Quotient spaces, or gluing
The ends of a string can be tied into a loop, and the edges of a sheet taped into a tube. Once some points of a space are declared to be the same point, which sets should be open in what is left?
Where you are 6 in Topological spaces
Why this exists
Relations, equivalence classes and partitions turned a set into the set of its classes. Topology wants the classes to form a space: gluing the ends of [0, 1] should give the circle, and gluing opposite edges of a square a torus. In Continuous maps and homeomorphisms, Example 4, wrapping [0, 1) once around S^1 is a continuous bijection but not a homeomorphism, since points near 1 land near (1, 0) while the domain keeps them far from 0. Where Subspace and product topologies took the coarsest topology making given maps out of a space continuous, a quotient takes the finest topology making a given map into it continuous.
Definition
Throughout, X is a topological space.
Quotient topology. Let q : X \to Y be a surjection onto a set Y. The quotient topology induced by q is
A surjection q : X \to Y between spaces is a quotient map if, for every V \subseteq Y, V is open exactly when q^{-1}(V) is open; that is, Y carries \mathcal{T}_q.
Quotient space. Let \sim be an equivalence relation on X, with classes [x] and set of classes X / {\sim}. The quotient space is X / {\sim} with the quotient topology of q(x) = [x]: a set of classes is open exactly when their union is open in X.
Fibers and saturated sets. For q : X \to Y, the fiber over y is q^{-1}(\{y\}). A set U \subseteq X is saturated if U = q^{-1}(q(U)), that is, if U is a union of fibers; for X / {\sim}, a union of classes.
Gluing and collapsing. A list of identifications x_i \sim y_i means the equivalence relation they generate: the intersection of all equivalence relations on X containing the listed pairs, itself an equivalence relation, since reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity pass to intersections. For nonempty A \subseteq X, the space X / A is X / {\sim} for the relation whose classes are A and the sets \{x\} with x \notin A: A is collapsed to a point.
Intuition
An open set of the quotient is an open set of X that never splits a class, pushed down. In [0, 1] with 0 \sim 1, a small open set about the glued point must come from an open piece at each end, such as [0, a) \cup (1 - a, 1] (Figure 1, g as in Example 2). The set [0, a) alone is open in [0, 1] but not saturated, as it holds 0 and not 1, and its image is not open.
Results
Theorem 1 (the quotient topology). Let q : X \to Y be a surjection onto a set Y. (a) \mathcal{T}_q is a topology on Y, q is continuous for it, and it is the finest topology on Y for which q is continuous. (b) For a quotient map q, C \subseteq Y is closed if and only if q^{-1}(C) is closed in X.
Theorem 2 (saturated open sets). Let q : X \to Y be a quotient map. Then V \mapsto q^{-1}(V) is a bijection from the open sets of Y onto the saturated open sets of X, with inverse U \mapsto q(U). The same holds for closed sets.
Theorem 3 (maps out of a quotient). Let q : X \to Y be a quotient map and Z a space. (a) A function h : Y \to Z is continuous if and only if h \circ q is continuous. (b) If g : X \to Z is continuous and constant on each fiber of q, there is exactly one h : Y \to Z with h \circ q = g, and h is continuous.
Theorem 4 (recognizing quotient maps). (a) A continuous surjection that is open, or closed, is a quotient map. (b) A composite of quotient maps is a quotient map. (c) A homeomorphism is a quotient map, and a bijective quotient map is a homeomorphism.
Theorem 5 (identifying a quotient). Let g : X \to Z be a continuous surjection, and let x \sim x' mean g(x) = g(x'). Then h([x]) = g(x) defines a continuous bijection h : X / {\sim} \to Z, and h is a homeomorphism if and only if g is a quotient map. In particular, if g is open or closed, X / {\sim} \approx Z.
Theorem 6 (closed bounded domains). Let X \subseteq \mathbb{R}^m be closed and bounded and g : X \to \mathbb{R}^k continuous. Then g(C) is closed in \mathbb{R}^k for every C closed in X; so g : X \to g(X) is a closed map.
Theorem 7 (Hausdorff quotients). If X / {\sim} is Hausdorff (distinct points have disjoint neighborhoods, Hausdorff spaces and separation), every class is closed in X, and R = \{(x, x') \in X \times X : x \sim x'\} is closed in X \times X.
Why it is true
Theorem 1. Proof. (a) Preimages commute with unions, intersections and complements (Theorem 1 of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms), and q^{-1}(\varnothing) = \varnothing, q^{-1}(Y) = X, so the axioms for \mathcal{T}_q follow from those of X. Continuity of q is the definition. If q is continuous for \mathcal{T}' and V \in \mathcal{T}', then q^{-1}(V) is open, so V \in \mathcal{T}_q. (b) q^{-1}(Y \setminus C) = X \setminus q^{-1}(C). \square
Theorem 2. Proof. q^{-1}(V) is saturated, and q(q^{-1}(V)) = V because q is onto (Theorem 1 of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms). If U is saturated, q^{-1}(q(U)) = U, so by definition q(U) is open exactly when U is. For closed sets use Theorem 1(b). \square
Theorem 3. Proof. (a) (h \circ q)^{-1}(W) = q^{-1}(h^{-1}(W)), which is open exactly when h^{-1}(W) is open, as q is a quotient map. (b) Each fiber is nonempty, as q is onto, so h(y) = g(x) for any x with q(x) = y is defined, and the choice of x does not matter. Any h with h \circ q = g must take these values. It is continuous by (a). \square
Theorem 4. Proof. (a) Let q^{-1}(V) be open. If q is open, V = q(q^{-1}(V)) is open. If q is closed, q(X \setminus q^{-1}(V)) = Y \setminus V is closed. (b) For quotient maps q : X \to Y and r : Y \to Z, (r \circ q)^{-1}(W) = q^{-1}(r^{-1}(W)) is open if and only if r^{-1}(W) is, if and only if W is. (c) A homeomorphism is open, so (a) applies. If q is a bijective quotient map, every set is saturated, so q(U) is open for open U by Theorem 2, and q is a homeomorphism by Theorem 5(b) of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms. \square
Theorem 5. Proof. \sim is an equivalence relation whose classes are the fibers of g (Theorem 6 of Relations, equivalence classes and partitions). So g is constant on the fibers of q, and Theorem 3(b) gives a continuous h with h \circ q = g. It is onto because g is, and one to one because g(x) = g(x') means [x] = [x']. If h is a homeomorphism, g = h \circ q is a quotient map by Theorem 4(b) and (c). Conversely, let g be a quotient map and V open in X / {\sim}. As h is a bijection, g^{-1}(h(V)) = q^{-1}(h^{-1}(h(V))) = q^{-1}(V), which is open, so h(V) is open. Then h is an open continuous bijection, a homeomorphism (Theorem 5(b) of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms). The last sentence is Theorem 4(a). \square
Theorem 6. Proof. C = C' \cap X with C' closed in \mathbb{R}^m (Theorem 1(c) of Subspace and product topologies), so C is closed and bounded in \mathbb{R}^m. Let u \in \overline{g(C)}. Each ball \displaystyle B(u, \frac{1}{n}) meets g(C) (Theorem 3 of Closed sets, closure and limit points), say at g(c_n) with c_n \in C. The sequence (c_n) is bounded, so by Subsequences and Bolzano-Weierstrass, applied one coordinate at a time, a subsequence c_{n_j} converges to some c \in \mathbb{R}^m. If c \notin C, a ball about c misses the closed set C, yet holds c_{n_j} for large j; so c \in C. By continuity at c (Theorem 4 of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms), g(c_{n_j}) \to g(c), while \displaystyle \lVert g(c_{n_j}) - u \rVert < \frac{1}{n_j} gives g(c_{n_j}) \to u. Limits in \mathbb{R}^k are unique, so u = g(c) \in g(C). Hence g(C) is closed in \mathbb{R}^k, and g(C) = g(C) \cap g(X) is closed in g(X). \square
Theorem 7. Proof. A Hausdorff space is T_1 (Theorem 3(b) of Hausdorff spaces and separation), so \{[x]\} is closed, and so is q^{-1}(\{[x]\}) = [x] (Theorem 1(b)). Let (x, x') \notin R. Then [x] \ne [x'] have disjoint neighborhoods V, V', and W = q^{-1}(V) \times q^{-1}(V') is an open set containing (x, x'). If (z, z') \in W \cap R, then [z] = [z'] \in V \cap V', which is empty. So W misses R, and R is closed. \square
Worked examples
A quotient of a finite space
Let X = \{1, 2, 3, 4, 5\} have the topology with basis \{1\}, \{1, 2\}, \{3\}, \{4\}, \{4, 5\}, and glue it into the classes p = \{1, 5\}, r = \{2, 4\}, s = \{3\}. Find the topology of Y = X / {\sim}, and decide whether q is open and whether it is closed.
SolutionBy Theorem 2 the open sets of Y come from the saturated open sets of X, the open unions of classes. An open set containing 5 contains \{4, 5\}, and one containing 2 contains \{1, 2\}. So \{1, 5\}, \{2, 4\}, \{1, 3, 5\}, \{2, 3, 4\} are not open, while \{3\} and \{1, 2, 4, 5\} = \{1, 2\} \cup \{4, 5\} are. Hence
The set \{1\} is open but q(\{1\}) = \{p\} is not, so q is not open. The set \{2\} is closed, its complement \{1\} \cup \{3\} \cup \{4, 5\} being open, but q(\{2\}) = \{r\} is not closed, since \{p, s\} is not open. So the converse of Theorem 4(a) fails.
The circle as the line modulo the integers
Let p : \mathbb{R} \to S^1, p(s) = (\cos 2\pi s, \sin 2\pi s), and let s \sim t mean s - t \in \mathbb{Z}. Prove that \mathbb{R} / {\sim} \approx S^1, and that [0, 1] with 0 \sim 1 is homeomorphic to S^1.
SolutionProof. p is continuous, as its coordinates are, and onto (The unit circle). By \cos \alpha \cos \beta + \sin \alpha \sin \beta = \cos(\alpha - \beta), p(s) \cdot p(t) = \cos 2\pi(s - t), which equals 1 exactly when p(s) = p(t) and exactly when s - t \in \mathbb{Z}. So the fibers of p are the classes of \sim.
p is open. Let 0 < b - a < 1, \displaystyle m = \frac{a + b}{2} and \delta = \pi(b - a). A point p(s) lies in p((a, b)) when some s + n with n \in \mathbb{Z} is within \displaystyle \frac{b - a}{2} of m, that is, when the distance d from s - m to the nearest integer is below \displaystyle \frac{b - a}{2}. As \cos decreases on [0, \pi], this says \cos 2\pi d = \cos 2\pi(s - m) > \cos \delta, so
the preimage of (\cos \delta, \infty) under the continuous map u \mapsto u \cdot p(m), hence open. Every open set of \mathbb{R} is a union of intervals shorter than 1, and images preserve unions, so p is open. By Theorems 4(a) and 5, \mathbb{R} / {\sim} \approx S^1.
Now let g = p|_{[0, 1]}. Its fibers are \{0, 1\} and \{s\} for 0 < s < 1, the classes of 0 \sim 1. As [0, 1] is closed and bounded, g is closed by Theorem 6, a quotient map by Theorem 4(a), and [0, 1] / {\sim} \approx S^1 by Theorem 5. \square
The map g is not open: \displaystyle g([0, \frac{1}{2})) contains (1, 0) but no point with y < 0. Its restriction to [0, 1) is the bijection of Continuous maps and homeomorphisms, Example 4: a restriction of a quotient map need not be one.
Collapsing an interval of the line
(a) Prove that \mathbb{R} / [-1, 1] \approx \mathbb{R}. (b) Prove that \mathbb{R} / (-1, 1) is not Hausdorff.
Solution(a) Proof. Let g(x) = x + 1 for x \le -1, g(x) = 0 for -1 \le x \le 1, and g(x) = x - 1 for x \ge 1. The rules agree at \pm 1 and the pieces are closed, so g is continuous by the pasting lemma (Theorem 3(d) of Subspace and product topologies, applied twice). It is onto, with fibers [-1, 1] and single points. Let g^{-1}(V) be open and v \in V. If v > 0, some (v + 1 - \varepsilon, v + 1 + \varepsilon) with \varepsilon < v lies in g^{-1}(V), and its image (v - \varepsilon, v + \varepsilon) lies in V; v < 0 is symmetric. If v = 0, the open set g^{-1}(V) contains [-1, 1], hence some (-1 - \varepsilon, 1 + \varepsilon) (take the smaller of the radii about -1 and 1), whose image (-\varepsilon, \varepsilon) lies in V. So g is a quotient map, and Theorem 5 applies. \square
(b) Proof. Let m be the class (-1, 1). A saturated open set containing 1 contains some (1 - \varepsilon, 1 + \varepsilon), which meets (-1, 1), so it contains all of (-1, 1). Every neighborhood of [1] contains m, and the two cannot be separated. \square
As Theorem 7 predicts, the class (-1, 1) is not closed in \mathbb{R}.
A screen that wraps around
Malik is coding a spaceship game on the square screen [0, 1]^2. A ship leaving through the right edge at (1, y) reappears at (0, y), and one leaving through the top at (x, 1) reappears at (x, 0). So the screen is the quotient X of [0, 1]^2 by (0, y) \sim (1, y) and (x, 0) \sim (x, 1). (a) Prove that X \approx T^2 = S^1 \times S^1. (b) A ship leaves the corner at t = 0, moving 2 screen widths per second to the right and 3 up. Show that its path is continuous in X, and find the first t > 0 at which it is back at the corner.
Solution(a) Proof. The classes are: each interior point alone; \{(x, 0), (x, 1)\} and \{(0, y), (1, y)\} for 0 < x, y < 1; and the four corners, as (0, 0) \sim (1, 0) \sim (1, 1) \sim (0, 1). With p as in Example 2, let G(x, y) = (p(x), p(y)) \in \mathbb{R}^4, continuous (Theorem 5 of Subspace and product topologies) and onto T^2. On [0, 1], p(x) = p(x') exactly when x = x' or \{x, x'\} = \{0, 1\}, so the fibers of G are the classes. As [0, 1]^2 is closed and bounded, Theorems 6, 4(a) and 5 give a homeomorphism h : X \to T^2. \square
(b) The ship is at the class \gamma(t) of the point of the square that differs from (2t, 3t) by integers. As p has period 1, h(\gamma(t)) = (p(2t), p(3t)), which is continuous; so \gamma = h^{-1} \circ (h \circ \gamma) is continuous. The ship is at the corner when 2t and 3t are integers, and then so is t = 3t - 2t. The first return is at t = 1.
The mirror screen
Jin adds a mirror mode: a ship leaving through the right edge at (1, y) reappears at (0, 1 - y), and top and bottom are glued as before. The screen is the Klein bottle K, the quotient of [0, 1]^2 by (1, y) \sim (0, 1 - y) and (x, 0) \sim (x, 1) (Figure 2). (a) Find the class of the corner (0, 0). (b) A ship at (0.8, 0.3) moves with velocity (0.5, 0.1) per second. Where is it at t = 1? (c) Do \cos 2\pi y and \sin 2\pi y define continuous functions on K?
(a) (0, 0) \sim (0, 1) by the top and bottom, (1, 1) \sim (0, 0) and (1, 0) \sim (0, 1) by the mirror. So all four corners form one class.
(b) The ship reaches x = 1 when 0.8 + 0.5t = 1, at t = 0.4, at height 0.3 + 0.04 = 0.34, and reappears at (0, 0.66). Points just above (1, 0.34) are glued to points just below (0, 0.66), so its vertical motion is reversed: for 0.4 \le t \le 1 it is at (0.5(t - 0.4),\ 0.66 - 0.1(t - 0.4)). At t = 1 it is at (0.3, 0.60). The two pieces of the path are q composed with straight lines and agree at t = 0.4, since q(1, 0.34) = q(0, 0.66); by the pasting lemma the path is continuous.
(c) By Theorem 3(b), a continuous f on [0, 1]^2 defines one on K exactly when it is constant on classes. As \cos 2\pi(1 - y) = \cos 2\pi y and \cos 0 = \cos 2\pi, \cos 2\pi y does. But \sin 2\pi y is 1 at \displaystyle (1, \frac{1}{4}) and -1 at the glued point \displaystyle (0, \frac{3}{4}), so it defines no function on K.
The real projective line
Each line through the origin of \mathbb{R}^2 meets S^1 in two opposite points, so the real projective line is S^1 / {\sim} with u \sim -u. Prove that it is homeomorphic to S^1, using g(x, y) = (x^2 - y^2, 2xy).
SolutionProof. With p as in Example 2, the double angle formulas give g(p(s)) = (\cos 4\pi s, \sin 4\pi s) = p(2s). So g maps S^1 onto S^1, as \displaystyle p(t) = g(p(\frac{t}{2})), and it is continuous, its coordinates being polynomials. Now g(p(s)) = g(p(t)) means 2s - 2t \in \mathbb{Z}, that is, \displaystyle t = s + \frac{k}{2} with k \in \mathbb{Z}. As \displaystyle p(s + \frac{1}{2}) = -p(s), the fibers of g are the pairs \{u, -u\}. S^1 is closed and bounded, so Theorems 6, 4(a) and 5 give S^1 / {\sim} \approx S^1. \square
Boundaries
- Images of open sets. A quotient map carries saturated open sets to open sets (Theorem 2), but not all open sets (Examples 1 and 2).
- Restrictions. The restriction of a quotient map to a subspace need not be one (Example 2); to a saturated open subspace it is (Exercise 16).
- Separation. A quotient of a Hausdorff space need not be Hausdorff, or even T_1 (Example 3, Exercises 5 and 6), as the line with two origins of Hausdorff spaces and separation also shows.
- Theorem 6 needs a closed bounded domain. p : \mathbb{R} \to S^1 is not closed: \displaystyle C = \{n + \frac{1}{n} : n \ge 2\} is closed, but \displaystyle p(C) = \{p(\frac{1}{n}) : n \ge 2\} misses its limit point (1, 0).
Where this goes next
Compactness and open covers proves that a continuous map from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is closed, which with Compactness in products and the Heine-Borel theorem contains Theorem 6. Classification of surfaces builds every closed surface by gluing the edges of a polygon, as Malik’s torus is the square with edge word a b a^{-1} b^{-1}. The map p of Example 2 returns in The fundamental group of the circle, where paths in S^1 are lifted to \mathbb{R}.
Exercises
Small quotients
- Let X = \{a, b, c, d\} have the open sets \varnothing, \{a\}, \{c\}, \{a, b\}, \{a, c\}, \{a, b, c\}, X. Find the quotient topology for the classes (a) \{a, d\}, \{b\}, \{c\}; (b) \{a, b\}, \{c, d\}. Is q open in either case?
- Give \{0, 1\} the quotient topology of q : \mathbb{R} \to \{0, 1\}, where q(x) = 1 exactly when (a) x > 0; (b) x \ge 0; (c) x \in \mathbb{Q}. Which of the three spaces are homeomorphic?
The line and the plane
- On \mathbb{R} let x \sim -x. Prove that \mathbb{R} / {\sim} \approx [0, \infty), using g(x) = |x|.
- Let E be the union of the circles of radius 1 about (-1, 0) and (1, 0). Show that [0, 2] / \{0, 1, 2\} \approx E, using g(t) = (-1 + \cos 2\pi t, \sin 2\pi t) on [0, 1] and g(t) = (1 - \cos 2\pi t, \sin 2\pi t) on [1, 2].
- On \mathbb{R} let x \sim y mean x - y \in \mathbb{Q}. Prove that \mathbb{R} / {\sim} is indiscrete.
- (a) Show that \mathbb{R} / \mathbb{Q} is not Hausdorff. (b) List the open sets of [0, 1] / (0, 1), and decide whether it is T_1.
Gluing the screen
- Malik’s third mode glues (0, y) \sim (1, 1 - y) and (x, 0) \sim (1 - x, 1), the projective plane \mathbb{RP}^2: a ship leaving the top at (x, 1) reappears at (1 - x, 0) with its horizontal motion reversed. A ship at (0.6, 0.85) moves with velocity (0.1, 0.25) per second. Where is it at t = 1?
- In the gluing of Exercise 7, find the classes of the four corners.
- The Möbius band is M = [0, 1]^2 / {\sim} with (0, y) \sim (1, 1 - y). Which of these define continuous functions on M? (a) \displaystyle (y - \frac{1}{2})\cos 2\pi x; (b) \displaystyle (y - \frac{1}{2})^2; (c) y \sin \pi x; (d) x.
Identifying quotients
- On S^1 let (x, y) \sim (x, -y). Prove that S^1 / {\sim} \approx [-1, 1].
- Let T be the triangle with vertices (0, 0), (1, 0), \displaystyle (\frac{1}{2}, 1). Prove that [0, 1]^2 / ([0, 1] \times \{1\}) \approx T, using \displaystyle g(x, y) = ((1 - y)x + \frac{y}{2}, y).
Proofs
- Prove that every quotient of a discrete space is discrete, and every quotient of an indiscrete space is indiscrete.
- Let q : X \to Y be continuous, and let s : Y \to X be continuous with q \circ s = \mathrm{id}_Y. Prove that q is a quotient map. Deduce that \mathrm{pr}_1 : X \times Y \to X is a quotient map when Y \ne \varnothing.
- Prove that X / {\sim} is T_1 (points are closed) if and only if every class is closed in X.
- Let f : X \to X' be continuous, and \sim, \sim' equivalence relations on X, X' with f(x) \sim' f(y) whenever x \sim y. Prove that F([x]) = [f(x)] is a well defined continuous map X / {\sim} \to X' / {\sim'}.
- Let q : X \to Y be a quotient map and A \subseteq X saturated and open. Prove that q|_A : A \to q(A) is a quotient map.
Answers
- (a) Of the unions of classes only \varnothing, \{c\}, X are open: \mathcal{T}_q = \{\varnothing, \{[c]\}, Y\}. (b) \{a, b\} is open, \{c, d\} is not: \mathcal{T}_q = \{\varnothing, \{[a]\}, Y\}. Neither q is open: in (a) q(\{a\}) = \{[a]\}, in (b) q(\{c\}) = \{[c]\}.
- (a) q^{-1}(\{1\}) = (0, \infty) is open and q^{-1}(\{0\}) = (-\infty, 0] is not: \{\varnothing, \{1\}, \{0, 1\}\}. (b) \{\varnothing, \{0\}, \{0, 1\}\}. (c) Neither \mathbb{Q} nor \mathbb{R} \setminus \mathbb{Q} is open: indiscrete. (a) and (b) are homeomorphic by swapping 0 and 1; (c) has fewer open sets.
- g is continuous and onto, with fibers \{x, -x\}. It is open: g((a, b)) = (a, b) if 0 \le a, (-b, -a) if b \le 0, and [0, \max\{-a, b\}), open in [0, \infty), if a < 0 < b. Theorems 4(a) and 5 finish. \square
- Both rules give (0, 0) at t = 1, so g is continuous by the pasting lemma, and (x + 1)^2 + y^2 = 1, (x - 1)^2 + y^2 = 1 hold on the two pieces. The left circle has x \le 0, the right x \ge 0, meeting only at (0, 0), and each rule is one to one on (0, 1) or (1, 2) (Example 2). So the fibers are \{0, 1, 2\} and single points, and Theorems 6, 4(a), 5 apply. \square
- Let U be a nonempty saturated open set, with (a, b) \subseteq U. For any x, a rational r lies in (a - x, b - x), so x + r \in U and x \sim x + r; as U is saturated, x \in U. So U = \mathbb{R}. \square
- (a) The class \mathbb{Q} is not closed in \mathbb{R}; apply Theorem 7. (b) With a = [0], m = [(0, 1)], b = [1], the saturated open sets are \varnothing, (0, 1), [0, 1), (0, 1], [0, 1]: the open sets are \varnothing, \{m\}, \{a, m\}, \{m, b\}, Y. Not T_1: \{m\} is not closed, matching Exercise 14.
- It reaches the top when 0.85 + 0.25t = 1, at t = 0.6, at x = 0.66. It reappears at (0.34, 0) with velocity (-0.1, 0.25), and at t = 1 it is at (0.30, 0.10).
- (0, 0) \sim (1, 1) by both rules, and (1, 0) \sim (0, 1) by both. The classes are \{(0, 0), (1, 1)\} and \{(1, 0), (0, 1)\}.
- A function descends when f(0, y) = f(1, 1 - y) (Theorem 3(b)). (a) No: \displaystyle y - \frac{1}{2} against \displaystyle \frac{1}{2} - y. (b) Yes. (c) Yes: both sides are 0. (d) No: 0 \ne 1.
- g(x, y) = x is continuous from S^1 onto [-1, 1] with fibers \{(x, y), (x, -y)\}; S^1 is closed and bounded, so Theorems 6, 4(a), 5 apply. \square
- g is continuous. For y < 1 its first coordinate is strictly increasing in x (slope 1 - y > 0), with range \displaystyle [\frac{y}{2}, 1 - \frac{y}{2}], the slice of T at height y; for y = 1, g is constant, \displaystyle (\frac{1}{2}, 1). So g maps onto T with fibers the top edge and single points, and Theorems 6, 4(a), 5 apply. \square
- If X is discrete, every preimage is open, so every subset of the quotient is open. If X is indiscrete, q^{-1}(V) is open only when it is \varnothing or X, so V = \varnothing or V = Y, as q is onto. \square
- q is onto, since q(s(y)) = y. If q^{-1}(V) is open, then V = s^{-1}(q^{-1}(V)) is open, as q(s(y)) \in V exactly when y \in V. For \mathrm{pr}_1, fix y_0 \in Y and take s(x) = (x, y_0), continuous by Theorem 5 of Subspace and product topologies. \square
- \{[x]\} is closed in X / {\sim} exactly when q^{-1}(\{[x]\}) = [x] is closed in X (Theorem 1(b)). \square
- If [x] = [y], then f(x) \sim' f(y), so F is well defined. F \circ q = q' \circ f is continuous, so F is continuous by Theorem 3(a). \square
- q|_A maps onto q(A), which is open by Theorem 2, and is continuous by Theorem 3(b) and (c) of Subspace and product topologies. Let V \subseteq q(A) with (q|_A)^{-1}(V) = q^{-1}(V) \cap A open in A, hence in X. Since A is saturated and V \subseteq q(A), q^{-1}(V) \subseteq A, so q^{-1}(V) is open, V is open in Y, and hence in q(A). \square