = e^{u} \le e^{u(z_0)} = |g(z_0)| on G, so by Result 3 g is constant, and so is u = \ln|g|. Then u_x = u_y = 0, the Cauchy-Riemann equations give v_x = -u_y = 0, and f' = u_x + iv_x = 0, so f is constant by Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations. \blacksquare
- Proof. Let \displaystyle g(z) = \frac{f(z)}{z} for z \ne 0 and g(0) = f'(0). As f(0) = 0, this is the function of Example 5 of Cauchy's integral formula with a = 0, so g is holomorphic on D(0, 1). For |z| < r < 1, Result 4 on D(0, r) gives \displaystyle |g(z)| \le \max_{|w| = r}\frac{|f(w)|}{r} \le \frac1r. Letting r \to 1, |g(z)| \le 1: so |f(z)| \le |z|, trivially at 0, and |f'(0)| = |g(0)| \le 1. \blacksquare
- Proof. Write p(z) = a_n z^n + \dots + a_0 with a_n \ne 0, and S = |a_{n-1}| + \dots + |a_0|. For |z| = R \ge 1, |a_k z^k| \le |a_k|R^{n-1} when k < n, so by the reverse triangle inequality of The complex plane, revisited |p(z)| \ge R^{n-1}(|a_n|R - S). Choose R \ge 1 with |a_n|R \ge S + |a_0| + 1; then |p(z)| > |p(0)| on |z| = R. If p had no zeros, Result 5(b) on D(0, R) would give q with |q| = R and |p(q)| \le |p(0)|, a contradiction. \blacksquare