math.wiki
Complex analysis › Complex integration › Liouville's theorem and the fundamental theorem of algebra
Sign in

Liouville's theorem and the fundamental theorem of algebra

A real function can be differentiable everywhere and bounded without being constant, as \sin x is. Can a function with a complex derivative at every point of the plane stay bounded, and what would that say about the roots of polynomials?

Where you are 5 in Complex integration

Why this exists

The lesson on the The fundamental theorem of algebra states that every polynomial of degree n \ge 1 has a complex root and uses it to count roots, but it gives no proof, because every proof needs analysis. Cauchy's integral formula supplies that analysis. Its Cauchy estimate bounds the derivative of a holomorphic function at the center of a circle by the size of the function on the circle, divided by the radius. For an entire function, holomorphic on all of \mathbb{C}, the circle can be as large as we like, and a bound on the function that holds on every circle forces the derivative to be 0.

That is Liouville’s theorem: a bounded entire function is constant. Nothing like it holds on the real line, where \sin x and \displaystyle \frac{1}{1 + x^2} are bounded and differentiable everywhere. Applied to \displaystyle \frac{1}{p} for a polynomial p with no roots, it proves the fundamental theorem of algebra in a few lines.

Definition

A function f is bounded on a set S when there is a real number M with |f(z)| \le M for every z \in S. Liouville’s theorem says: if f is entire and bounded on \mathbb{C}, then f is constant.

Equivalently, every nonconstant entire function is unbounded: for each M there is a z with |f(z)| > M. The theorem carries Liouville’s name, but Cauchy published it earlier.

Intuition

Cauchy’s estimate (Result 4 of Cauchy's integral formula) with n = 1 says that if f is holomorphic on an open set containing \overline{D}(w, R) and |f| \le M on C(w, R), then

|f'(w)| \le \frac{M}{R}.

A function that stays within M of 0 on a large circle cannot change quickly at the center: over a distance R it has room to change by at most about 2M. If f is entire, the circles C(w, R) may be taken as large as we please (Figure 1), and if one M serves for all of them, the bound \displaystyle \frac{M}{R} shrinks to 0.

C(w, 1)
C(w, 2)
C(w, 4)
w
Figure 1The proof of Liouville’s theorem. If |f| \le M on the whole plane, Cauchy’s estimate on C(w, R) gives \displaystyle |f'(w)| \le \frac{M}{R}, and an entire function allows every radius.

The same argument with the nth derivative, \displaystyle |f^{(n)}(w)| \le \frac{n!\,M}{R^n}, allows M to grow with R. If f grows no faster than |z|^s, then M grows like R^s and every derivative of order n > s is forced to vanish: f is a polynomial (Result 2).

Results

1. Liouville’s theorem. If f is entire and there is a real M with |f(z)| \le M for all z \in \mathbb{C}, then f is constant.

2. Polynomial growth. Let f be entire, let s \ge 0 be real, and let A, B, R_0 \ge 0 be constants with

|f(z)| \le A + B|z|^s

whenever |z| \ge R_0. Then f is a polynomial of degree at most \lfloor s \rfloor (a constant if s < 1).

3. A polynomial is comparable to its leading term. Let p(z) = a_d z^d + a_{d-1}z^{d-1} + \dots + a_1 z + a_0 with d \ge 1 and a_d \ne 0, and let S = |a_0| + |a_1| + \dots + |a_{d-1}|. Put \displaystyle R = \max\left(1, \frac{2S}{|a_d|}\right). Then for every z with |z| \ge R,

\tfrac12|a_d||z|^d \le |p(z)| \le \tfrac32|a_d||z|^d.

Moreover every root of p satisfies \displaystyle |z| \le \max\left(1, \frac{S}{|a_d|}\right).

4. The fundamental theorem of algebra. Every polynomial of degree d \ge 1 with complex coefficients has a root in \mathbb{C}. Consequently p(z) = a_d(z - c_1)(z - c_2)\cdots(z - c_d) for some c_1, \dots, c_d \in \mathbb{C}, not necessarily distinct.

Why it is true

Result 1. Proof. Let |f(z)| \le M for all z, and fix w \in \mathbb{C}. For every R > 0, f is holomorphic on the open set \mathbb{C}, which contains \overline{D}(w, R), and |f| \le M on C(w, R). Cauchy’s estimate with n = 1 gives \displaystyle |f'(w)| \le \frac{M}{R}. The left side does not depend on R, and the right side tends to 0 as R \to \infty, so f'(w) = 0. As w was arbitrary, f' = 0 on the region \mathbb{C}, and f is constant by Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations. \blacksquare

Result 2. Proof. Let n = \lfloor s \rfloor + 1, so n > s. Fix w and take R \ge |w| + R_0. Each z on C(w, R) has |z| \ge R - |w| \ge R_0 by the reverse triangle inequality (Result 4 of The complex plane, revisited) and |z| \le |w| + R, so |f(z)| \le A + B(|w| + R)^s. Cauchy’s estimate on C(w, R) gives

\begin{aligned} |f^{(n)}(w)| &\le \frac{n!\,\big(A + B(|w| + R)^s\big)}{R^n} \\ &= n!\left(\frac{A}{R^n} + B\Big(1 + \frac{|w|}{R}\Big)^{s} R^{s - n}\right), \end{aligned}

which tends to 0 as R \to \infty because n > s. So f^{(n)} = 0 on \mathbb{C}.

It remains to show that an entire g with g^{(m)} = 0 is a polynomial of degree at most m - 1, by induction on m \ge 1. For m = 1 this is Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations. If it holds for m and g^{(m+1)} = 0, then g' is entire with (g')^{(m)} = 0, so g'(z) = \sum_{k=0}^{m-1} b_k z^k. The entire function \displaystyle q(z) = g(z) - \sum_{k=0}^{m-1} \frac{b_k}{k + 1}z^{k+1} has q' = 0, so q is a constant b and \displaystyle g = b + \sum_{k=0}^{m-1}\frac{b_k}{k+1}z^{k+1} has degree at most m. With g = f and m = n, f has degree at most n - 1 = \lfloor s \rfloor. \blacksquare

Result 3. Proof. Let |z| \ge R. Since |z| \ge 1, |z|^k \le |z|^{d-1} for 0 \le k \le d - 1, so by the Triangle inequality

\begin{aligned} \Big|\sum_{k=0}^{d-1} a_k z^k\Big| &\le S|z|^{d-1} \\ &\le \tfrac12|a_d|R\,|z|^{d-1} \le \tfrac12|a_d||z|^d, \end{aligned}

using \displaystyle S \le \frac12|a_d|R and R \le |z|. Then \displaystyle |p(z)| \le |a_d||z|^d + \frac12|a_d||z|^d, and by the reverse triangle inequality \displaystyle |p(z)| \ge |a_d||z|^d - \frac12|a_d||z|^d. For the roots: if p(z) = 0 and |z| \ge 1, then |a_d||z|^d = \big|\sum_{k<d} a_k z^k\big| \le S|z|^{d-1}, so \displaystyle |z| \le \frac{S}{|a_d|}. Every root therefore has |z| < 1 or \displaystyle |z| \le \frac{S}{|a_d|}. \blacksquare

Result 4. Proof. Suppose p has degree d \ge 1 and no root. Then \displaystyle f = \frac{1}{p} is entire, a quotient of entire functions with a denominator that never vanishes. With R from Result 3, \displaystyle |f(z)| \le \frac{2}{|a_d||z|^d} \le \frac{2}{|a_d|} for |z| \ge R. On the closed disk \overline{D}(0, R), which is closed and bounded, the continuous function |f| attains a maximum (The extreme value theorem, in its form for closed bounded sets of the plane). So f is bounded on \mathbb{C}, hence constant by Result 1, and so is \displaystyle p = \frac{1}{f}. But by Result 3, \displaystyle |p(z)| \ge \frac12|a_d||z|^d \to \infty, so p is not constant: a contradiction.

For the factorization, the factor theorem (as in The fundamental theorem of algebra) writes p(z) = (z - c_1)q(z) with q of degree d - 1 and leading coefficient a_d, and d applications give the product. \blacksquare

Worked examples

Example 1

Bounded on a line, unbounded on the plane

On the real axis |\sin x| \le 1. Show that |\sin z| \ge |\sinh y| for z = x + iy, and find every point of the imaginary axis where |\sin z| = 12.

Solution

By Result 6 of The complex exponential and logarithm, |\sin z|^2 = \sin^2 x + \sinh^2 y \ge \sinh^2 y, so |\sin z| \ge |\sinh y|. On the imaginary axis x = 0 and |\sin(iy)| = |\sinh y|. The equation \sinh y = 12 reads e^{y} - e^{-y} = 24, that is (e^{y})^2 - 24e^{y} - 1 = 0, whose positive root is \displaystyle e^{y} = 12 + \sqrt{145}. Since \sinh is odd, the points are \displaystyle z = \pm i\ln(12 + \sqrt{145}) \approx \pm 3.180i. Liouville’s theorem predicted that \sin z, entire and nonconstant, must be unbounded somewhere; here it grows like \displaystyle \frac12 e^{|y|} off the real axis.

Example 2

Where the roots are

Show that every root of p(z) = 2z^3 - 6iz + 8 satisfies |z| < 2.2.

Solution

Result 3 gives a first answer: S = 6 + 8 = 14, |a_3| = 2, so every root has |z| \le 7. The idea of its proof gives more. If p(z) = 0 and t = |z|, then 2t^3 = |6iz - 8| \le 6t + 8, so g(t) = t^3 - 3t - 4 \le 0. Now g'(t) = 3t^2 - 3 > 0 for t > 1, g(t) < 0 for 0 \le t \le 1, and g(2.2) = 10.648 - 6.6 - 4 = 0.048 > 0. So g(t) > 0 for t \ge 2.2, and every root has |z| < 2.2.

The exact radius is the positive root t_0 of t^3 - 3t - 4, which Cardano’s formula gives as

t_0 = \sqrt[3]{2 + \sqrt3} + \sqrt[3]{2 - \sqrt3} \approx 2.196.

By Result 4, p has three roots counting multiplicity, all in this disk. Numerically they are z_1 \approx 1.318 + 1.697i, z_2 \approx -1.603 - 0.661i and z_3 \approx 0.285 - 1.035i, of moduli about 2.148, 1.734 and 1.074 (Figure 2). As checks, their sum is 0, the negative of the z^2 coefficient over the leading one, and their product is \displaystyle -4 = -\frac{8}{2}.

\operatorname{Re}
\operatorname{Im}
z_1
z_2
z_3
|z| = t_0
Figure 2Example 2. The three roots of 2z^3 - 6iz + 8, found numerically, all lie in the disk |z| \le t_0 with t_0 \approx 2.196 that the estimate guarantees.
Example 3

Polynomial growth pins down a function

Find every entire f with |f(z)| \le 1 + |z|^3 for all z, f(0) = 1, f'(0) = 0 and f''(0) = 0.

Solution

Result 2 with s = 3, A = B = 1, R_0 = 0 says f(z) = c_0 + c_1 z + c_2 z^2 + c_3 z^3. Then f(0) = c_0 = 1, f'(0) = c_1 = 0 and f''(0) = 2c_2 = 0, so f(z) = 1 + az^3 with a = c_3. The bound decides which a are allowed. If |a| \le 1, the triangle inequality gives |1 + az^3| \le 1 + |a||z|^3 \le 1 + |z|^3. If |a| > 1, the reverse triangle inequality gives |f(z)| \ge |a||z|^3 - 1, which exceeds 1 + |z|^3 once (|a| - 1)|z|^3 > 2. So the answer is exactly the functions

f(z) = 1 + az^3, \qquad |a| \le 1.
Example 4

A short proof: a one-sided bound is enough

Prove that an entire f whose real part is bounded above, \operatorname{Re} f(z) \le M for all z, is constant.

Solution

Proof. The function g = e^{f} is entire, being the composition of entire functions. By the exponent laws |e^{w}| = e^{\operatorname{Re} w}, so |g(z)| = e^{\operatorname{Re} f(z)} \le e^{M}, and g is bounded. By Liouville’s theorem g is constant, so 0 = g' = f'e^{f} by the chain rule. Since e^{f(z)} \ne 0 (Result 1 of The complex exponential and logarithm), f' = 0 on \mathbb{C}, and f is constant by Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations. \blacksquare

The same proof applied to -f handles \operatorname{Re} f \ge m. So an entire function whose values avoid a whole half-plane is constant; Exercise 16 shows the same when the values avoid a disk.

Example 5

A short proof: two periods force a constant

Let f be entire with f(z + 1) = f(z) and f(z + i) = f(z) for all z. Prove that f is constant.

Solution

Proof. From f(z) = f\big((z - 1) + 1\big) = f(z - 1) and induction, f(z + m + ni) = f(z) for all integers m, n. Let Q = \{x + iy : 0 \le x \le 1,\ 0 \le y \le 1\}, a closed bounded square. The continuous function |f| has a maximum M on Q (The extreme value theorem). Any z = x + iy equals q + m + ni with m = \lfloor x \rfloor, n = \lfloor y \rfloor and q = (x - m) + i(y - n) \in Q, so |f(z)| = |f(q)| \le M. Thus f is bounded on \mathbb{C} and constant by Liouville’s theorem. \blacksquare

One period is not enough: \sin 2\pi z is entire with period 1 and is not constant. It has no second period i, and by Example 1 it is unbounded on the vertical strip 0 \le \operatorname{Re} z \le 1.

Example 6

Steady temperature on a wide plain

At a permafrost field station, Mei and Omar model the steady temperature of a thin, flat, very wide layer of frozen ground as a function u(x, y) in degrees Celsius, positions in kilometers. At steady state with no heat sources, u is harmonic, and they idealize the layer as all of \mathbb{R}^2. Omar’s sensors read between -25 and -15 degrees, and he wants a model that stays in that band everywhere. (a) Prove that a harmonic function on all of \mathbb{R}^2 that is bounded above is constant. (b) Mei proposes u(x, y) = -20 + e^{-x}\cos y. Check that it is harmonic and find where it leaves the band along the lines y = 0 and y = \pi.

Solution

(a) Proof. Let u be harmonic on \mathbb{R}^2 with u \le M. Result 4 of Harmonic functions, with D = \mathbb{C}, gives a harmonic conjugate v, so f = u + iv is entire with \operatorname{Re} f = u \le M. By Example 4, f is constant, so u is constant. Applying this to -u shows the same for u bounded below. \blacksquare

(b) u_{xx} = e^{-x}\cos y and u_{yy} = -e^{-x}\cos y, so \Delta u = 0; indeed u = \operatorname{Re}(-20 + e^{-z}). By part (a), a nonconstant model cannot stay in any band, so it must leave Omar’s. Along y = 0, u = -20 + e^{-x} > -15 exactly when e^{-x} > 5, that is x < -\ln 5 \approx -1.609 kilometers. Along y = \pi, \cos \pi = -1 and u = -20 - e^{-x} < -25 for the same x. At x = -2 the model gives -20 + e^{2} \approx -12.61 and -20 - e^{2} \approx -27.39 degrees, and along y = 0 it passes 0 degrees, where the ground would thaw, once x < -\ln 20 \approx -3.0. The honest reading of Liouville’s theorem: a steady temperature that varies at all needs an edge or a source of heat somewhere, and a model on the whole plane must be checked against the region it really describes.

Boundaries

The whole plane. Holomorphic and bounded on a smaller set is not enough. e^{iz} is entire, and on the closed upper half-plane |e^{iz}| = e^{-y} \le 1, yet it is not constant. \displaystyle \frac{1}{1 + z^2} is bounded on |z| \ge 2 and holomorphic off \pm i (Exercise 12).

Complex, not real, derivatives. \sin x and \displaystyle \frac{1}{1 + x^2} are bounded and differentiable on \mathbb{R}. Real differentiability gives no Cauchy formula, and their complex extensions are unbounded or have poles.

Weaker hypotheses. Example 4 and Exercises 15 and 16 show that an entire function whose values avoid a half-plane or a disk is constant. Picard’s little theorem, that an entire function omitting two complex values is constant, is stated here without proof; it is beyond this course. One omitted value is not enough: e^{z} omits 0.

Growth. e^{z} satisfies no bound A + B|z|^s, since \displaystyle \frac{e^{x}}{x^s} \to \infty along the real axis, so Result 2 says nothing about it. Result 2 needs the bound in every direction.

Existence only. The fundamental theorem of algebra gives no formula for the roots, and for degree 5 and higher no formula in radicals exists in general (the Abel-Ruffini theorem, stated without proof, beyond this course). The theorem is about polynomials: the entire function e^{z} has no root at all. The radius in Result 3 is a crude bound; Example 2 shows a sharper one.

Where this goes next

The maximum modulus principle comes from the same integral formula through the mean-value property and gives a local version of the theme here: the size of |f| on a boundary controls it inside. In Holomorphic functions are power series an entire function equals its Taylor series on all of \mathbb{C}, and Result 2 becomes the statement that Cauchy’s estimates kill every coefficient c_n with n > s. The The argument principle and Rouché's theorem counts the roots of a polynomial or a holomorphic function inside a given loop, sharpening disks like the one in Example 2 into exact counts, and it rests on the The residue theorem. Doubly periodic functions, as in Example 5, must have poles if they are not constant; those are the elliptic functions.

Exercises

Bounded on lines, unbounded on the plane

  1. Find every point of the imaginary axis where |\cos z| = 13.
  2. Show that f(z) = e^{-z^2} satisfies |f(x)| \le 1 for real x, and find every real y with |f(iy)| = 100.
  3. Show that |e^{iz}| = 1 on the real axis, and find the point of the imaginary axis where |e^{iz}| = 50.

Where the roots are

  1. Show that every root of z^4 + 2iz - 5 satisfies |z| < 1.71.
  2. For p(z) = 3z^5 - 4z^2 + iz - 2 + 2i, find the radius R of Result 3 and the bounds it gives on |p(z)| for |z| \ge R.
  3. Let p(z) = z^2 + 4z + 8i. Show that \displaystyle \left|\frac{1}{p(z)}\right| \le \frac{1}{100} whenever \displaystyle |z| \ge 2 + 4\sqrt7.

Growth and polynomials

  1. Find every entire f with |f(z)| \le 5|z|^2 + 4 for all z, f(0) = 1, f(1) = 3 and f(-1) = 1.
  2. Show that no entire f satisfies f(0) = 0, f(i) = 3 and |f(z)| \le 2|z|^{3/2} for |z| \ge 1.
  3. Let f be entire with |f(z)| \le |e^{2z}| for all z and \displaystyle f(0) = \frac{i}{2}. Find \displaystyle f\left(\frac{\pi i}{4}\right).
  4. Find every entire f with |f(z)| \le 3|z| for all z and f(2) = 3 - 3i.

Explaining

  1. \sin x is bounded and differentiable at every real x but is not constant. Why does this not contradict Liouville’s theorem?
  2. Show that \displaystyle \left|\frac{1}{1 + z^2}\right| \le \frac13 for |z| \ge 2. Which hypothesis of Liouville’s theorem fails for \displaystyle \frac{1}{1 + z^2}?
  3. e^{z} is entire and never 0, so \displaystyle e^{-z} = \frac{1}{e^{z}} is entire. Why does the proof of Result 4, applied to e^{z} in place of p, not show that e^{z} is constant?
  4. x^2 + 1 has no real root, and \displaystyle \frac{1}{x^2 + 1} is bounded and differentiable on \mathbb{R}. Which step of the proof of Result 4 has no real counterpart?

Proofs

  1. Prove that an entire f with \operatorname{Im} f(z) \ge 0 for all z is constant.
  2. Prove that if f is entire and there are a \in \mathbb{C} and \varepsilon > 0 with |f(z) - a| \ge \varepsilon for all z, then f is constant.
  3. Let f and g be entire, with g(z) \ne 0 and |f(z)| \le |g(z)| for all z. Prove that f = cg for a constant c with |c| \le 1.
  4. Let f be entire with f(z) \to 0 as |z| \to \infty: for every \varepsilon > 0 there is an R with |f(z)| < \varepsilon whenever |z| > R. Prove that f = 0.
  5. Let f be entire with f(z + \omega_1) = f(z) and f(z + \omega_2) = f(z) for all z, where \omega_1, \omega_2 \ne 0 and \displaystyle \frac{\omega_2}{\omega_1} is not real. Prove that f is constant.
  6. Let f be entire with |f'(z)| \le |z| for all z. Prove that f(z) = a + bz^2 for constants a, b with \displaystyle |b| \le \frac12.
Answers
  1. \displaystyle z = \pm i\ln(13 + 2\sqrt{42}) \approx \pm 3.257i. On the imaginary axis \cos(iy) = \cosh y, and \cosh y = 13 gives (e^{y})^2 - 26e^{y} + 1 = 0, so \displaystyle e^{y} = 13 \pm \sqrt{168}; the two roots are reciprocals, giving \displaystyle y = \pm\ln(13 + \sqrt{168}), and \displaystyle \sqrt{168} = 2\sqrt{42}.
  2. \displaystyle y = \pm\sqrt{2\ln 10} \approx \pm 2.146. For real x, |e^{-x^2}| = e^{-x^2} \le 1. At z = iy, -z^2 = y^2, so |f(iy)| = e^{y^2} = 100 gives y^2 = \ln 100 = 2\ln 10.
  3. z = -i\ln 50 \approx -3.912i. |e^{iz}| = e^{\operatorname{Re}(iz)} = e^{-\operatorname{Im} z}, which is 1 on the real axis; at z = iy it is e^{-y} = 50, so y = -\ln 50.
  4. If p(z) = 0 and t = |z|, then t^4 = |5 - 2iz| \le 5 + 2t, so g(t) = t^4 - 2t - 5 \le 0. Now g'(t) = 4t^3 - 2 > 0 for t \ge 1, g(t) < 0 for 0 \le t \le 1, and g(1.71) \approx 0.130 > 0, so g > 0 for t \ge 1.71 and every root has |z| < 1.71. The bound is nearly sharp: z = it_0, with t_0 \approx 1.7027 the positive root of g, is itself a root, since (it_0)^4 + 2i(it_0) - 5 = g(t_0) = 0.
  5. \displaystyle R = \frac{10 + 4\sqrt2}{3} \approx 5.219, and \displaystyle \frac32|z|^5 \le |p(z)| \le \frac92|z|^5 for |z| \ge R. Here |a_5| = 3 and \displaystyle S = 4 + 1 + |{-2} + 2i| = 5 + 2\sqrt2, so \displaystyle \frac{2S}{|a_5|} = \frac{10 + 4\sqrt2}{3} > 1.
  6. For \displaystyle t = |z| \ge 2 + 4\sqrt7, the reverse triangle inequality gives |p(z)| \ge t^2 - 4t - 8, and t^2 - 4t - 8 - 100 = (t - 2)^2 - 112 \ge 0 because \displaystyle t - 2 \ge 4\sqrt7 = \sqrt{112}. So |p(z)| \ge 100.
  7. f(z) = z^2 + z + 1. By Result 2 with s = 2, f = c_0 + c_1 z + c_2 z^2; then c_0 = 1, c_0 + c_1 + c_2 = 3 and c_0 - c_1 + c_2 = 1 give c_1 = c_2 = 1. It does satisfy the bound: |z^2 + z + 1| \le |z|^2 + |z| + 1, which is at most 2|z|^2 + 2 \le 5|z|^2 + 4 because \displaystyle |z| \le \frac{1 + |z|^2}{2}.
  8. By Result 2 with \displaystyle s = \frac32, f has degree at most \displaystyle \lfloor \frac32 \rfloor = 1, and f(0) = 0 gives f(z) = az. Then f(i) = 3 gives a = -3i, so |f(1)| = 3 > 2 = 2 \cdot 1^{3/2}, against the bound at z = 1.
  9. \displaystyle -\frac12. g(z) = f(z)e^{-2z} is entire with |g| \le 1, so it is constant, \displaystyle g = g(0) = \frac{i}{2}, and \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{i}{2}e^{2z}. Then \displaystyle f\left(\frac{\pi i}{4}\right) = \frac{i}{2}e^{\pi i/2} = \frac{i}{2} \cdot i = -\frac12.
  10. \displaystyle f(z) = \frac{3 - 3i}{2}z. By Result 2 with s = 1, f(z) = c_0 + c_1 z; |f(0)| \le 0 gives c_0 = 0, and f(2) = 3 - 3i gives \displaystyle c_1 = \frac{3 - 3i}{2}. Since \displaystyle |c_1| = \frac{3\sqrt2}{2} \approx 2.12 \le 3, this f satisfies the bound.
  11. Liouville’s theorem is about functions with a complex derivative at every point of \mathbb{C}. Real differentiability on \mathbb{R} gives no integral formula and no Cauchy estimate. The entire extension \sin z is unbounded: by Example 1, |\sin(iy)| = |\sinh y|.
  12. For |z| \ge 2, |1 + z^2| \ge |z|^2 - 1 \ge 3. The function is not entire: it is undefined at \pm i, and |1 + z^2| \to 0 as z \to i, so it is unbounded near i.
  13. The proof of Result 4 needs \displaystyle \frac{1}{p} to be bounded, which came from \displaystyle |p(z)| \ge \frac12|a_d||z|^d for large |z|. Nothing like this holds for e^{z}: |e^{-z}| = e^{-x} is unbounded as x \to -\infty, so Liouville’s theorem does not apply.
  14. Liouville’s theorem. The bound on \displaystyle \frac{1}{x^2 + 1} holds on \mathbb{R}, but a bounded real-differentiable function need not be constant. Over \mathbb{C}, \displaystyle \frac{1}{z^2 + 1} is not entire, exactly because z^2 + 1 has the roots \pm i.
  15. Proof. Since \operatorname{Im}\big(f(z) + i\big) \ge 1, |f(z) + i| \ge 1, so f + i never vanishes and \displaystyle g = \frac{1}{f + i} is entire with |g| \le 1. By Liouville’s theorem g is a constant, which is not 0, so \displaystyle f = \frac1g - i is constant. \blacksquare
  16. Proof. f - a never vanishes, so \displaystyle g = \frac{1}{f - a} is entire with \displaystyle |g| \le \frac{1}{\varepsilon}. By Liouville’s theorem g is a nonzero constant c, and \displaystyle f = a + \frac1c is constant. \blacksquare
  17. Proof. \displaystyle h = \frac{f}{g} is entire since g never vanishes, and |h| \le 1. By Liouville’s theorem h is a constant c, with |c| \le 1, and f = cg. \blacksquare
  18. Proof. Take \varepsilon = 1: |f| < 1 for |z| > R. On \overline{D}(0, R) the continuous |f| is bounded (The extreme value theorem). So f is bounded and, by Liouville’s theorem, a constant c. Then |c| < \varepsilon for every \varepsilon > 0, so c = 0. \blacksquare
  19. Proof. As vectors in \mathbb{R}^2, \omega_1 and \omega_2 are linearly independent, since \omega_2 = \lambda\omega_1 with \lambda real is excluded; so every z is s\omega_1 + t\omega_2 with s, t real. As in Example 5, f(z + m\omega_1 + n\omega_2) = f(z) for all integers m, n. The parallelogram P = \{s\omega_1 + t\omega_2 : 0 \le s, t \le 1\} is closed and bounded, so |f| \le M on P. Each z = s\omega_1 + t\omega_2 equals q + \lfloor s \rfloor\omega_1 + \lfloor t \rfloor\omega_2 with q \in P, so |f(z)| = |f(q)| \le M, and f is constant by Liouville’s theorem. \blacksquare
  20. Proof. f' is entire (Result 2 of Cauchy's integral formula) with |f'(z)| \le |z|, so by Result 2 with s = 1, f'(z) = b_0 + b_1 z. At z = 0, |b_0| \le 0, so b_0 = 0; then |b_1||z| \le |z| gives |b_1| \le 1. The entire function \displaystyle f(z) - \frac{b_1}{2}z^2 has derivative 0, so it is a constant a by Result 5 of Complex differentiability and the Cauchy-Riemann equations. With \displaystyle b = \frac{b_1}{2}, f(z) = a + bz^2 and \displaystyle |b| \le \frac12. \blacksquare
math.wiki · updated 2026-11-18 · CC-BY-SA-4.0